<?xml version="1.0"?>
<iati-activities version="2.03" generated-datetime="2026-11-16T08:38:56+00:00"><!--Generated By AidStream-->  <iati-activity last-updated-datetime="2022-06-24T12:55:49+00:00" xml:lang="en" default-currency="CHF" humanitarian="0" hierarchy="1" linked-data-uri="">    <iati-identifier>CH-FDJP-109458452-CH-FDJP-109458452</iati-identifier>    <reporting-org type="60" ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" secondary-reporter="0">      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>    </reporting-org>    <title>      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence Sector Reform Programme in the Republic of North Macedonia</narrative>    </title>    <description type="1">      <narrative xml:lang="en">The DCAF Intelligence Sector Reform Programme (Programme) is a multi-donor funding instrument established in 2017 to finance DCAF supported engagement in the Republic of North Macedonia. The aim is to make an effective and sustainable contribution toward improved security and intelligence sector accountability and governance.</narrative>    </description>    <description type="2">      <narrative xml:lang="en">The Programme is designed to provide long-term engagement with national authorities and partner organizations involved in security sector reform, focusing in particular on strengthening intelligence governance in order to increase the capacity of the Macedonian state to fulfil its responsibility to protect human rights and individual liberties and ensure the respect for European norms and standards in this field. Support is provided in three areas: legislative and institutional reforms, development of parliamentary and independent oversight, and development of judicial and prosecutorial standards and capacity for authorization and review of special investigative methods.</narrative>    </description>    <description type="3">      <narrative xml:lang="en">The target groups are as follows: Government security and intelligence stakeholders; The Parliament of the Republic of North Macedonia (Intelligence-, Security- and Defense Committee Members and staff) and related independent oversight institutions (such as the Ombuds institution, Directorate for Data Protection); all relevant stakeholders within the judicial branch involved in the control of the use of special investigative methods by security services.</narrative>    </description>    <description type="4">      <narrative>The Government of North Macedonia has expressed a commitment to undertake reforms and address deficiencies in the area of intelligence governance, focusing in particular on ensuring effective control and oversight over the system of telecommunication interceptions, in order to strengthen the rule of law and ensure the respect for human rights in line with European norms and standards. The reforms aim to implement the recommendations of the Group of Independent Senior Rule of Law Experts which was mandated by the European Commission. The recommendation emphasized the interception of communications, judiciary and prosecution services, and external oversight bodies as &#x201C;three main areas where urgent action was most needed. The Programme aims to provide support to the Government, while fostering greater donor coordination, which is key to providing effective support to local security sector reform processes. A Donor Steering Group helps provide strategic guidance to DCAF for the implementation of the Programme. All DCAF activities within the Programme are ODA eligible.</narrative>    </description>    <participating-org ref="XM-DAC-7" type="10" role="1" activity-id="4000000892">      <narrative xml:lang="en">Netherlands - Ministry of Foreign Affairs</narrative>    </participating-org>    <participating-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" type="60" role="2" activity-id="548000">      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>    </participating-org>    <participating-org ref="SE-0" type="10" role="1" activity-id="11965">      <narrative xml:lang="en">Sweden, through Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency (Sida)</narrative>    </participating-org>    <participating-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" type="60" role="4" activity-id="548000">      <narrative xml:lang="en">Geneva Centre for the Democratic Control of Armed Forces (DCAF)</narrative>    </participating-org>    <participating-org ref="CH-4" type="10" role="1">      <narrative xml:lang="en">Switzerland - Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (SDC)</narrative>    </participating-org>    <participating-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" type="60" role="1">      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>    </participating-org>    <activity-status code="4"/>    <activity-date type="1" iso-date="2017-10-01">      <narrative xml:lang="en">Planned start date</narrative>    </activity-date>    <activity-date type="2" iso-date="2017-11-01">      <narrative xml:lang="en">The activity is currently being implemented</narrative>    </activity-date>    <activity-date type="3" iso-date="2021-08-31">      <narrative xml:lang="en">5 month Budget Neutral extension  </narrative>    </activity-date>    <activity-scope code="4"/>    <recipient-country code="MK" percentage="100">      <narrative xml:lang="en">THe beneficiary of the Programme is Macedonia (The Former Yugoslav Republic of)</narrative>    </recipient-country>    <sector code="15210" percentage="100" vocabulary="1">      <narrative xml:lang="en">Technical co-operation provided to parliament, government ministries, law enforcement agencies and the judiciary to assist review and reform of the security system to improve democratic governance and civilian control; technical co-operation provided to government to improve civilian oversight and democratic control of budgeting, management, accountability and auditing of security expenditure, including military budgets, as part of a public expenditure management programme; assistance to civil society to enhance its competence and capacity to scrutinise the security system so that it is managed in accordance with democratic norms and principles of accountability, transparency and good governance. [Other than in the context of an international peacekeeping operation.</narrative>    </sector>    <budget type="1" status="2">      <period-start iso-date="2017-11-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2017-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2017-10-17">35496</value>    </budget>    <budget type="1" status="2">      <period-start iso-date="2018-01-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2018-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2018-01-01">534465</value>    </budget>    <budget type="2" status="2">      <period-start iso-date="2019-01-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2019-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2019-12-31">678204</value>    </budget>    <budget type="2" status="2">      <period-start iso-date="2020-01-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2020-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2020-01-01">716243</value>    </budget>    <budget type="2" status="2">      <period-start iso-date="2020-01-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2020-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2020-03-27">835030</value>    </budget>    <planned-disbursement type="1">      <period-start iso-date="2017-10-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2018-09-30"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2017-11-15">224044</value>      <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="4000000892" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">First Installment Year 1</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">First Installment Year 1 - Intelligence Sector Reform Programme in the Republic of North Macedonia (2017-2020)</narrative>      </receiver-org>    </planned-disbursement>    <planned-disbursement type="2">      <period-start iso-date="2018-10-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2019-09-30"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2018-12-06">113916</value>      <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="4000000892" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Second Installment Year II</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative>Second Installment Year II - Intelligence Sector Reform Programme in the Republic of North Macedonia (2017-2020)</narrative>      </receiver-org>    </planned-disbursement>    <planned-disbursement type="2">      <period-start iso-date="2019-10-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2020-09-30"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2020-01-14">60948</value>      <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="4000000892" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Remaining funds from second installment (total for Year 2 CHF 174'864)</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Remaining funds from second installment (total for Year 2 CHF 174'864)</narrative>      </receiver-org>    </planned-disbursement>    <planned-disbursement type="1">      <period-start iso-date="2019-10-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2020-09-30"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2020-01-14">120219</value>      <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="4000000892" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Third Installment Year III</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Third Installment Year III</narrative>      </receiver-org>    </planned-disbursement>    <planned-disbursement type="1">      <period-start iso-date="2020-10-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2020-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-05-01">27322</value>      <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="4000000892" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Final Payment (max) as per contract</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Final Payment</narrative>      </receiver-org>    </planned-disbursement>    <planned-disbursement type="1">      <period-start iso-date="2018-06-26"/>      <period-end iso-date="2018-12-31"/>      <value currency="SEK" value-date="2020-01-14">1500000</value>      <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="11965" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">First Installment from Sida Year 1 FY2018</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">First Installment received upon signature of contract</narrative>      </receiver-org>    </planned-disbursement>    <planned-disbursement type="1">      <period-start iso-date="2019-01-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2019-12-31"/>      <value currency="SEK" value-date="2019-06-26">1500000</value>      <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="11965" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Year 2 - FY 2019 (upon approval of annual work plan and budget (FY2019) and upon approval of annual reporting and annual audit (FY2018)</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Year 2 - FY 2019 (upon approval of annual work plan and budget (FY2019) and upon approval of annual reporting and annual audit (FY2018)</narrative>      </receiver-org>    </planned-disbursement>    <planned-disbursement type="1">      <period-start iso-date="2020-01-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2020-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2020-02-28">750000</value>      <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="11965" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Year 3 - FY2020 - upon approval of annual work plan and annual budget</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Year 3 - FY2020 - upon approval of annual work plan and annual budget</narrative>      </receiver-org>    </planned-disbursement>    <planned-disbursement type="1">      <period-start iso-date="2020-01-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2020-12-31"/>      <value currency="SEK" value-date="2020-05-01">600000</value>      <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="11965" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Year 3 - FY2020 upon approval of annual reporting and annual audit</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Year 3 - FY2020 upon approval of annual reporting and annual audit</narrative>      </receiver-org>    </planned-disbursement>    <planned-disbursement type="1">      <period-start iso-date="2020-01-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2020-12-31"/>      <value currency="SEK" value-date="2020-05-01">150000</value>      <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="11965" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Year 4 - FY 2021 - Final Payment upon approval of final report and annual audit</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Final Payment from Sida</narrative>      </receiver-org>    </planned-disbursement>    <planned-disbursement type="1">      <period-start iso-date="2017-09-20"/>      <period-end iso-date="2020-02-28"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2018-10-25">350000</value>      <provider-org ref="CH-4" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">First installment (CHF 170000) and second installment (CHF 180000)</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">First installment (CHF 170000) upon signing contract and second installment (CHF 180000) during month of October as per contract 81056699</narrative>      </receiver-org>    </planned-disbursement>    <planned-disbursement type="1">      <period-start iso-date="2020-03-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2020-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2020-03-01">100000</value>      <provider-org ref="CH-4" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Third installment after approval by FDFA of narrative and financial report</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Third installment from SDC</narrative>      </receiver-org>    </planned-disbursement>    <planned-disbursement type="1">      <period-start iso-date="2020-03-01"/>      <period-end iso-date="2020-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-05-01">50000</value>      <provider-org ref="CH-4" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">final max payment after approval of operational and financial report</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">final max payment after approval of operational and financial report bu SDC</narrative>      </receiver-org>    </planned-disbursement>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="1"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2020-02-18"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2020-02-17">181167</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Third Installment as per Disbursement Request</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Netherlands" provider-activity-id="XM-DAC-7" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Stabilization and Humanitarian Aid Department</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="DCAF" type="60"/>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="1"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2018-12-06"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2018-12-06">113916</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Second installment</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="4000000892" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Stabilisation and Humanitarian Aid Department</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60"/>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="1"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2017-11-15"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2017-11-15">224044</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Installment for Year One</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="4000000892" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Installment for Year one</narrative>      </provider-org>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="1"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2018-07-19"/>      <value currency="SEK" value-date="2017-07-19">1500000</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Funds received for first year</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="11965" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>      </receiver-org>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="1"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2019-06-25"/>      <value currency="SEK" value-date="2019-06-25">1500000</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Second Installment</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="11965" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida</narrative>      </provider-org>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="1"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2019-12-17"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2020-02-17">181167</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Third Installment as per Disbursement Request</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Netherlands" provider-activity-id="XM-DAC-7" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Stabilization and Humanitarian Aid Department</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60"/>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="1"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2020-04-03"/>      <value currency="SEK" value-date="2020-05-12">750000</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Request for Q1 (following approval of the annual work plan and budget)</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="11965" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>      </receiver-org>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="4"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2019-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2019-12-31">76885</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period Jan - December 2019</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="4000000892" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Netherlands (Stabilisation and Humanitarian Aid Department)</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative>DCAF</narrative>      </receiver-org>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="4"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2018-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2018-12-31">89513.77</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period Sept - December 2018</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81056699" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">SDC</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>      </receiver-org>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="4"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2018-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2018-12-31">90400</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period June - December 2018</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="11965" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60"/>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="1"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2020-05-08"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2020-05-18">100000</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Third Installment</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81056699" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">SDC</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>      </receiver-org>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="1"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2018-11-09"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2018-11-09">180000</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">First Installment</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81056699" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">as per contract</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>      </receiver-org>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="1"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2018-11-13"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2018-11-13">170000</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">second installment</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81056699" type="10">        <narrative>SDC</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">second installment</narrative>      </receiver-org>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="4"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2018-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2018-12-31">218098.98</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenses incurred for period 1 Nov 2017 - 31 December 2018</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="4000000892" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Amount Spent per Donor NL - Amount spent CHF 218'098.98</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>      </receiver-org>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="4"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2019-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2019-12-31">179994</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period Jan-Dec 2019</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="11965" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>      </receiver-org>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="4"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2020-01-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2019-12-31">180393</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period Jan-Dec 2019</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81056699" type="10">        <narrative>SDC</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60">        <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>      </receiver-org>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="4"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2021-08-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-08-31">90842.08</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period Jan - August 2021</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="11965" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60"/>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="1"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2020-11-13"/>      <value currency="SEK" value-date="2020-11-13">600000</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Year 3 &#x2013; FY2020 (2Q)</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="11965" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida contribution for Intelligence Sector Reform Programme  in North Macedonia</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60"/>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="4"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2020-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2020-12-31">126500.50</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period Jan - Dec 2020. </narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="4000000892" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Netherlands</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60"/>      <disbursement-channel code="1"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="4"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2020-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2020-12-31">100562.91</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period Jan - Dec 2020 . Sida contribution</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="11965" type="10"/>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60"/>      <disbursement-channel code="1"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="4"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2020-12-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2020-12-31">117750.59</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period Jan - Dec 2020 . SDC contribution </narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="CH-4" type="10">        <narrative xml:lang="en">SDC</narrative>      </provider-org>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60"/>      <disbursement-channel code="1"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="4"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2021-08-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-08-31">103283.37</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Expendire for period Jan - August 2021</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="DSH-4000000892" type="10"/>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60"/>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <transaction humanitarian="0">      <transaction-type code="4"/>      <transaction-date iso-date="2021-08-31"/>      <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-08-31">94502.76</value>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure Jan-August 2021</narrative>      </description>      <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81056699" type="10"/>      <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548000" type="60"/>      <disbursement-channel code="2"/>      <flow-type code="10"/>      <finance-type code="110"/>      <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>      <tied-status code="5"/>    </transaction>    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/factsheet_intelligence-sector-reform-programme_11-20180716090708.06.2018.pdf" format="application/pdf">      <title>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Programme Factsheet</narrative>      </title>      <category code="A02"/>      <language code="en"/>      <document-date iso-date="2018-06-15"/>    </document-link>    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/DCAF-Exclusion-Policy-20180814090838.pdf" format="application/pdf">      <title>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Exclusion Policy</narrative>      </title>      <category code="B08"/>      <language code="en"/>      <document-date iso-date="2018-05-02"/>    </document-link>    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/190131_DCAF-PFNMK-Results-Framework-20190424070437.pdf" format="application/pdf">      <title>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Pooled Fund Result Framework - Intelligence Sector Reform Programme in the Republic of Norht Macedonia 2017-2020</narrative>      </title>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Result Framework - Annex to the main the Programmme Document.</narrative>      </description>      <category code="A08"/>      <language code="en"/>      <document-date iso-date="2019-01-31"/>    </document-link>    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/PFMK-Results-for-period-Nov-2017-31-Dec-2018-20190424070403.pdf" format="application/pdf">      <title>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Results for period Nov 2017 - 31 Dec 2018</narrative>      </title>      <description>        <narrative>Listed in this table are main results achieved under the Intelligence Sector Reform Programme in the Republic of North Macedonia during the period Nov 2017 - 31 December 2018.</narrative>      </description>      <category code="A08"/>      <language code="en"/>      <document-date iso-date="2018-12-31"/>    </document-link>    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/PFMK_CII_Newsletter-No1_Sep2018-(final)-as-of-5-Nov_revised-name-NorthFV-20190425120449.pdf" format="application/pdf">      <title>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter No.1 Nov 2017 - Sept 2018</narrative>      </title>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Activities organised in support of the Parliament of the Republic of North Macedonia during the period Nov 2017 - Sept 2018</narrative>      </description>      <category code="A08"/>      <language code="en"/>      <document-date iso-date="2019-01-31"/>    </document-link>    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/Annex-1_180509-Theory-of-Change-Intelligence-sector-reform-20190507030526.pdf" format="application/pdf">      <title>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Theory of Change - Intelligence Sector Reform Programme in the Republic of North Macedonia</narrative>      </title>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Theory of Change</narrative>      </description>      <category code="A08"/>      <language code="en"/>      <document-date iso-date="2017-10-10"/>    </document-link>    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/Macedonia_Newsletter_Oriana_ENG_FV-20200117010137.pdf" format="application/pdf">      <title>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter No 2 January to June 2019</narrative>      </title>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter includes information on activities and results achieved during this period.</narrative>      </description>      <category code="A08"/>      <language code="en"/>      <document-date iso-date="2019-06-30"/>    </document-link>    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/Macedonia_Newsletter_EN_JulySept2019-20200117020155.pdf" format="application/pdf">      <title>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter No 3 for period July - September 2019</narrative>      </title>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">The Newsletter includes information on activities and results achieved during the period July to September 2019.</narrative>      </description>      <category code="A08"/>      <language code="en"/>      <document-date iso-date="2019-09-30"/>    </document-link>    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/Macedonia_Newsletter_EN_OctDec2019--20200117030107.pdf" format="application/pdf">      <title>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter No. 4 Oct - December 2019</narrative>      </title>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter contains information on activities and achieved results during period October to December 2019</narrative>      </description>      <category code="A08"/>      <language code="en"/>      <document-date iso-date="2019-12-31"/>    </document-link>    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/PFMK_DCAF_Factsheet_2019_PRINT-20200117030130.pdf" format="application/pdf">      <title>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Factsheet on Intelligence Sector Reform Programme in the Republic of North Macedonia (2017-2020)</narrative>      </title>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Factsheet with key achievements for the Programme since its inception until December 2019</narrative>      </description>      <category code="A02"/>      <language code="en"/>      <document-date iso-date="2020-12-11"/>    </document-link>    <result type="1" aggregation-status="1">      <title>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Mid-Year Report Jan-June 2020</narrative>      </title>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">This reporting was heavily influenced by the outbreak of COVID-19. This global health crisis posed a challenge to the implementation of activities within the Programme. However, in line with measures taken in Switzerland and North Macedonia, DCAF remained operational but had to adapt to the situation. Consequently, some activities were cancelled or moved to an online platform, others were postponed. Working online allowed for funding to be freed for new activities. Furthermore, this period void of travels was an opportunity for the team to invest more in research and legal analysis.</narrative>      </description>      <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/DCAF_MidYear-Report_-JUNE2020-20200714090701.pdf" format="application/pdf">        <title>          <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF Mid-Year Report Jan-June 2020</narrative>        </title>        <category code="A08"/>        <language code="en"/>      </document-link>      <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">        <title>          <narrative xml:lang="en">The reforms in the Intelligence Sector in the Republic of North Macedonia continue with a slow pace during this period.</narrative>        </title>        <period>          <period-start iso-date="2020-01-01"/>          <period-end iso-date="2020-06-30"/>        </period>      </indicator>    </result>    <result type="2" aggregation-status="1">      <title>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Performance for 2019 according to Result Framework</narrative>      </title>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Progress made in 2019 in North Macedonia</narrative>      </description>      <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/PERFORMANCE-ACCORDING-TO-IMPLEMENTATION-PLAN-2019-20200714090708.pdf" format="application/pdf">        <title>          <narrative xml:lang="en">Performance according to implementation plan in 2019</narrative>        </title>        <category code="A08"/>      </document-link>      <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">        <title>          <narrative xml:lang="en">International standards and good practices in intelligence oversight are integrated in the work of the Parliament.</narrative>        </title>        <description>          <narrative xml:lang="en">- 22 members of parliament, 6 parliamentary staffers, representing 6 political parties and 4 parliamentary committees, participated in 13 capacity building activities designed to improve their understanding, skills, and knowledge of security and intelligence governance, accountability and oversight and enable them to perform more effectively. - On average, 45% of the participants of these activities were women - The three intelligence oversight committees and the Council for Citizen&#x2019;s Supervision conducted 12 oversight activities in 2019.</narrative>        </description>        <period>          <period-start iso-date="2019-01-01"/>          <period-end iso-date="2020-12-31"/>        </period>      </indicator>    </result>    <result type="2" aggregation-status="1">      <title>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Performance 2018 according to Result Framework</narrative>      </title>      <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/PERFORMANCE-2018-ACCORDING-TO-RESULT-FRAMEWORK-20200714100710.pdf" format="application/pdf">        <title>          <narrative xml:lang="en">2018 Performance</narrative>        </title>        <category code="A08"/>      </document-link>      <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">        <title>          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Benchbook is used on a regular basis as a reference guide by judges and prosecutors in decision making on warrant requests</narrative>        </title>        <description>          <narrative xml:lang="en">During this reporting period a framework for sustained, systematic exchanges within the Macedonian judiciary on the standards that should apply in judicial supervision of intrusive methods was created</narrative>        </description>        <period>          <period-start iso-date="2017-11-01"/>          <period-end iso-date="2018-12-31"/>        </period>      </indicator>    </result>    <result type="1" aggregation-status="1">      <title>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter Jan - March 2021</narrative>      </title>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Activities and results achieved during period Jan - March 2021</narrative>      </description>      <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter_EN_JAN-MAR_2021-20210603080645.pdf" format="application/pdf">        <title>          <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter Jan - March 2021 describes the activities implemented during this period and results achieved. </narrative>        </title>        <category code="A08"/>        <language code="en"/>        <document-date iso-date="2021-03-31"/>      </document-link>      <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">        <title>          <narrative xml:lang="en">Laws and bi-laws on intelligence are reviewed, amended and/or replaced and increasingly aligned with ECHR jurisprudence</narrative>        </title>        <description>          <narrative xml:lang="en">In March the Common Minimum Standards (CMS) for&#xD;Conducting Control and Oversight Visits in Security&#xD;and Intelligence Institutions in the Republic of&#xD;North Macedonia was published in Macedonian,&#xD;Albanian and English.Both analysis papers reflect on the current&#xD;state of play of the laws and their practical&#xD;implementation. The papers point out the main&#xD;challenges which come as a result of inconsistent&#xD;and imprecise legal provisions. Special emphasis&#xD;is put on the provisions that do not fully serve&#xD;the reform priorities and the segments that do&#xD;not correspond to international legal documents&#xD;and the practice of European courts. The analyses&#xD;offer alternative solutions and concrete recommendations&#xD;to overcome the evident weaknesses&#xD;in some existing legal provisions.</narrative>        </description>        <baseline year="2017" iso-date="2017-11-01"/>        <period>          <period-start iso-date="2021-01-01"/>          <period-end iso-date="2021-03-31"/>        </period>      </indicator>    </result>    <result type="2" aggregation-status="1">      <title>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Final Performance Results Nov 2017 - August 2021</narrative>      </title>      <description>        <narrative xml:lang="en">Final Results achieved on outputs to outcome level</narrative>      </description>      <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/PERFORMANCE-RESULTS-NOV-2017---AUG-2021-20211014101027.pdf" format="application/pdf">        <title>          <narrative xml:lang="en">Performance Result - Intelligence Sector Reform Programme in North Macedonia </narrative>        </title>        <category code="A08"/>        <language code="en"/>        <document-date iso-date="2021-08-31"/>      </document-link>      <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">        <title>          <narrative xml:lang="en">Laws and by-laws on intelligence are reviewed, amended and/or replaced and increasingly aligned with ECHR jurisprudence.&#xD;&#xD;</narrative>        </title>        <description>          <narrative xml:lang="en">&#x2022;The Law on Interception of Communications (LIC), adopted by the Parliament of Republic of North Macedonia in mid-April 2018, including with a number of DCAF proposed amendments; &#xD;&#x2022;The Operational-Technical Agency (OTA) was set up and started operating on 1 November 2018. The OTA serves as a mediator in the communication interception process;&#xD;&#x2022;In May 2019, the law on the new National Security Agency (NSA) was adopted by a two-thirds majority in the Parliament of North Macedonia and included a number of DCAF proposed amendments; &#xD;&#x2022;In May 2019 Law on Coordination of Security and Intelligence Community in North Macedonia was adopted by a Parliament of North Macedonia;&#xD;&#x2022;The National Security Agency became operational on 1 September 2019 replacing the stigmatized UBK;&#xD;&#x2022;The new Law on Intelligence Agency was adopted by the Parliament of North Macedonia on 25 January 2021;In March 2021, Common Minimum Standards (CMS) for Conducting Control and Oversight Visits in Security and Intelligence Institutions in the Republic of North Macedonia (Link) was published in Macedonian, Albanian and English. The CMS document is a joint roadmap that gathers necessary minimum standards, principles, and procedures prescribed in domestic legislation and international good practice, to help facilitate more effective control and oversight visits and activities. Analysis of the Law on the Operational Technical Agency and the Law on Interception of Communications (Link) and the Analysis of the Law on the National Security Agency and Law for Coordination of the Security and Intelligence Community in the Republic of North Macedonia (Link) published in Macedonian, Albanian and English. Both analyses reflect on the current state of play of the laws and their practical implementation and offer alternative solutions and concrete recommendations to overcome the evident weaknesses in some existing legal provisions.&#xD;</narrative>        </description>        <baseline year="2017" iso-date="2017-10-01">          <location ref="North Macedonia"/>        </baseline>        <period>          <period-start iso-date="2017-11-01"/>          <period-end iso-date="2021-08-31"/>        </period>      </indicator>    </result>  </iati-activity>
<iati-activity last-updated-datetime="2026-11-16T08:38:54+00:00" xml:lang="en" default-currency="CHF" humanitarian="0" hierarchy="1" linked-data-uri="">
  <iati-identifier>CH-FDJP-109458452-400004197</iati-identifier>
  <reporting-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" secondary-reporter="0" type="60">
    <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
  </reporting-org>
  <title>
    <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector Reform Programme in North Macedonia (2021 - 2026)</narrative>
  </title>
  <description type="1">
    <narrative xml:lang="en">By building on recent achievements during Phase I (2017-2021), the objective of this programme is to continue a process of democratic reforms within the security sector in North Macedonia, by working closely with national partners to operationalize and make sustainable initial results made, aimed at creating a more accountable and through that ultimately a more effectively governed security and intelligence sector.</narrative>
  </description>
  <description type="2">
    <narrative xml:lang="en">Working together with national partners to align the legal and institutional framework of the intelligence and security sector with relevant Euro-Atlantic principles and good practice and respect of human rights (Outcome 1); improving existing capacity of external oversight bodies to conduct effective and transparent oversight and control (Outcome 2); and helping ensure the public is informed on the functionality and results of the intelligence and security accountability system (Outcome 3);, the DCAF intervention strategy aims to ensure that intelligence and security services in North Macedonia function effectively under active democratic control and oversight and fight serious and organised crime and curb corruption in line with good practice of accountability and respect for human rights (Project goal). Ultimately, the Programme seeks to make an effective and sustainable contribution towards improved democratic governance of the intelligence and security (law enforcement) sector thus contributing to enhanced accountability, stability, rule of law and security for the state and the citizens (Development Goal)</narrative>
  </description>
  <description type="3">
    <narrative xml:lang="en">Partners and beneficiaries in North Macedonia:•Cabinet of the President (National Security Advisor);  •The Parliament;   •Prime Minister’s Office; •Ministry of Interior;•Law Enforcement agencies; •Ministry of Defense; •Ministry of Justice;•Security and Intelligence Services (the so-called authorised bodies);•Operational Technical Agency (OTA); •Agency for Personal Data Protection; •Directorate for Security of Classified Information; •Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors; •State Public Prosecutor Office for Organised Crime and Corruption; •Other courts and judicial institutions; •Ombudsperson; •State Audit Office;•Commission for the Protection of the Right to Free Access to Public Information;•State Administrative Inspectorate;•Various CSOs and media outlets. </narrative>
  </description>
  <description type="4">
    <narrative xml:lang="en">The proposed programme intervention supports Macedonian reform areas outlined in the Plan 2018, aiming at a comprehensive security, justice and intelligence sector reform.  It further supports the Macedonian Defence Strategy  in having the different intelligence service providers and their oversight institutions acting in accordance with Euro-Atlantic standards. Other governmental strategies’ implementation which this programme explicitly supports are the Transparency Strategy of the Government of the Republic of North Macedonia (2019-2021),  the Open Data Strategy (2018-2021) , and the Communication Strategy 2019/2020 , all aiming at increasing transparency, outreach and public access to governmental activities, thus building public trust in their leadership. </narrative>
  </description>
  <participating-org ref="XM-DAC-7" type="10" role="1" activity-id="4000004197" crs-channel-code="11000">
    <narrative xml:lang="en">Netherlands - Ministry of Foreign Affairs</narrative>
  </participating-org>
  <participating-org ref="SE-0" type="10" role="1" activity-id="14299" crs-channel-code="11000">
    <narrative xml:lang="en">Sweden, through Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency (Sida)</narrative>
  </participating-org>
  <participating-org ref="CH-4" type="10" role="1" activity-id="81056699" crs-channel-code="11000">
    <narrative xml:lang="en">Switzerland - Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (SDC)</narrative>
  </participating-org>
  <participating-org ref="XI-IATI-EC_NEAR" type="15" role="1" activity-id="IPA/2021/425-651" crs-channel-code="11000">
    <narrative xml:lang="en">European Commission - Neighbourhood and Enlargement Negotiations</narrative>
  </participating-org>
  <participating-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" type="60" role="2" activity-id="548004" crs-channel-code="20000">
    <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
  </participating-org>
  <participating-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" type="60" role="4" activity-id="548004" crs-channel-code="20000">
    <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
  </participating-org>
  <activity-status code="2"/>
  <activity-date type="2" iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
  <activity-date type="3" iso-date="2026-12-31"/>
  <contact-info type="2">
    <organisation>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>
    </organisation>
    <department>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Operations, Europe and Central Asia</narrative>
    </department>
    <person-name>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Irena Dzajkovska </narrative>
    </person-name>
    <job-title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Programme Manager</narrative>
    </job-title>
    <telephone>0041795448796</telephone>
    <email>i.dzajkovska@dcaf.ch</email>
  </contact-info>
  <activity-scope code="4"/>
  <recipient-country code="MK" percentage="100">
    <narrative xml:lang="en">The Programme is implemented throughout the entire country. </narrative>
  </recipient-country>
  <policy-marker code="3"/>
  <default-flow-type code="10"/>
  <default-finance-type code="110"/>
  <default-aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
  <default-tied-status code="5"/>
  <budget type="1" status="2">
    <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
    <period-end iso-date="2021-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-06-18">1174973</value>
  </budget>
  <budget type="1" status="2">
    <period-start iso-date="2022-01-01"/>
    <period-end iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2022-06-24">1518242</value>
  </budget>
  <planned-disbursement type="1">
    <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
    <period-end iso-date="2026-03-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-04-01">780000</value>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="4000004197" type="10"/>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60"/>
  </planned-disbursement>
  <planned-disbursement type="1">
    <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
    <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-04-01">1000000</value>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81056699" type="10"/>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60"/>
  </planned-disbursement>
  <planned-disbursement type="1">
    <period-start iso-date="2021-08-01"/>
    <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
    <value currency="SEK" value-date="2021-08-01">9000000</value>
    <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="14299" type="10"/>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative>DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
  </planned-disbursement>
  <planned-disbursement type="1">
    <period-start iso-date="2021-07-12"/>
    <period-end iso-date="2024-07-12"/>
    <value currency="EUR" value-date="2021-07-12">300000</value>
    <provider-org ref="XI-IATI-EC-NEAR" provider-activity-id="IPA_2021_425_651" type="10">
      <narrative>European Union</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548006" type="60">
      <narrative>DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
  </planned-disbursement>
  <planned-disbursement type="1">
    <period-start iso-date="2025-01-01"/>
    <period-end iso-date="2026-02-28"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2025-01-01">500000</value>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81056699" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Swiss Development Cooperation</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
  </planned-disbursement>
  <planned-disbursement type="2">
    <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
    <period-end iso-date="2026-03-31"/>
    <value currency="SEK" value-date="2024-03-01">14275650</value>
    <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="14299" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida - Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
  </planned-disbursement>
  <planned-disbursement type="1">
    <period-start iso-date="2025-06-06"/>
    <period-end iso-date="2028-06-06"/>
    <value currency="EUR" value-date="2025-06-06">600000</value>
    <provider-org ref="XI-IATI-EC-NEAR" provider-activity-id="IPAIII-ENEST_2025_484-005" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">European Union</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548007" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
  </planned-disbursement>
  <transaction ref="Sida, Disbursement 4" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2024-03-28"/>
    <value currency="SEK" value-date="2024-03-28">2000000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Fourth transfer from Sida.</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="14299" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida - Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210"/>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Sida, Disbursement 5" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2024-10-17"/>
    <value currency="SEK" value-date="2024-10-17">1000000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Fifth transfer from Sida.</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="14299" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida - Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210"/>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Annual Expenditure 2022 (NL)" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="4"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2022-12-31">181026</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure between January and December 2022. NL contribution.</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="DSH-400004197" type="10">
      <narrative>The Netherlands, Ministry of Foreign Affairs</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Annual Expenditure 2022 (SDC/FDFA)" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="4"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2022-12-31">301612</value>
    <description>
      <narrative>Expenditure for period January - December 2022. SDC/FDFA contribution.</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81068740" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">SDC/FDFA</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Annual Expenditure 2022 (Sida)" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="4"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2022-12-31">279440</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period January - December 2022. Sida contribution.</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="14299" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2021-06-01"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-06-01">250000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">First instalment upon signing of agreement. </narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81056699" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">SDC</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60"/>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2021-07-30"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-07-30">156000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">First Instalment as per contract </narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="40004197" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Netherlands</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector Reform</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2021-11-24"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-11-24">350000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Second Instalment as per contract</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81056699" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">SDC - Second transfer as per contract</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector </narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="4"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2021-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-12-31">80624</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditures during period April - December 2021. Expenses charged to NL </narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="40004197" type="10"/>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60"/>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="4"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2021-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-12-31">124454</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditures during period April - December 2021. Sida Contribution </narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="SE-0" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative>DCAF</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="4"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2021-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-12-31">134329</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditures during period April - December 2021. SDC Contribution </narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81056699">
      <narrative>SDC</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector</narrative>
    </sector>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2021-09-10"/>
    <value currency="SEK" value-date="2021-09-10">4500000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">First instalment upon signing of agreement</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="14299" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Annual Expenditure 2024 (Sida)" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="4"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2024-12-31">223808</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period January - December 2024. Sida contribution.</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="14299" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida </narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and security sector. </narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2022-11-28"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2022-11-28">156000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Second Transfer from NL </narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="400004197" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Second Transfer Ministry of Foreign Affairs as per contract</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Support to the Intel &amp; Security Sector Reform Programme in North Macedonia</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2022-09-02"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2022-09-02">300000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Third Installment as per contract</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81056699" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">SDC- Transfer as per contract </narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence &amp; Security Sector Reform</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2022-11-18"/>
    <value currency="SEK" value-date="2022-11-18">1500000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Second Transfer</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="14299" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida - Second Transfer</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210"/>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Sida, Final Disbursement" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2025-09-23"/>
    <value currency="SEK" value-date="2025-09-23">1000000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Final transfer from Sida.</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="14299" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida - Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210"/>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="11"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2021-07-28"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2022-08-31">156000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Second instalment as per contract</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="400004197" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="11"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2021-07-28"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2023-08-31">195000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Third Instalment as per contract</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="400004197">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">intelligence and security sector reform programme activities</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="11"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2021-07-28"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2025-08-31">107000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">fifth instalment as per contract</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="400004197">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative>DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">intelligence and security sector reform activities</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="11"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2021-07-28"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-07-28">39000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">final instalment as per contract</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="400004197" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF = Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">intelligence and security sector reform activities</narrative>
    </sector>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="First Instalment, NL" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="11"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2021-07-28"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2021-07-31">156000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">First instalment as per contract</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="400004197" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector reform programme activities </narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Second Installment, SDC" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="11"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2024-03-11"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2024-03-04">100000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Part of second instalment as per contract </narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81080278" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">SDC </narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">intelligence and security sector reform activities </narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Fourth Transfer from NL" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2025-03-04"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2025-03-04">117000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Fourth Transfer from NL</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="400004197" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Fourth Transfer Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs as per contract </narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Support to the Intelligence &amp; Security Sector Reform Programme in North Macedonia</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Sida, Disbursement 6" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2025-04-11"/>
    <value currency="SEK" value-date="2025-04-11">2000000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Sixth transfer from Sida.</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="14299" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida - Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210"/>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Third Installment, SDC" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2025-11-07"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2025-11-07">100000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Third installment, as per contract.</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81056699" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">SDC - Swiss Development Cooperation</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Third Installment, SDC</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Third Transfer from NL" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2023-10-12"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2023-10-12">205000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Third Transfer from NL</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="400004197" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Third Transfer Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs as per contract </narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Support to the Intel &amp; Security Sector Reform Programme in North Macedonia</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Annual Expenditure 2024 (SDC/FDFA)" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="4"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2024-12-31">223294</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period January - December 2024. SDC/FDFA contribution. </narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81068740" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">SDC/FDFA </narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and security sector. </narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Annual Expenditure 2024 (NL)" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="4"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2024-12-31">141516</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure between January and December 2024. NL contribution.</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="DSH-400004197" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">The Netherlands, Ministry of Foreign Affairs </narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Sida, Disbursement 3" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2023-09-20"/>
    <value currency="SEK" value-date="2023-09-20">2275650</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Third transfer from Sida.</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="14299" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida - Third Transfer</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210"/>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Annual Expenditure 2025 (Sida)" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="4"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2025-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2025-12-31">209100</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period January - December 2025. Sida contribution.</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="14299" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida </narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and security sector. </narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Fourth Installment, SDC" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2024-09-16"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2024-09-16">200000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Fourth installment, as per contract.</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81080278" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">SDC - Swiss Development Cooperation</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210"/>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Annual Expenditure 2025 (SDC/FDFA)" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="4"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2025-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2025-12-31">189663</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period January - December 2025. SDC/FDFA contribution. </narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81068740" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">SDC/FDFA </narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and security sector. </narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Annual Expenditure 2025 (NL)" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="4"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2025-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2025-12-31">76009</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure between January and December 2025. NL contribution.</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="DSH-400004197" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">The Netherlands, Ministry of Foreign Affairs </narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Fifth Transfer from NL" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2025-09-30"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2025-09-30">107000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Fifth Transfer from NL</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="400004197" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Fifth Transfer Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs as per contract </narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Support to the Intelligence &amp; Security Sector Reform Programme in North Macedonia</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Fifth Installment, SDC" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="1"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2025-06-26"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2025-06-26">150000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Fifth installment, as per contract.</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81056699" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">SDC - Swiss Development Cooperation</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210"/>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="2025 Disbursement" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="3"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2025-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2025-12-31">474773</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual expenditure for 2025 (NL, Sida, SDC)</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">all donors</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and security sector reform activities </narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="2024 Disbursement" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="3"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2024-12-31">1268527</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual expenditure</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">all donors</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and security sector reform activities </narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Final instalment" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="11"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2024-03-11"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2024-03-11">50000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">final payment</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81080278" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">SDC</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">intelligence and security sector reform activities</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Second Installment, SDC" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="11"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2024-03-11"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2024-03-11">150000</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">First Instalment as per contract</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81080278" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">SDC</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">intelligence and security sector reform activities</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="2023 Disbursement" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="3"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2023-12-31">1029624</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual expenditure</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">All donors</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and security sector reform activities </narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="2026" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="2"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2025-08-20"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2025-07-17">686942</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual planned budget for 2026</narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">All donors</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and security sector reform activities </narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="2025" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="2"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2024-12-01"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2024-12-01">620898</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual planned budget </narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">All donors</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and security sector reform activities </narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Annual Expenditure 2023 (NL)" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="4"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2023-12-31">201467.33</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure between January and December 2023. NL contribution. </narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="XM-DAC-7" provider-activity-id="DSH-400004197" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">The Netherlands, Ministry of Foreign Affairs</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Annual Expenditure 2023 (Sida)" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="4"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2023-12-31">309449.90</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period January - December 2023. Sida contribution. </narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="SE-0" provider-activity-id="14299" type="10">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Sida</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and security sector.</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <transaction ref="Annual Expenditure 2023 (SDC/FDFA)" humanitarian="0">
    <transaction-type code="4"/>
    <transaction-date iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
    <value currency="CHF" value-date="2023-12-31">445034.82</value>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Expenditure for period January - December 2023. SDC/FDFA contribution. </narrative>
    </description>
    <provider-org ref="CH-4" provider-activity-id="81068740" type="10">
      <narrative>SDC/FDFA</narrative>
    </provider-org>
    <receiver-org ref="CH-FDJP-109458452" receiver-activity-id="548004" type="60">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF - Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance</narrative>
    </receiver-org>
    <disbursement-channel code="2"/>
    <sector vocabulary="1" code="15210">
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and security sector.</narrative>
    </sector>
    <flow-type code="10"/>
    <finance-type code="110"/>
    <aid-type code="B04" vocabulary="1"/>
    <tied-status code="5"/>
  </transaction>
  <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/DCAF-Exclusion-Policy-20220624010627.pdf" format="application/pdf">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF Exclusion Policy</narrative>
    </title>
    <category code="B08"/>
    <language code="en"/>
    <document-date iso-date="2018-05-02"/>
  </document-link>
  <result type="1" aggregation-status="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report October - December 2023</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter_EN_OCT-DEC_2023-20240314020330.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter No. 10: October - December 2023</narrative>
      </title>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.1.2: Oversight actors feel more confident in institutional cooperation and exchange .</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2020">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Baseline #2.1.1 – 2.1.2: Insufficient cooperation between intelligence/security services and legally mandated oversight actors.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By end of 2023 80% of the actors expressed feeling more confident in institutional cooperation and exchange. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">During this period, DCAF worked with parts of the intelligence community on increasing their reporting capacities, transparency policies, and use of good governance. These activities contribute to improve the confidence of oversight actors by improving inter-institutional cooperation and exchange.DCAF organised a Workshop on Reporting and Inter-Institutional Cooperation in Skopje on 17 October and Workshop on Intelligence Budgeting and Management of Special Funds in Ljubljana between 05-07 December for senior-level managers in the intelligence institutions. During the first workshop, participants discussed tools for reporting to the public and respective institutions, reporting standards, and mechanisms for inter-institutional cooperation. During the second workshop, participants discussed budgeting, such as the intelligence budget cycle as a process through which funds (budgets) for the operation of intelligence services are formed, approved, implemented (spent), and reviewed (controlled). DCAF’s expert additionally facilitated a discussion around the role of public finance principles and intelligence tasking in guiding the formation of intelligence budgets facilitated.Between 6 and 10 November, DCAF organised a Training of Trainers (ToT) Course for the Military Service for Security and Intelligence (MSSI) in Berovo, North Macedonia. The course focused on increasing participants’ knowledge of learning and teaching methods and principles and bringing education and training closer to operational needs to enhance the training system in the MSSI. The participants of the ToT will be able to apply their knowledge by delivering courses on military intelligence and good governance organised by the MSSI and DCAF in December 2023 and January 2024.Subsequently, between 11 and 22 December in Skopje, DCAF and the MSSI organised the first Course for Military Security and Intelligence and Good Governance. The course contains material on good governance in the security sector with a focus on military security and intelligence. The first course was attended by sixteen participants at the mid-management level and increased levels of understanding of the importance of applying democratic and good governance standards in security institutions and the influence of good governance on the professionalism, productivity, transparency, and accountability of the security sector.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-10-26"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-11-08"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By end of 2023 80% of the actors expressed feeling more confident in institutional cooperation and exchange. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">During this period, DCAF engaged with the ombuds institution to increase its confidence for performing oversight activities.From 26 to 27 October, DCAF organised the first training for representatives of the Ombuds institution in North Macedonia entitled: "The Oversight Role of the Ombudsman over Intelligence and Security". The objective of the training was to familiarise the representatives of the Ombuds institution in North Macedonia with oversight principles, the institutions’ responsibilities for oversight, and the role of Ombuds institutions in enhancing security sector reform. The training utilised expert sessions on theory, practical exercises, and case studies to encourage a discussion of existing challenges to performing effective oversight. DCAF will continue to support the representatives of the Ombuds institution to strengthen their oversight role in the intelligence and security sector.   On 8 November, DCAF, in cooperation with the Ombudsperson of North Macedonia, organised a “Conference on the Oversight Role of the Ombudsperson over Intelligence and Security” in Skopje.The event featured a wide range of prominent speakers, panelists, and over 100 attendees. Among the key speakers of the event were the President of North Macedonia and DCAF’s Assistant Director, Mr. Hans Born. During the conference, speakers and panelists examined the possibility of strengthening the Ombudsperson's role as an oversight actor in the intelligence and security sector and exchanged European practices for Ombuds institutions in intelligence and security sector oversight. The event convened a diverse range of participants including Members of Parliament, representatives of the Government, employees of the Ombudsperson office in North Macedonia, security institutions, and intelligence agencies, independent experts, the academic community, civil society, media, as well as senior representatives of the international community in North Macedonia.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.3.1: Shielded Room and protected workspace constructed in Parliament and equipment installed.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2020">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Parliament has no protected workspace and meeting facility to discuss and store classified information, impeding meaningful exchange of sensitive and classified information with security and intelligence services. Parliament, in Feb 2020, approved the establishment of the shielded room. Within its Phase I Programme DCAF allocated funds as a contribution towards the establishment of the Shielded Room and protected workplace. Due to Covid-19 the process was delayed throughout 2020. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2021 the Parliament has a Shielded Room and protected space Installed. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continued to support the Assembly for the construction and accreditation of a Shielded Room and protected workspace for handling classified information. The construction, directed by Parliament and supported by DCAF, commenced in July. The process is progressing and, according to the Construction Action Plan, is expected to be completed by the beginning of May 2024. In addition, DCAF continues to facilitate the process of producing accreditation documents for the use of the Shielded Room.  On 5 December, DCAF organised a Working Visit to the Slovenian Parliament for three committee chairs of the oversight committees of the Macedonian Parliament and eight staffers who are or will be involved in the installation, accreditation, and use of the Shielded Room. The MPs met their Slovenian counterparts and discussed the Slovenian and Macedonian models of parliamentary oversight, areas for improvement, and future perspectives. The staffers additionally had the opportunity to compare their own experiences with those of their Slovenian counterparts. This exchange of experiences should optimise their work and the processes and procedures for the Shielded Room.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.9.1: Selected employees from the Ministry of Interior successfully conclude vocational trainings.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2020">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Employees from the Ministry of Interior, e.g. the Section for Crime – Technical Analysis and Expertise, and the National Central Unit for Information Exchange, are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge to administer automated exchange of DNA data.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2023, relevant employees from the Ministry of Interior received the necessary vocational trainings.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF organised a Workshop on Revising the Guidelines and Strategy for Recovering Biological Samples for DNA Analysis in Skopje from 6 to 8 November. The purpose of the workshop, facilitated by an international expert in forensic science and DNA analysis, was to allow members of the Laboratory for the Reception and Selection of Biological Material to review comments, advice, and suggestions for improving the Guidelines developed by the expert. The Guidelines explain the entire process of forensic-technical processing and are intended to reduce the risks of cross-contamination, or complete destruction, of traces of biological origin while ensuring uniformity in the processing of biological traces for DNA analysis. Once completed and internally approved, the Laboratory representatives will consult the Guidelines during their work in order to enhance the quality of collected traces.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 2.11.1 Recommendations from the Gender Self-Assessment are translated into a Gender Action Plan by the Ministry of Defense.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Within the Ministry of Defence (MoD), despite of the existing gender-sensitive policies, which have so far made significant progress in terms of gender responsiveness of the institution, there is still no evidence-based research on the degree of progress in enhancing gender-responsive practices, as well as on the potential gaps and weaknesses in the domain of the gender mainstreaming.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025, a Gender Action Plan is developed for the Ministry of Defense and the Army.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continued to assist the Ministry of Defense (MoD) and the Army of North Macedonia in conducting the Gender Self-Assessment (GSA). In the October to December period, DCAF conducted a comprehensive analysis of the quantitative and qualitative data collected during the field research phase, working with the Working Group of the MoD to identify gaps, weaknesses, and opportunities for gender mainstreaming in the MoD and Army. The data, collected between May and September 2023,  came from interviews with individuals in management and command positions, focus group discussions, and survey responses from MoD and Army personnel (Officers, NCOs, professional soldiers and administrative staff) in North Macedonia.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.1.1: CSOs and Media report improved understanding of intelligence sector reforms, accountability requirements and police integrity </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2020">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">CSOs and Media are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge and skills on intelligence sector reforms and accountability requirements, and police integrity to do monitoring and assessments of intelligence and security sector reforms.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2023, 5 trainings/workshops delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">During this period, much progress was made on training representatives of CSOs and media and facilitating an exchange between state and non-state actors. Between 18 and 20 October 2023, DCAF organised a Multi-Stakeholder Workshop entitled “Reconciling security sector and justice sector reform in North Macedonia” in Mavrovo. The workshop brought together representatives from local CSOs/media, Parliament (MPs and staff) and the Judiciary (judges and public prosecutors) with the aim to increase their understanding of each stakeholders’ roles and responsibilities in ensuring effective and accountable intelligence and security sector governance.Through tailor-made exercises and a scenario-based simulation, participants had the opportunity to enhance their knowledge on different forms of oversight in line with international human rights standards. In addition, the workshop served as a platform for building trust and cooperation between different oversight actors through their joint definition of the functions and challenges of the intelligence and security sector.The workshop "Developing Standardised Guidelines for Civilian Oversight of Intelligence and Security by Civil Organisations and the Media" was organised between 23 and 25 November in Strumica and attended by representatives of CSOs, the media, and Parliament. This workshop was designed to encourage participants to contribute to the development of common standardised guidelines for effective civilian oversight over intelligence and security. The workshop included dynamic plenary discussions and breakout sessions moderated by an expert.Subsequently, on 15 December 2023, DCAF organised a Workshop for the Validation of the Standardised Guidelines for Civilian Oversight of Intelligence and Security by CSOs and Media in North Macedonia.The workshop also marked the conclusion of the first phase of a year-long capacity-building process on "Security Sector Governance and Accountability" that was designed for CSO and media representatives in North Macedonia.These guidelines are designed to serve as a structural framework, outlining principles, standards, and norms for civilian oversight of the intelligence and security sector that were defined by CSO and media representatives in North Macedonia. The guidelines  are a practical resource and should assist the CSOs and media to methodically and systematically engage in democratic oversight of intelligence and security sector institutions in North Macedonia.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-12-20"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-21"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2023, 5 trainings/workshops delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">To increase the exchange between the security sector/intelligence institutions and CSOs and media outlets on gender equality in terms of SSR, DCAF organised a Gender Talk on 21 December 2023. The event was on the topic of Gender Perspectives of the Intelligence Sector in cooperation with UNI-FORM (Association of Women from the Security Sector). The Gender Talks are moderated discussions aimed to prompt reflections on progress and challenges of gender mainstreaming practices in intelligence and security institutions in North Macedonia. The first Gender Talk featured speakers from the Intelligence Agency and the Operational-Technical Agency (OTA) who explained their institutions’ approach to gender mainstreaming.The audience consisted of representatives of intelligence and security institutions, CSOs, the media, and the academic community. The event garnered great interest and prompted interesting discussions.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.2.1: Public institutions legally mandated to oversee or control intelligence services report on their activities.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2020">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">There is none or inconsistent public reporting by intelligence sector actors taking place.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2022 four theoretical and practical trainings on report drafting organised with all intelligence sector actors.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">On 21 November, in Skopje, DCAF organised a roundtable for presenting the Guide for Developing Annual Reports in Security/Intelligence Services and Control/Oversight Institutions. The Guide was drafted by a small group of selected participants from the multi-stakeholder workshops on Reporting Standards for Security/Intelligence Services and Control/Oversight Institutions, during which of the Guide, a document of common standards and principles for preparing public reports, was developed. During the roundtable, participants provided feedback on the Guide and offered suggestions for its improvement. The document will be reviewed by an expert before being distributed in its final version to all institutions involved in the development process. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.3.1: Independent working group produces meaningful monitoring reports.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2020">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The annual report of public prosecutor is the only source of information about use of SIM (number or requests and number of approved warrants) in criminal investigation. There is no publicly available information allowing an assessment of the use of SIM and judicial authorisation of SIM. Last report published was in 2018.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">At least one monitoring report per year produced and shared with public and relevant institutions.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">On 1 September 2023, the Research Team for Developing Methodology for Conducting Research on Macedonian Judicial Practice for the Authorisation and Implementation of Special Investigative Measures (SIMs), consisting of three drafters nominated by the Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors, held its first meeting. The team will create a methodology according to which longitudinal research of the jurisprudence related to SIM will be conducted. This methodology will be beneficial for monitoring, tracking, and evaluating the SIM jurisprudence, and potentially for creating recommendations to advance the jurisprudence.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.4.2: Inter-institutional Protocols, harmonised Templates and Guidelines for different stages of SIM approval are drafted and submitted for approval by relevant institutions within the criminal justice chain.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2020">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Courts and prosecutorial offices have different (sometimes dated, or even contradictory) procedures and templates used in the authorisation of SIM. Harmonisation of practice and exchange of information are not in place to ensure effective authorisation of SIM, in agreement with new legislative provisions and European standards.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2022 working groups draft proposals designed to unify and harmonise practice.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">At the request of the Criminal Court in Skopje, DCAF organised a Third Workshop on Conceptualising Procedures for Destroying Data Produced by Special Investigative Measures (SIM) from November 29 to December 01 in Popova Shapka. This workshop addressed the need for a specific procedure for the destruction of data produced by SIM, recognised over the past two years during DCAF's multistakeholder workshops on measures for the interception of communications. The Agency for Personal Data Protection recommended the development of this procedure to protect citizens' privacy. Engaging representatives from various institutions, specifically the Judiciary (Supreme Court, Basic Criminal Court, Basic Public Prosecution Skopje, Basic Public Prosecution for Organised Crime and Corruption), Ministry of Interior, Ministry of Justice, Agency for Personal Data Protection, Directorate for Security of Classified Information, State Archive, Lawyer Chamber, and academia, the workshop focused on drafting procedures for the destruction of SIM-generated data. Discussions covered legal basis, responsible parties, steps, and deadlines for data retention and destruction. Following the workshop, the Guidelines for the Destruction of Data Produced by SIMs were presented in a coordination meeting held in Skopje on 21 December. The Ministry of Justice is presently distributing the Guidelines to stakeholders for feedback and DCAF will continue supporting the institutions for its finalisation. Upon finalisation, legal practitioners will initiate the implementation of the Guidelines, starting with a pilot phase in judicial institutions nationwide.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.6.1: A system for accountability in the use of intrusive methods (SIM), where different actors involved are aware of each other’s role and function in complementarity (judiciary, parliamentary committees, law enforcement, CCS, etc) is developed.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2020">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">No training delivered by the Academy on SIM </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #2.6.1 (b): By the end of 2023 most judicial practitioners working on criminal investigative matters have theoretical and practical knowledge on procedures and European standards for managing personal data and classified information. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">In partnership with the Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors, DCAF organised a training on European principles and standards for the judicial control of the use of SIMs by police and intelligence agencies from 8 to 9 November in Skopje. The training reached 80 aspiring judges and prosecutors enrolled in the 8th generation of entry-level training at the Academy. The training was a combination of lectures and practical exercises covering European principles, standards, and good practices for criminal investigations, information collection, and evidence assessment. The training was delivered by a team of four senior experts from EU countries, specifically Austria, Croatia, Slovenia, and Finland, who shared their extensive knowledge of European jurisprudence and rich practical experience in criminal investigations and the implementation of SIMs. This unique training exposed participants to specialised knowledge and expertise, emphasising the value of enriching participants’ understanding of international standards and practices in judicial control.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.8.1: SICPS’ employees have updated knowledge and skills to perform their duties related to preventing corruption and integrity violations more efficiently within the MoI.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2020">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Over the last two years DCAF supported the MoI in the development and drafting of the Integrity Plan. Presently, the Integrity Plan is pending approval from the Minister of Interior. The Ministry of Interior (MoI) is amending the law on internal affairs to improve the internal control mechanisms that promote integrity. The new law will include integrity testing measures as a means of internal control, which will be applied to both current and future employees of the MoI. The MoI does not possess technical equipment to perform professional integrity testing, which will be a requirement in accordance to the new Law on Internal Affairs. In addition, the North Macedonian Police have revised their Code of Ethics in 2020</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By end of 2023 all employees within the SICPS have undergone integrity training</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">From 2 to 5 October in Veles, DCAF trained a group of trainers from the Ministry of Interior (MoI) of North Macedonia on police integrity and gender topics. The four days of training were highly interactive, with trainers learning of modern adult learning principles and delivering their own practice sessions to their peers. Subsequently, on 3 November, DCAF convened the same trainers from the Ministry of Interior (MoI) at a meeting to coordinate the planning and organisation of training courses on police integrity. During this meeting, the trainers discussed the objectives, agenda, content, schedule, and quality assurance of the integrity courses. These courses are part of the Action Plan of the MoI’s Integrity Plan for the period 2023-2025, approved by the Minister and aimed at strengthening the integrity of MoI employees from organisational units identified in the Plan as the most susceptible to corruption. The trainers delivered 8 training courses on police integrity covering over 160 police officers throughout North Macedonia. The train-the-trainer course, along with the subsequent delivery of trainings across the country, enable the MoI to increase its organisational integrity in a sustainable manner.DCAF will continue to support the MoI to implement its Integrity Plan, monitor its execution, and prepare the related Annual Report.DCAF additionally organised two Training Courses on Criminal Investigations for Crimes Committed by Police Officers in Struga from 26 to 29 October and 09 to 12 November. The trainings engaged two groups of 20 participants from the Department for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations, and Professional Standards and responded to the MoI’s need for strengthened capacities for conducting criminal investigations in line with the Law on Internal Affairs. Facilitated by judicial practitioners (two public prosecutors, two judges, and a defence lawyer), the training aimed to increase participants’ knowledge on conducting investigations and collecting evidence as well as enhance cooperation, communication, and coordination between the Department and the public prosecution and courts. Participants engaged in discussions with the experts, shared experiences, identified key challenges and gaps in communication and coordination with the judiciary, and proposed potential solutions for increasing the effectiveness and efficiency of criminal investigations.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="2">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Main Results 2023</narrative>
    </title>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Main outcome-level results achieved in 2023</narrative>
    </description>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/2023-DCAF-IntelSSR-in-MK_Operational-Report-Jan-Dec-2023_IATI-20240430090450.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual Report 2023 - Narrative</narrative>
      </title>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2024-04-30"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">1.2: The MoI is acting in accordance with new amendments to the law on Internal Affairs and in accordance with the MoI Integrity Plan. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The amendments to the Law on Internal Affairs, which are currently in parliamentary procedure (June 2021), make a change in Article 66 of the law that sets up the general criteria a person should meet so that he/she can be employed in the MoI, with a new criterion being introduced – the person must pass an Integrity Test carried out by the MoI.  A professional integrity test will also be conducted for existing employees, contributing to the prevention of corruption and abuse of office, aimed at strengthening the integrity of Ministry and Police employees and preventive action. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The Integrity Plan and Action Plan (2023-2025) of the MoI was developed by the MoI’s WG on Integrity. It was endorsed and adopted by MoI leadership in 2023 and was made publicly available on the MoI’s website. It will assist the MoI to prevent and mitigate corruption risks in its institution. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">2.3: The Ministry of Interior of North Macedonia (MoI) has strategic and operational capacity to effectively build integrity in line with European values and good policing practice, enabling more effective oversight. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Section for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations, and Professional Standards (DICCIPS), in cooperation with DCAF, developed an Integrity Plan over the past three years. The Plan assesses the corruption risk of all job positions in the Ministry of Interior, in accordance with the Rulebook on systematization of job positions in the MoI, proposing measures aimed to reduce risk.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The MoI implemented the first year of its Integrity Plan (2023 – 2025) and produced an annual report that indicates an implementation rate of 100%, with all trainings, controls, and other activities performed.  </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">2.5: Recommendations from the GSA process translated into Gender Action Plan with the capacity to be configured as a complementary part of the institutional gender activities, plans and strategies of the MoD.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Ministry of Defense and Army do not have a Gender Action Plan based on a thorough institutional assessment.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">•The Gender Self-Assessment of the MoD is finalised, and the end-products (GSA Report and Gender Action Plan) are drafted (following data collection and analysis phase in 2023). Final endorsement is expected by the Minister in April 2024.•13 members of the MoD working group and the Coordinator of Equal Opportunities were trained on gender assessment methodology.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">3.1: Public can debate and challenge the content of reports produced by intelligence and law enforcement actors.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The intelligence sector reforms and accountability are not sufficiently and publicly debated and professionally addressed by media and CSOs.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">•The Conference on the Oversight Role of the Ombudsman over Intelligence and Security, an activity supported by the programme, was covered by a range of local media (TV channels, newspapers, and media portals). In addition, there was significant engagement on social media (via Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn) with content shared/re-shared and tweeted/re-tweeted on DCAF’s and participants’ social media profiles. The event was additionally livestreamed via an MIA (Media Information Agency) media aggregator and was summarised in a short documentary video produced by 360 Stepeni. This media attention would suggest that media interest and resultingly public interest in the topic of oversight has grown.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">3.2: Media coverage and CSO research paper mentioning the topic of intelligence reform, integrity and accountability.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual reporting by intelligence and security sector institutions and oversight actors is not sufficiently comprehensive, appropriate, and transparent.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">•Four in-depth stories/mini-TV documentaries (eight to 12 minutes each), 1 interview with OTA Director and 1 interview with the Minister of Interior on topics related to intelligence and security sector reform aired as part of the “360 Degrees” TV show on Macedonian Radio-television (MRT). These mini documentaries were also shared and extensively promoted on the website, Facebook page, and YouTube channel of 360 Degrees, as well on DCAF’s official website, social media and YouTube channel. They helped increase the Programme’s visibility and informed the broader public on the progress of reforms in the intelligence and security sector. The mini-documentaries attracted significant viewership and engagement, with each video receiving more than 35.000 - views on TV . The total viewership of the videos is 161,000 views on TV, and 5,287 views on Facebook.•Three Gender Talks (moderated discussions) were organised in cooperation with partner CSO UNI-FORM with interlocutors from intelligence agencies, MoI and MoD. Each Gender Talk was attended by more than 30 participants (representatives of the intelligence and security institutions and representatives of CSOs and media organizations/outlets).•14 representatives from CSOs and media were trained throughout 2023 to contribute to the informal civilian oversight and for better-informed public debate. Guidelines for Informal Civilian•Oversight of Intelligence and Security conducted by CSOs and Media in North Macedonia was developed as a joint product. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">3.3: Transparency, towards the public is improved for the overall work of the intelligence and law enforcement actors, respecting the limits of classified information and personal data protection (GDPR).</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual reporting by intelligence and security sector institutions and oversight actors is not sufficiently comprehensive, appropriate, and transparent.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">•Four theoretical and practical trainings on report drafting were organised with intelligence and security sector institutions. The trainings resulted in the development of the Guide for Developing Annual Reports in Security and Intelligence Services and Control and Oversight Institutions in North Macedonia.  Drawing upon the guidelines outlined in the Guide and adhering to the legally mandated obligations, the Operational Technical Agency (OTA) thoroughly crafted its annual report for the year 2023, subsequently presenting it to the Parliament for review and consideration. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">1.1 (a) Amended laws, bi-laws and procedures on intelligence aligned with international principles, gender and human rights obligations, good practice and respecting the diversity of the citizens of the Republic of North Macedonia, adopted by Parliament. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The current law, by-laws and procedures are not suitable to allow for effective oversight of the intelligence services. In addition, legally mandated oversight bodies are functioning but not sufficiently effective. The formal relationship between the Parliament and the Council for Civilian Supervision remains inadequate as a result.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-07-18"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-07-19"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Amendment of the Law on Interception of Communications (LIC) was passed by the Parliament on 18 July 2023 with a 2/3rds majority. The adoption of the LIC amendment provides a legal foundation for the proper functioning of the Council for Civilian Supervision (CCS) and Parliament’s engagement of technical experts to support the Council.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Security operating procedures for Shielded Room were drafted and finalised in 2023 through an inclusive process with the Parliament, the Directorate for Security of Classified Information (DSCI), and the MoI. This is one of the documents needed for the accreditation of the Shielded Room. The Statement for Security Needs and Security Assessment were also developed in 2023. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Security operating procedures for Shielded Room were drafted and finalised in 2023 through an inclusive process with the Parliament, the Directorate for Security of Classified Information (DSCI), and the MoI. This is one of the documents needed for the accreditation of the Shielded Room. The Statement for Security Needs and Security Assessment were also developed in 2023. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The Committee on Oversight of Implementation of Measures for Interception of Communication has developed and adopted its Rules of Procedure (R&amp;P), based on the Parliament’s R&amp;P and the provisions from the LIC that regulate oversight.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">1.3: All missing requirements and standards, for automated exchange of biometric (DNA) data pursuant to the PCC Prüm Agreement are in place and are sufficient for exchange.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Ministry of Interior has established a solid normative base in the field of DNA exchange, however not yet sufficient to initiate automated exchange of such data, pursuant to the PCC Prüm Agreement.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Internal guidelines and manuals for DNA profiling and analysis necessary for the automated exchange of DNA data were developed in 2023 (including Guidelines and Strategy for Recovering Biological Samples for DNA and Interpretation Guideline for Autosomal STR Profiling).</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">2.1: Quality and frequency of direct oversight interaction between the Parliament and intelligence services increased to meet oversight effectiveness.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Cooperation between the Parliament and security and intelligence services exists but does not meet full oversight needs.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Most of the MPs (members of the 3 parliamentary committees supervising the security and intelligence sectors, representatives of all political parties), as well as the parliamentary staff that support the three oversight committees, participated in capacity building activities (trainings, workshops, working visits, awareness activities) organized by DCAF throughout 2023 (this process started since 2021). Notably, half of the participants were women. MPs and parliamentary staffers involved in the capacity building activities noted an increase in their awareness and comprehension of security and intelligence governance, accountability, and oversight and increase in confidence for conducting oversight activities. The parliamentary oversight process over the intelligence and security enhanced in both quality and frequency. In 2023, the three parliamentary committees overseeing security and intelligence conducted 8 main oversight activities. Namely, these activities include reports, 6 oversight hearings, and _2 oversight visits to the National Security Agency (NSA) and Intelligence Agency (IA). During the period spanning from May 17 to June 15, 2023, the Committee for Oversight of the Implementation of Measures for Interception of Communications conducted 6 classified oversight sessions and hearings, focusing on scrutinizing the operations of the Operational Technical Agency (OTA). Subsequently, the Committee publicly disclosed its consensual conclusion through a press conference and forwarded its findings to the Public Prosecution for further investigation. Additionally, informal channels such as coordination and ad hoc meetings are enhancing cooperation between intelligence agencies and committees, signifying progress towards more effective oversight. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">2.2: Increased consistency of judicial practice (prosecutors and judges) in authorization and review of intrusive methods (intrusive methods to be based on law, be non-discriminatory, have a legitimate aim, and be a “necessary” and “proportional” response).</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The ECHR case law is not regularly observed by prosecutors and judges in the request and authorisation of intrusive methods. The judicial practice (interpretation and application of law by prosecutors and judges) in authorization of intrusive methods is still not consistent and adequate.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The reports from the Public Prosecutor’s Office in 2022 indicate there was a reduction in the number of cases where special investigative measures were implemented compared to 2021, decreasing from 59 to 53 cases. In general, the intrusive measures applied by the Public Prosecutor's Office are reducing each year (specifically the number of wiretaps, physically monitored persons, deployment of persons with concealed identity to detect more serious forms of crimes).•Draft Guidelines for the Destruction of Data Produced by SIMs was developed throughout 2023 with a working group consisting of judicial practitioners and experts. The Guidelines are currently in the process of being verified by judicial sector stakeholders.Trainers from Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors applied skills gained from DCAF’s capacity building to deliver 5 trainings on the Implementation of measures for the interception of communications and 13 trainings on other various topics – organised crime/corruption, financial crime, custody, ethics, hate crime, and confiscation – throughout 2022 and 2023.•Collection of Case-Law on SIMs in North Macedonia developed throughout 2023. It is expected to be made available in 2024 on the Academy’s website in local languages for use by the students and practitioners.   </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="2">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Main Results 2025</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/Annual-Operational-Report-2025_NMK-20260409020404.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual Report 2025</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">2025 Annual Operational Report of the Intelligence and Security Sector Reform Programme in the Republic of North Macedonia (2021-2026)</narrative>
      </description>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <category code="B01"/>
      <language code="en"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2026-04-09"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.1 (b):  Amended laws, by-laws and procedures on intelligence implemented by oversight sector actors.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The current law, by-laws and procedures are not suitable to allow for effective oversight of the intelligence services. In addition, legally mandated oversight bodies are functioning but not sufficiently effective. The formal relationship between the Parliament and the Council for Civilian Supervision remains inadequate as a result.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #1.1 (b): By 2026 all oversight bodies are more effectively implementing oversight and control over intelligence and security sector actors.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">A Checklist for Conducting Oversight Visits by the Ombudsperson was produced as a standardized tool to guide and enhance the effectiveness of oversight visits by the Ombudsperson. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.3: The Ministry of Interior of North Macedonia (MoI) has strategic and operational capacity to effectively build integrity in line with European values and good policing practice, enabling more effective oversight.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Section for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations, and Professional Standards (DICCIPS), in cooperation with DCAF, developed an Integrity Plan over the past three years. The Plan assesses the corruption risk of all job positions in the Ministry of Interior, in accordance with the Rulebook on systematization of job positions in the MoI, proposing measures aimed to reduce risk.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By end of the programme the MoI (DICCIPS) is successfully implementing the Integrity Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The third and final Annual Report was issued by MoI on the implementation of its Integrity Plan (2023 – 2025) which indicates 90% implementation rate across three years, with trainings, internal controls, and other activities increasing continuously. In 2025, DICCIPS initiated investigations into 1,484 cases of alleged illegal, unprofessional, and unethical conduct, as well as abuse of official position, reflecting a 8.6% increase compared to the previous year.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator # 2.1: Quality and frequency of direct oversight interaction between the Parliament and intelligence services increased to meet oversight effectiveness.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Cooperation between the Parliament and security and intelligence services exists but does not meet full oversight needs.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #2.1 (a):  By 2025, each security and intelligence committee convenes an oversight session or hearing at least 6 times annually and produces, for public access, an annual committee report documenting its (non-classified) oversight activities and conclusions.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The Shielded Room and Protected Workplace as a secure facility with protective systems for handling sensitive data and confidential information during oversight activities was used for holding 4 classified sessions and several other reviews and hearings.  Four oversight-related activities were conducted by the Committee for oversight over the intelligence services. Four parliamentary staff members advanced their communication and advisory skills to support MPs in the oversight process attending a series of tailored training and mentoring sessions. Under DCAF guidance, they developed Guide to communication, analytical, and advisory skills to serve as a practical tool for strengthening the role of the parliamentary service in supporting Members of Parliament in the oversight of the intelligence and security sector. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.2: Increased consistency of judicial practice (prosecutors and judges) in authorization and review of intrusive methods (intrusive methods to be based on law, be non-discriminatory, have a legitimate aim, and be a “necessary” and “proportional” response)</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The ECHR case law is not regularly observed by prosecutors and judges in the request and authorisation of intrusive methods. The judicial practice (interpretation and application of law by prosecutors and judges) in authorization of intrusive methods is still not consistent and adequate.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #2.2 (a): By 2025 judicial practice in authorisation of intrusive methods is more consistent and adequate compared to 2020.  </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The report from the Public Prosecutor’s Office in 2024 indicate that there is a significant decrease in the number of cases where special investigative measures (SIM) were implemented compared to previous years, from 53 in 2022 and 87 in 2023 drop to 35 in 2024. This downward trend in recent years is confirmed in the comparative analysis within the extensive research on Application of Special Investigative Measures in the Republic of North Macedonia undertaken this year. The collection of Case-Law on SIMs available on the Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors’ website also serves as educational tool to assist current and future judges and prosecutors to act in a consistent manner when resorting to the use of SIMs. A comprehensive Analysis report Application of Special Investigative Measures in the Republic of North Macedonia developed following an inclusive multi-stakeholder process involving judicial practitioners and experts. The Analysis highlights 16 recommendations for improvement of judicial practice in accountable application of SIMs. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.1 (a): Public can debate and challenge the content of reports produced by intelligence and law enforcement actors. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The intelligence sector reforms and accountability are not sufficiently and publicly debated and professionally addressed by media and CSOs.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-05-20"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">As of 2022, at least one public debate per year organised by CSOs and Media on reports produced by intelligence and law enforcement actors.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The official promotion of the Gender Self-Assessment results and the Gender Action Plan (2024–2028) of the Ministry of Defence had wide coverage by a range of national and local mainstream media (TV channels, newspapers, and media portals). In addition, there was significant engagement on social media (via Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn) with content shared/re-shared and tweeted/re-tweeted on DCAF’s and participants’ social media profiles, including the ones of policymakers. This media coverage indicates significant public attention and interest in the topic of gender mainstreaming in the defence sector.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">As of 2022, at least one public debate per year organised by CSOs and Media on reports produced by intelligence and law enforcement actors.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Fourteen representatives from CSOs and media finalized the extensive ToT programme started in 2024 in order to continue disseminating the acquired knowledge among their peers, organizations and networks, following the updated Guidelines for Informal Civilian Oversight of Intelligence and Security conducted by CSOs and Media in North Macedonia. This cohort of CSOs and media professionals engaged in the development of a micro-qualification curriculum on Security Sector Governance and Oversight, under the flagship of Goce Delčev University in Štip.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.1 (b): Amount of media coverage and CSO research papers mentioning the topic of intelligence reform, integrity and accountability.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The intelligence sector reforms and accountability are not sufficiently and publicly debated and professionally addressed by media and CSOs.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">As of 2022, at least one investigative report and/or policy/research paper per year produced by media and CSOs on intelligence reform and results of the intelligence accountability system.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Two in-depth stories/mini-TV documentaries were produced to inform the broader public on the progress of reforms in the intelligence and security sector and increase the P sector and visibility. Specific video documentaries were produced on gender mainstreaming practices in the intelligence, police, and defence sector, as well as North Macedonia’s NATO integration journey. The latter generated particularly strong engagement, reaching 22,305 views on Facebook.  </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.2: The MoI is acting in accordance with new amendments to the Law on Internal Affairs and in accordance with the MoI Integrity Plan.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The amendments to the Law on Internal Affairs, which are currently in parliamentary procedure (June 2021), make a change in Article 66 of the law that sets up the general criteria a person should meet so that he/she can be employed in the MoI, with a new criterion being introduced – the person must pass an Integrity Test carried out by the MoI.  A professional integrity test will also be conducted for existing employees, contributing to the prevention of corruption and abuse of office, aimed at strengthening the integrity of Ministry and Police employees and preventive action.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #1.2 (b): By the end of the programme, the MoI (DICCIPS) has developed and approved the second iteration of the Integrity Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The Professional Integrity Plan 2026-2028 of the MoI developed utilizing established methodologies, rigorous analysis and data collected from previous annual implementation reports. The new plan outlines seven risk areas for potential corrupted behaviour and an embedded action plan with preventive measures, capacity building initiatives and control mechanisms.  The MoI Department for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations and Professional Standards assumed full "ownership" of its integrity framework as the newly identified risks are directly based on patterns emerging from citizen complaints, internal cases, and findings documented in the annual implementation reports, demonstrating that improved monitoring has been translated into preventive measures.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.4: The Ministry of Defence (MoD) of North Macedonia is effectively implementing the Gender Action Plan.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2023">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Ministry of Defense and Army do not have a Gender Action Plan based on a thorough institutional assessment.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The MoD achieves at least 80% of its annual targets in the Gender Action Plan (2024-2028) in 2025 and 2026 in relation to training and awareness raising activities.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The findings of Gender Self-Assessment (GSA) report and the Gender Action Plan (2024–2028) of the Ministry of Defence and the Army were officially adopted highlighting the institutional strengths, gaps, and opportunities for advancing gender equality in the defence sector. The implementation of the GAP started with development of an Evaluation, Monitoring, and Reporting (EMR) Framework, as integral part of the Gender Action Plan for assessing its implementation.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.4: The Ministry of Interior (MoI) of North Macedonia has organizational and technical capacity to engage in an automated exchange of biometric (DNA and dactyloscopic) data with other Parties to the joint PCC Prüm multilateral legal framework, aligned with European standards and good practice. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Ministry of Interior has established solid organizational, and technical capacity in the field of DNA, however not yet sufficient to initiate automated exchange of such data, pursuant to the PCC Prüm Agreement.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #2.4 (a): By 2026, the Ministry of Interior has successfully performed the pilot run for exchanging DNA data foreseen by the PCC Prüm Agreement.  </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The MoI Forensics Examinations Department continued to enhance its organisational and technical aspects related to automated biometric data processing and exchange under the PCC Prüm framework. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.2: Transparency of intelligence and security sector institutions and oversight actors towards the public, respecting the limits of classified information and personal data protection (GDPR).</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual reporting by intelligence and security sector institutions and oversight actors is not sufficiently comprehensive, appropriate, and transparent.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #3.2 (b): Starting in 2024, each intelligence and security sector institution engaged in the programme produces one annual report containing comprehensive information on its activities.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The Guide for Developing Annual Reports in Security and Intelligence Services and Control and Oversight Institutions developed through a series of multi-stakeholder workshops in 2024, has been used as a valuable and effective reporting tool by the intelligence and security institutions, particularly by OTA which consistently uses the guidelines when preparing their annual reports. Security sector institutions and intelligence agencies have demonstrated a commitment to openness and transparency, as evidenced by their active engagement and willingness to collaborate with DCAF within the framework of the Programme. The perception among civil society organizations and participants in the media training group is that the gap between civil society and state institutions is gradually narrowing, with the Services showing a growing inclination toward greater transparency. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report: January - March 2024</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter_EN_JAN-MAR_2024-20240816020847.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector Reform Programme in North Macedonia, Newsletter 11, January - March 2024</narrative>
      </title>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2024-03-31"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.1.2: Gender Self-Assessment (GSA) conducted in the MoD through a participatory process. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Within the Ministry of Defence (MoD), despite existing gender-sensitive policies, there is still no evidence-based research on progress towards enhancing gender-responsive practices nor on the potential gaps and weaknesses in the domain of gender mainstreaming. An in-depth institutional analysis of gender equality, or a ‘Gender Self-Assessment’ has yet to be completed.  </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-03-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the beginning of 2024, a Gender Self-Assessment is completed in the MoD. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continued to support the Gender Self-Assessment (GSA) process in the Ministry of Defence (MoD) and the Army. After completing the comprehensive research and analysis of the data, several workshops were organised for review and validation of the GSA results with the MoD working group. The initial Workshop for Reflection and Validation of GSA Report took place between 24-25 January in Skopje aimed at reviewing, reflecting upon, and validating the findings presented in the GSA report. It provided a platform for the members of the MoD Working Group to discuss and jointly assess the report's findings and confirm the accuracy and relevance of its content. Additional one-day workshops were organised during February and March 2024, facilitating necessary adjustments to the report, including revisions. The MoD working group actively participated in developing the report recommendations based on the findings.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.4.2: Inter-institutional Protocols, harmonised Templates and Guidelines for different stages of SIM approval are drafted and submitted for approval by relevant institutions within the criminal justice chain.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Courts and prosecutorial offices have different (sometimes dated, or even contradictory) procedures and templates used in the authorisation of SIM. Harmonisation of practice and exchange of information are not in place to ensure effective authorisation of SIM, in agreement with new legislative provisions and European standards.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-03-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2022 working groups draft proposals, templates, and guidelines designed to unify and harmonise practice and submit them for approval.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Upon the request of the Basic Criminal Court in Skopje, DCAF organized the Fourth Workshop on Conceptualising Procedures for Destroying Data Produced by Special Investigative Measures (SIMs) from 31 January to 02 February in Ohrid.The Guidelines/instructions for SIMs Gathered Data Destruction, were developed by judicial practitioners through four joint workshops and other bilateral meetings engaging representatives from various institutions, specifically the Judiciary (Supreme Court, Basic Criminal Court, Basic Public Prosecution Skopje, Basic Public Prosecution for Organised Crime and Corruption), Ministry of Interior, Ministry of Justice, Agency for Personal Data Protection, Directorate for Security of Classified Information, State Archive, Lawyer Chamber, and academia. These Guidelines were finalised and widely approved within the judiciary. The Ministry of Justice of North Macedonia has disseminated the Guidelines to relevant institutions for feedback collection. Upon conclusion of this period, comments will be collated and addressed in a coordination workshop.The Guidelines will serve as a practical tool for judicial practitioners to follow the described procedures and use the proposed templates in the process of destroying SIMs gathered data, in line with the national legislation (on criminal procedure, communications interception, personal data protection, classified information, archiving etc). </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.5.1: Judicial practitioners receive training on judicial authorisation of SIM (more concretely on interception of communications), use of European legal standards and principles related to information collection. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">No training delivered by the Academy on SIM </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-03-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Each year starting 2021 candidates for future judges and prosecutors selecting the subject on interception of communications, will undergo 9 academic classes.  </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Between 8-10 February, DCAF organised the final workshop on the development of the Collection of Case-law related to SIMs Authorisation and Implementation in North Macedonia. Once it is finalised, the Collection will be available on the Academy website and will serve as a training resource for entry-level students at the Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors. It comprises various cases from judicial practice with implemented SIMs, presented and elaborated according to a previously prepared methodology, explaining how the international standards and good practices are applied in each case. DCAF will continue to provide support to the Academy in the forthcoming period to strengthening its training resources and capacities.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.9.2: Relevant experts from the Ministry of Interior receive mentoring to support them in performing duties.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The EU Member States that are Parties to the PCC Prüm Agreement already have the experience and routine of exchanging data. The Ministry of Interior will during the project identify where such experience/routine from these countries would be of added value.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-03-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By mid-2023, all requested mentoring by experts from EU Member States will be provided.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The MoI Forensics and IT Department has completed all requisite preparations for linking up with the TESTA-ng network, the EU's data communication network service. Collaborating closely with the Ministry of information Society and Administration (MISA), acting as a Point of Contact (PoC) to DG DIGIT, the MoI is poised to integrate seamlessly into the system. This network plays a crucial role in enabling automated exchanges of biometric data (including DNA, dactyloscopic, and facial recognition) as well as vehicle registration information, in line with PCC SEE (so-called “mini Prüm”) requirements.DCAF will continue to provide the Ministry with legal support and technical assistance in this regard, including capacity building with international experts. Following the integration process, a comprehensive pilot will be conducted to ensure smooth operations, addressing both technical and legal aspects, before official evaluation and data exchange begins. This holistic approach ensures that all necessary components are in place, promoting a seamless transition and maximising the effectiveness of the exchange platform.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.8.1: DICCIPS’ employees have updated knowledge and skills to perform their duties related to preventing corruption and integrity violations more efficiently within the MoI;</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Over the last two years DCAF supported the MoI in the development and drafting of the Integrity Plan. Presently, the Integrity Plan is pending approval from the Minister of Interior. The Ministry of Interior (MoI) is amending the law on internal affairs to improve the internal control mechanisms that promote integrity. The new law will include integrity testing measures as a means of internal control, which will be applied to both current and future employees of the MoI. The MoI does not possess technical equipment to perform professional integrity testing, which will be a requirement in accordance to the new Law on Internal Affairs. In addition, the North Macedonian Police have revised their Code of Ethics in 2020. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-03-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By end of 2023 all employees within the DICCIPS have undergone training on integrity or training related to implementing the Integrity Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">With DCAF's steadfast assistance, the Ministry of the Interior's Integrity Plan 2023-2025 is making strides forward. Through the provision of guidance and ongoing support, DCAF has facilitated the implementation, monitoring, and evaluation of the plan.Following a workshop organized by DCAF between 24-26 January to review the Integrity Plan's progress in the first year of its implementation, the Internal Control Department has produced its inaugural annual public report. This comprehensive document is accessible on the MoI website in Macedonian, Albanian, and English. Looking ahead, the Internal Control Department is committed to executing the Action Plan for 2024. DCAF is continuously providing support in ongoing implementation, monitoring, and evaluation efforts.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.1.3: Gender Action Plan developed by MoD based on recommendations in the Gender-Self Assessment report and MoD increases its capacity to implement the Plan. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The MoD does not currently have a specific, evidence-based gender action plan aimed at enhancing gender equality in the institution based on an in-depth institutional gender analysis.  </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-03-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the first quarter of 2024, the MoD has a Gender Action Plan based on recommendations developed from a Gender Self-Assessment. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Between 14-16 February in Veles, a Workshop for Development of Gender Action Plan for MoD and the Army took place. The workshop sought to collaboratively design a strategic Gender Action Plan with active participation from the members of the MoD working group and guidance from an expert. Based on the informed insights and findings of the GSA, the Gender Action Plan contains a set of short-term objectives and clear guidelines aimed at fostering better gender mainstreaming within the institution. The GSA Report and the Gender Action Plan are completed and DCAF will continue to support the MoD in implementing the Gender Action Plan in the upcoming period. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.1.1: Regular multi-stakeholder meetings and joint trainings/workshops are held and are attended by a gender-diverse group from all relevant institutions.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Insufficient cooperation between intelligence/security services and legally mandated oversight actors.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-03-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #2.1.1 (a): At least 4 multi-stakeholder meetings and joint trainings/workshops take place annually from 2022.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF, in cooperation with the partner organization UNI-FORM (Association of Women from Security Sector), continued to organise Gender Talks. The Gender Talks are moderated discussions aimed at prompting reflections on the progress and challenges of gender mainstreaming practices in intel and security institutions of North Macedonia, providing a platform for confronting gender bias and fostering gender equality. The second Gender Talk was held on 23 January on the topic Gender Perspectives of the Police Sector with interlocutors from the MoI. The third Gender Talk, held on 29 January was focused on the Gender Perspectives of the Defence Sector with interlocutors from the MoD and the Army. The audience consisted of representatives from MoI, MoD, intelligence and security institutions, CSOs, media and the academic community, who actively engaged in the discussions. The events prompted great interest and discussion, with the interlocutors elaborating on how the gender component is integrated into their respective institutions. A short documentary is currently in production, which will showcase the main takeaways from the Gender Talks.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.3.1: Independent working group produce meaningful monitoring reports.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The annual report of public prosecutor is the only source of information about use of SIM (number or requests and number of approved warrants) in criminal investigation. There is no publicly available information allowing an assessment of the use of SIM and judicial authorisation of SIM. Last report published was in 2018.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-03-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #3.3.1 (b): By mid-2022 monitoring and evaluation tools (indicators, data collection methods) developed.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">On 23 January, at the Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors, the research team, comprising three university professors in criminal procedure law, presented the Methodology for Conducting Research on the Judicial Practice for the Authorisation and Implementation of Special Investigative Measures (SIMs) in North Macedonia. The judicial practitioners who attended the presentation agreed that the Methodology would be beneficial for monitoring, tracking, and evaluating the SIM jurisprudence, and potentially for creating recommendations to advance the SIMs authorisation and implementation procedures.On 13 February, at the Academy, a coordination meeting was held with the Working Group to create an action plan for conducting the research according to the approved Methodology. The Academy will spearhead the research efforts and produce a comprehensive analysis report. This report is anticipated to serve as a robust foundation for identifying challenges within the judiciary pertaining to authorization and implementation of SIMs.On 23 January, at the Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors, the research team, comprising three university professors in criminal procedure law, presented the Methodology for Conducting Research on the Judicial Practice for the Authorisation and Implementation of Special Investigative Measures (SIMs) in North Macedonia. The judicial practitioners who attended the presentation agreed that the Methodology would be beneficial for monitoring, tracking, and evaluating the SIM jurisprudence, and potentially for creating recommendations to advance the SIMs authorisation and implementation procedures.On 13 February, at the Academy, a coordination meeting was held with the Working Group to create an action plan for conducting the research according to the approved Methodology. The Academy will spearhead the research efforts and produce a comprehensive analysis report. This report is anticipated to serve as a robust foundation for identifying challenges within the judiciary pertaining to authorization and implementation of SIMs.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.1.1: CSOs and Media receive trainings/mentoring programs on intelligence and security sector governance, accountability requirements and police integrity. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">CSOs and Media are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge and skills on intelligence sector reforms and accountability requirements, and police integrity to do monitoring and assessments of intelligence and law enforcement sector reforms.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-03-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #3.1.1 (c): By 2025, at least 5 capacity building activities per year delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF commenced the second round of the training process for CSO and media representatives. The aim of this initiative is to build upon the previous progress related to the training of CSOs and media, with subsequent activities focusing primarily on the practical components inherent to security sector governance. The training on "Monitoring and Implementation of the Indicators of Effectiveness, Transparency, and Accountability of the Intelligence and Security Sector" took place between 21-23 March in Veles. Its goal was to equip participants with the essential skills and knowledge for monitoring the activities of intelligence and security institutions. By focusing on performance indicators developed during the Main Phase, the training aimed to enhance the capacities of participants as oversight actors to contribute to a properly governed intelligence and security sector.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report April - June 2024</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter_EN_APR-JUN_2024-20240808030856.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Intelligence and Security Sector Reform Programme in North Macedonia: Newsletter No. 12, April - June 2024</narrative>
      </title>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2024-06-30"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.3.1: Shielded Room and protected workspace constructed in Parliament and equipment installed  .</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Baseline #2.3.1: The Parliament has no protected workspace and meeting facility to discuss and store classified information, impeding meaningful exchange of sensitive and classified information with security and intelligence services. Parliament, in Feb 2020, approved the establishment of the shielded room. Within its Phase I Programme DCAF allocated funds as a contribution towards the establishment of the Shielded Room and protected workplace. Due to Covid-19 the process was delayed throughout 2020. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-06-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2021 the Parliament has a Shielded Room and protected space Installed. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF has sustained its support for the Assembly in the construction and accreditation of a Shielded Room and protected workspace for handling classified information. Initiated by Parliament and supported by DCAF, the construction commenced in July 2023 and has now entered in its final stages. DCAF continues to facilitate the preparation of accreditation documents for the use of the Shielded Room, which is anticipated to be fully accredited and operational for parliamentary use by September 2024. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.5.1: Relevant experts from the Ministry of Interior, and other relevant institutions if necessary, draft normative/legal documents (e.g. regulations, amendments to national laws or by-laws).</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Some normative/legal capacities are already in place. Some of these existing documents will require amendments, while some additional documents might need to be created.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-06-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2022, the necessary normative/legal documents drafted and assessed by selected experts from EU Member States.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">On 14 June, DCAF organised a hybrid mentoringsession to provide guidance in developing two DNA related guidelines for the MoI Forensics Examination Department (Guidelines for the Interpretation andEvaluation of Y-STR Results and Guidelines for theInterpretation and Evaluation of Kinship Analysis – Missing Person, Unidentified Human Remains, and Crime Traces).The development of both documents aligns with thenew requirements related to interpretation, automated processing and exchange of DNA data, by engaging an experienced international DNA expert. The Guidelines will enhance DNA profiling techniques, enabling experts to achieve higher quality results that can be shared with other countries. Once finalised, both documents will be ready for approval and adoption by the Ministry of Interior for internal use.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.6.1: A system for accountability in the use of intrusive methods (SIM), where different actors involved are aware of each other’s role and function in complementarity (judiciary, parliamentary committees, law enforcement, CCS, etc) is developed.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Weak inter-institutional strands such as:•Criminal justice chain: police-prosecutors-judges;•Judiciary-OTA – on ex-post judicial control, digitalization of warrants;•Judiciary-Directorate for Personal Data Protection (DPDP)-Directorate for Security of Classified (DSCI) Information •Evaluation of the established procedures/standards for using, managing, handling, storing/keeping personal data and classified info by the judiciary•Judiciary-Parliament-CCS •Lack of material-technical resources that are required for the use of SIM within the MoI (e.g.non-existence of proper facilities and equipment for listening and transcription of communications, thus failing to ensure the secrecy and protection of human rights. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-06-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2023 most judicial practitioners working on criminal investigative matters have theoretical and practical knowledge on procedures and European standards for managing personal data and classified information. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF has continued working closely with the Judiciary, the Operative-Technical Agency (OTA) and the Agency for National Security (ANS) on developing and consolidating the system of judicial safeguards in implementing intrusive methods for information collection.In this regard, between 11-12 April in Veles, DCAF organised a coordination planning meeting on implementing the developed Guidelines for SIMs Data Destruction followed by an additional coordination meeting on 5 June in Skopje, with discussions focused on the practical and legal aspects of safeguarding, in line with the right to privacy and personal data protection. The working group has mapped out all steps and provided recommendations, addressing challenges in handling data gathered by intrusive methods for information collection. Committed to supporting judicial practitioners, the group aims to ensure timely and effective implementation of safeguarding procedures, aligned with European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) standards and best practices.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.7.1: Knowledge products related to local jurisprudence and on relevant ECHR case law are developed and made available to judges and prosecutors. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">There are no practical guidelines for judges and prosecutors that focuses on local jurisprudence or on relevant ECHR case law.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-06-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2023 at least one knowledge products is developed.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF supported the Academy in developing of the Collection of Case Law related to SIMs Authorisation and Implementation in North Macedonia. The finalised Collection is now available on the Academy’s website. It is intended to serve as a training resource for entry-level students at the Academy of Judges and Public Prosecutors. This collection comprises various judicial cases with implemented SIMs, presented and elaborated according to a previously prepared methodology, demonstrating how international standards and good practices are applied in each case. DCAF will continue to support the Academy in strengthening its training resources and capacities in future.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.9.2: Relevant experts from the Ministry of Interior receive mentoring to support them in performing duties.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The EU Member States that are Parties to the PCC Prüm Agreement already have the experience and routine of exchanging data. The Ministry of Interior will during the project identify where such experience/routine from these countries would be of added value.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-06-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By mid-2023, all requested mentoring by experts from EU Member States will be provided.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">From 16-18 April in Ljubljana, the 1st Meeting of the Thematic Working Group on the Practical and Technical Implementation of the PCC Prüm Agreement - Automated Exchange of Dactyloscopic Data was held. Representatives from the Forensics Examinations Department – Dactyloscopy Unit attended the workshop. They presented the current status, latest developments, plans, and requirements in for achieving  PCC Prüm operationalisation in the area of automated dactyloscopic data exchange. Their presentation included an  overview of their respective department and information on the AFIS (automated fingerprints identification) system. Participants had the opportunity to learn  about the technical preconditions for automated dactyloscopic data exchange and see its practical application  (1st and 2nd step data exchange). Special attention was given  to the evaluation procedure, with a walkthrough of the evaluation procedure for implementing the dactyloscopic data exchange provisions pursuant to the PCC Prüm Agreement. At the end of the meeting, evaluations of the non-EU PCC SEE Contracting Parties were conducted, and recommendations for next steps in becoming operational in the automated exchange of dactyloscopic data were  provided. On 18 April, back-to-back with the previous meeting, the 3rd Meeting of the Thematic Working Group on the Practical and Technical Implementation of the PCC Prüm Agreement - Automated Exchange of DNA Data was organised. Representatives from the Forensics Examinations Department – DNA labs were invited and shared relevant developments and plans regarding the implementation of automated DNA data exchange in North Macedonia, as well as their current hit management at both national and international levels. This meeting provided a platform for all working group participants to raise and address any topics of interest, such as how colleagues overcome specific challenges encountered in daily work, aspects of automated DNA data exchange, and how other countries perform specific tasks in their work process.While the Ministry of Interior (MoI) of North Macedonia has already identified several missing requirements and a preliminary fact-finding assessment was supported by the DCAF-hosted PCC SEE Secretariat in early 2019, the MoI has since addressed some of the missing capacities.Following the meeting in Ljubljana, between 26-28 June, DCAF deployed an international expert to Skopje to conduct an on-site assessment of automated biometric dactyloscopy data processing and exchange. The expert assessed the Ministry’s state of play concerning the normative/legal, organisational, and technical aspects, providing a report with concrete recommendations for improving the capacities. It is crucial for North Macedonia to adopt a comprehensive approach to identify and address all missing capacities necessary for operational dactyloscopy data exchange in line with PCC Prüm Agreement. The MoI is expected to appoint a working group to prepare a strategy and action plan, periodically monitoring its implementation, and making appropriate adjustments. The assessment report will serve as the basis for this preparation. The international expert will remain available to advise the working group on addressing the identified gaps.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.1.3: Gender Action Plan developed by MoD based on recommendations in the Gender-Self Assessment report and MoD increases its capacity to implement the Plan. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The MoD does not currently have a specific, evidence-based gender action plan aimed at enhancing gender equality in the institution based on an in-depth institutional gender analysis.  </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-06-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the first quarter of 2024, the MoD has a Gender Action Plan based on recommendations developed from a Gender Self-Assessment. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The Gender Self-Assessment process in the MoD and the Army has been successfully completed and the end-products (Report and Gender Action Plan) were endorsed. The Gender Action Plan of the MoD and the Army (2024-2028) is set to be implemented over the next four years.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.1.1: CSOs and Media receive trainings/mentoring programs on intelligence and security sector governance, accountability requirements and police integrity. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">CSOs and Media are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge and skills on intelligence sector reforms and accountability requirements, and police integrity to do monitoring and assessments of intelligence and law enforcement sector reforms.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-06-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025, at least 5 capacity building activities per year delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">As part of the DCAF’s work to enhance civilian oversight over security, a Workshop on Formal and Informal Civilian Oversight of the Security Sector: An International Law Perspective was organised between 13-15 May in Popova Shapka.Participants engaged in in-depth discussions on the intersection of International Law and Security Sector Reform, exploring key legal frameworks and international foundations aimed at improving the governance of the security sector.The discussions underscored the necessity for new legislative solutions to mandate and support increased civil society involvement in security sector reform. The session also highlighted the importance of enhancing coordination and information-sharing among the Ombudsperson office, civil society organizations, and the media. These reforms would enable all three entities to provide more comprehensive oversight and accountability.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report: July - September 2024</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter_EN_JUL-SEP_2024-20250306120350.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter 13: July - September 2024</narrative>
      </title>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2024-09-30"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.2.1: Committee Members and staffers (female and male) report improved understanding of intelligence oversight matters.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">A baseline survey of the new oversight committees’ MPs will be conducted to assess the level of knowledge and skills in oversight.  Organisational functions of Working Body staff are inadequate and prevent effective performance.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-08-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-09-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, 70% of new MPs report improved understanding of intelligence oversight matters .</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">During the transitional period when newly elected MPs take office, a robust staff structure is crucial to ensure the smooth functioning of oversight activities. To this end, DCAF launched a targeted training programme for staff supporting the three parliamentary intelligence and security committees. In August and September, three training sessions were held, offering tailored guidance on intelligence and security sector reforms in North Macedonia. The sessions also highlighted Parliament’s critical role in democratic oversight. DCAF will continue to provide training focused on developing skills to help staff to effectively guide and support new MPs through the oversight process.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.3: The Ministry of Interior of North Macedonia (MoI) has strategic and operational capacity to effectively build integrity in line with European values and good policing practice, enabling more effective oversight. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Section for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations, and Professional Standards (DICCIPS), in cooperation with DCAF, developed an Integrity Plan over the past three years. The Plan assesses the corruption risk of all job positions in the Ministry of Interior, in accordance with the Rulebook on systematization of job positions in the MoI, proposing measures aimed to reduce risk. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-08-08"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-08-09"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By end of the programme the MoI (DICCIPS) is successfully implementing the Integrity Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">On 8 August, DCAF experts met with the Ministry of Interior’s Internal Control Department to review and assess the progress of the MoI Integrity Plan implementation. The meeting covered the current status of the Plan, the measures being implemented by the Internal Control Department, and key lessons learned from the Plan’s implementation during the past year. Discussions also focused on how these insights can be incorporated into the revision of the Action Plan for the coming year (2025) to enhance its effectiveness.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.3.1: Shielded Room and protected workspace constructed in Parliament and equipment installed.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Parliament has no protected workspace and meeting facility to discuss and store classified information, impeding meaningful exchange of sensitive and classified information with security and intelligence services. Parliament, in Feb 2020, approved the establishment of the shielded room. Within its Phase I Programme DCAF allocated funds as a contribution towards the establishment of the Shielded Room and protected workplace. Due to Covid-19 the process was delayed throughout 2020. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-09-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-10-21"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2021 the Parliament has a Shielded Room and protected space Installed. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continued to support the Assembly in constructing and accrediting a Shielded Room and protected workspace for managing classified information. The construction is complete, and the accreditation process for the communication and information system is expected to be finalised before the official opening ceremony on 21 October at the Parliament of North Macedonia.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.9.2: Relevant experts from the Ministry of Interior receive mentoring to support them in performing duties.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The EU Member States that are Parties to the PCC Prüm Agreement already have the experience and routine of exchanging data. The Ministry of Interior will during the project identify where such experience/routine from these countries would be of added value.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-09-11"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-09-13"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DNA specialists, following their successful participation in DCAF’s capacity-building activities, which equipped them with new methods and software to advance their expertise, conducted internal research on "Familial Search as a Complementary Tool for the Identification of Unknown Offenders".They asked DCAF for support to participate in the 30th Congress of the International Society for Forensic Genetics in Santiago de Compostela, Spain, from 11-13 September. The congress offered a diverse programme, highlighting the latest advancements in DNA profiling and ethical considerations in forensics. The participants shared their expertise with global peers and gained valuable insights to enhance the quality of their work and improve data sharing under the PCC Prüm framework. They identified the need to establish an ethics commission within the Ministry to meet the EU's criteria for sharing and forwarding DNA profiles with other institutions and countries. This also includes addressing issues such as the retention period of DNA profiles in the database, data management methods, and legal regulations. During the congress, they also established connections with international companies offering state-of-the-art forensic genetics and DNA analysis equipment.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-09-19"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-09-20"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By mid-2023, all requested mentoring by experts from EU Member States will be provided.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Following an on-site assessment conducted by an Austrian expert in biometric data exchange from 26-27 June, DCAF organised a meeting on 19 September in Skopje to develop an Action Plan addressing gaps in automated biometric (DNA and fingerprint) data exchange.The meeting reviewed the assessment report, proposed steps, and recommendations, and outlined the next actions. Representatives from the Forensics Department agreed on the necessary technical steps to complete the TESTA connection, requiring broader support from the MoI and the Ministry of Digitalisation. DCAF will continue to support the Forensics Department in meeting the requirements for initiating international biometric data exchange under the PCC Prüm framework.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.1.2: By the first half of 2025, the mentored group of journalists develop journalist curriculum on informal oversight over the security/intelligence sector.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en"> In North Macedonia, there is still no specialised curriculum at university programs for journalists on reporting security matters.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-07-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-09-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Several workshops/meetings conducted for preparation of the curriculum by the end of 2025.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">In July, DCAF successfully launched the Training of Trainers (ToT) process: “Building Knowledge Transfer and Oversight Sustainability of CSOs and Media in North Macedonia” designed to empower civil society organizations (CSOs), media professionals and parliamentary staff focused on public relations with essential skills and advanced knowledge to effectively disseminate information on security sector governance and reform and strengthen oversight and accountability mechanisms.By enabling future trainers to educate and inform others within their institutions, organizations, and networks, DCAF aims to generate a more informed dissemination of SSR principles and practices in North Macedonia. The first ToT, held in Berovo from 11-13 July, focused on the fundamentals of andragogy, adult learning theories, and the characteristics of effective trainers. The second ToT, held in Strumica from 19-21 September, centred on VARK learning styles and methodologies for conducting training needs assessments. DCAF remains committed to enhancing the training capacities of CSO and media representatives in order to broaden the pool of trained individuals on SSG/R and oversight, contributing to sustainable good governance and accountability in the intelligence and security sector.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.4.2: Inter-institutional Protocols, harmonised Templates and Guidelines for different stages of SIM approval are drafted and submitted for approval by relevant institutions within the criminal justice chain.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Courts and prosecutorial offices have different (sometimes dated, or even contradictory) procedures and templates used in the authorisation of SIM. Harmonisation of practice and exchange of information are not in place to ensure effective authorisation of SIM, in agreement with new legislative provisions and European standards.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-09-16"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-09-18"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2022 working groups draft proposals, templates, and guidelines designed to unify and harmonise practice and submit them for approval.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">During DCAF's activities and discussions with judiciary members, several practical challenges in implementing Special Investigative Measures (SIMs) due to legislative inconsistencies were identified. To address these issues, DCAF held its first workshop with the judiciary group in Ohrid from 16-18 September, initiating a review of current amendments and developing new proposals for the Law on Criminal Procedure, with a focus on SIMs.The group, which includes members of the Ministry of Justice’s official Working Group, is committed to addressing legislative gaps to ensure a modern European criminal procedure that respects human rights while improving efficiency. This initiative aims to align North Macedonia's criminal procedure with Euro-Atlantic standards, particularly in areas such as privacy, data retention, judicial oversight, proportionality, transparency, and accountability in the use of Special Investigative Measures (SIMs).</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.6.1: A system for accountability in the use of intrusive methods (SIM), where different actors involved are aware of each other’s role and function in complementarity (judiciary, parliamentary committees, law enforcement, CCS, etc) is developed.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Weak inter-institutional strands such as:•Criminal justice chain: police-prosecutors-judges;•Judiciary-OTA – on ex-post judicial control, digitalization of warrants;•Judiciary-Directorate for Personal Data Protection (DPDP)-Directorate for Security of Classified (DSCI) Information •Evaluation of the established procedures/standards for using, managing, handling, storing/keeping personal data and classified info by the judiciary•Judiciary-Parliament-CCS •Lack of material-technical resources that are required for the use of SIM within the MoI (e.g.non-existence of proper facilities and equipment for listening and transcription of communications, thus failing to ensure the secrecy and protection of human rights. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-07-03"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-07-05"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2023 most judicial practitioners working on criminal investigative matters have theoretical and practical knowledge on procedures and European standards for managing personal data and classified information. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">In this regard, from 3-5 July in Mavrovo, DCAF organised the final workshop on implementing the newly developed Guidelines for SIMs Data Destruction. High-level discussions, attended by top management from all involved institutions, centred on the practical and legal aspects of safeguarding privacy and personal data. The working group outlined key steps and provided recommendations to address challenges in handling data collected through intrusive methods. Committed to supporting judicial practitioners, the group aims to ensure the timely and effective implementation of safeguarding procedures, in line with European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) standards and best practices.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report: October – December 2024</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter-14_EN_OCT-DEC_2024-20250404070433.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report: October – December 2024</narrative>
      </title>
      <category code="A08"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.3.2: MP’s, staffers and security personnel qualified on the use of the Shielded Room and protected workspace.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">New MPs elected in 2020 have no knowledge on how to secure and use classified documents&gt; they also have no knowledge on the use of a Shielded Room and protected space.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By end of 2021 all MPs, staffers and security personnel have undergone mandatory trainings on the use of the Shielded Room and protected workspace.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continues to support parliamentary staff in enhancing and institutionalising oversight of intelligence and security. During the transitional period when newly elected MPs take office, a robust staff structure is crucial to ensure the smooth functioning of oversight activities. To this end, DCAF launched a targeted training programme for staff supporting the three parliamentary intelligence and security committees. From October to December 2024, three additional one-day training sessions were held. The sessions focused on enhancing communication, analysis and advisory skills of the Parliamentary staff. DCAF will continue to provide training focused on developing skills to help staff to effectively guide and support new MPs through the oversight process.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.8.1: DICCIPS’ employees have updated knowledge and skills to perform their duties related to preventing corruption and integrity violations more efficiently within the MoI.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Over the last two years DCAF supported the MoI in the development and drafting of the Integrity Plan. Presently, the Integrity Plan is pending approval from the Minister of Interior. The Ministry of Interior (MoI) is amending the law on internal affairs to improve the internal control mechanisms that promote integrity. The new law will include integrity testing measures as a means of internal control, which will be applied to both current and future employees of the MoI. The MoI does not possess technical equipment to perform professional integrity testing, which will be a requirement in accordance to the new Law on Internal Affairs. In addition, the North Macedonian Police have revised their Code of Ethics in 2020.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, 80% of DICCIPS employees report increasing their capacities for conducting criminal and disciplinary investigations.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF organised two Training Courses on Criminal Investigations for Crimes Committed by Police Officers in Berovo from 17 to 19 October and in Ohrid from 31 October to 02 November. The trainings engaged two groups of 20 participants from the Department for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations, and Professional Standards and responded to the MoI’s need for strengthened capacities for conducting criminal investigations in line with the Law on Internal Affairs. Facilitated by judicial practitioners (three public prosecutors, two judges, and a defence lawyer), the training aimed to increase participants’ knowledge on conducting investigations and collecting evidence as well as enhance cooperation, communication, and coordination between the Department and the public prosecution and courts. Participants engaged in discussions with the experts, shared experiences, identified key challenges and gaps in communication and coordination with the judiciary, and proposed potential solutions for increasing the effectiveness and efficiency of criminal investigations. DCAF remains committed to support the Department for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations and Professional Standards to increase its investigative capacities and cooperation and coordination with the Department for Disciplinary Proceedings and Prosecutors Office.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-12-03"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-04"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, 80% of DICCIPS employees report increasing their capacities for conducting criminal and disciplinary investigations.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF supported the participation of the representatives of the MoI Department for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations and Professional Standards (DICCIPS) at the Regional Anti-Corruption Conference “Building Integrity from Within: Strengthening Internal Control for a Corruption-Free Future”, from 3 to 4 December 2024, in Chisinau Moldova. The conference brought representatives of security sector institutions from across Europe, including representatives from Ukraine, Estonia, Lithuania, Poland, Serbia, Romania, and North Macedonia, to exchange best practice on internal control mechanisms in law enforcement. The conference featured panels on the role of internal control units in national anti-corruption strategies, challenges and opportunities in building institutional integrity, regional cooperation on anti-corruption efforts, and emerging corruption threats and future trends. DCAF will continue to support regional efforts to enhance anti-corruption measures and promote integrity within security sector institutions.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.9.1: Selected employees from the Ministry of Interior successfully conclude vocational trainings.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Employees from the Ministry of Interior, e.g. the Section for Crime – Technical Analysis and Expertise, and the National Central Unit for Information Exchange, are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge to administer automated exchange of DNA data.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-11-14"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-11-15"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2023, relevant employees from the Ministry of Interior received the necessary vocational trainings.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">A Hybrid Workshop on "Y-STR – Procedures and Guidelines for the Interpretation and Evaluation of Y-STR Results" was held in Skopje from November 14 to 15. This workshop aimed to describe the method for evaluating and interpreting DNA profiles when determining Y chromosome haplotypes, as well as the phraseological interpretation of these results. This applies to profiles obtained through work in the DNA identification laboratory or those forwarded by another institution. Once finalized and internally approved, laboratory representatives will refer to these guidelines during their work to improve the quality of collected trace evidence.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-10-08"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-10-09"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2023, relevant employees from the Ministry of Interior received the necessary vocational trainings.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF organized a workshop on "Guidelines for the Interpretation and Evaluation of Kinship Analysis – Missing Persons, Unidentified Human Remains, and Crime Traces" in Skopje, held from October 8 to 9. The purpose of these guidelines is to outline the process for interpreting the results of familial and kinship connections during the analysis and comparison of DNA profiles. This includes profiles obtained at the DNA Laboratory of Reference Biological Material in the Registration Department, as well as those received from other institutions, both domestically and internationally. The guidelines provide a comprehensive explanation of the forensic-technical processing steps and aim to ensure accurate interpretation of kinship analysis for missing persons, unidentified human remains, and crime trace evidence.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.1.1: CSOs and Media receive trainings/mentoring programs on intelligence and security sector governance, accountability requirements and police integrity.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">CSOs and Media are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge and skills on intelligence sector reforms and accountability requirements, and police integrity to do monitoring and assessments of intelligence and law enforcement sector reforms.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-11-13"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-11-15"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025, at least 5 capacity building activities per year delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Between 13-15 November 2024, DCAF organized the third multi-stakeholder workshop on Privacy and Data Protection in the Digital Age. The event brought together formal and informal oversight actors, including civil society organisations (CSOs) and media representatives, members of Parliament (MPs), parliamentary staff, and members of the Ombudsperson’s office. Through a combination of theoretical presentations, hands-on exercises, and simulations, the workshop provided an in-depth exploration of privacy and data protection. Participants examined definitions, legal frameworks, and key challenges, with a particular focus on the impact of emerging technologies like AI and the Internet of Things. Principles like proportionality, necessity, transparency, and accountability were emphasized, alongside the indispensable role of both formal and informal security sector oversight mechanisms. These multi-stakeholder gatherings provide unique opportunity for networking, exchange of experiences and trust building between different oversight actors.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025, at least 5 capacity building activities per year delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF also continued with the Training of Trainers (ToT) programme, dedicated to enhancing the skills of representatives from CSOs, media, and the Parliamentary Channel in North Macedonia. The ToT #3 was organized between 24-26 October 2024 and focused on theories and types of instructional design, including developing effective training programs, curricula, and instructional frameworks. The ToT #4 was held between 19-21 December 2024 and covered training delivery techniques, including key aspects such as presentation, facilitation, and moderation techniques, with an emphasis on tailoring methods to different contexts and audiences.The initiative aims to empower CSOs and media professionals with advanced knowledge and skills to effectively disseminate information on security sector reform and governance across their organisations and networks while strengthening oversight and accountability mechanisms.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.2.6: The targeted staff at the Ombudsperson institution have a better understanding of their role as oversight actors.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Ombudsperson institution, although legally mandated for oversight over intelligence and security, still has no capacities to conduct proper oversight.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-12-16"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-17"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, at least 8 staff members of the Ombudsperson institution report improved practical and theoretical knowledge on how to conduct oversight over intelligence and security.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Between 16-17 December 2024, “Workshop on Strengthening Capacities for Independent Oversight of the Ombudsperson of North Macedonia” was organized. The workshop contained ability self-assessment session which allowed participants to evaluate their institutional strengths and areas for improvement. A moderated discussion focused on the necessity of developing a checklist and internal documents for conducting independent oversight over intelligence and security institutions and the specifics that the oversight by the Ombudsperson entails. Participants discussed expectations for these documents, explored potential content and structure, and outlined next steps for creating practical oversight tool.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.1.1: CSOs and Media receive trainings/mentoring programs on intelligence and security sector governance, accountability requirements and police integrity.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_X8NIvSOZjk" format="video/vnd.sealed.mpeg4">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Opening of a Shielded Room in the Parliament: why is it important?</narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Mini-documentary story </narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="mk"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2024-11-01"/>
      </document-link>
      <document-link url="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L92NWFZUOvk" format="video/vnd.sealed.mpeg4">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Who will protect the Ombudsperson's right to oversee the work of the police sector and intelligence services?</narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Mini-documentary story </narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="mk"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2024-10-01"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">CSOs and Media are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge and skills on intelligence sector reforms and accountability requirements, and police integrity to do monitoring and assessments of intelligence and law enforcement sector reforms.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">With respect to building public trust and increasing the visibility of reforms in the intelligence and security sector, DCAF continued cooperation with the TV production company by supporting their production of audio-visual mini-documentary stories. The videos combine storytelling with informational content intended to raise awareness and understanding among the general public about the progress of reforms in the intelligence and security sector. The mini-documentary stories are broadcasted on national TV in local languages. The mini-documentary story “Who will protect the Ombudsperson's right to oversee the work of the police sector and intelligence services?” (broadcast in October 2024) examines the necessary conditions for the Ombudsperson in North Macedonia to effectively fulfil its legally mandated oversight role over intelligence services. It also explores how to operationalize the Mechanism for Civilian Control over Police activities within the framework of the Ombudsperson's office, as well as their ongoing efforts to achieve accreditation with 'A' status, in compliance with the UN Paris Principles. Another mini-documentary story entitled “Opening of a Shielded Room in the Parliament: why is it important?”, aired in November 2024, captures the highlights from the Ceremonial Opening, where policymakers emphasize the importance of this facility in enhancing conditions for effective parliamentary oversight of security services and promoting greater accountability.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.3.1: Shielded Room and protected workspace constructed in Parliament and equipment installed.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Parliament has no protected workspace and meeting facility to discuss, and store classified information, impeding meaningful exchange of sensitive and classified information with security and intelligence services. Parliament, in Feb 2020, approved the establishment of the shielded room. Within its Phase I Programme DCAF allocated funds as a contribution towards the establishment of the Shielded Room and protected workplace. Due to Covid-19 the process was delayed throughout 2020.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-10-21"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-10-22"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2021 the Parliament has a Shielded Room and protected space Installed.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">As a result of the successful collaboration between DCAF and the Parliament of North Macedonia, the Shielded Room and Protected Workplace in the Parliament is officially open. On this occasion, a Ceremonial Opening took place in the Parliament on 21 October 2024. Designed to meet the highest security NATO and EU standards with most up-to-date equipment and cutting-edge technology, the Shielded Room ensures a secure environment for handling sensitive information. The facility reinforces the integrity of legislative processes by upholding confidentiality and accountability, while fostering a culture of security and trust. DCAF is grateful to the Parliament for their leadership and collaboration, as well as its commitment to democratic accountability, data integrity, and protection of sensitive information. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.1.3: Gender Action Plan developed by MoD based on recommendations in the Gender-Self Assessment report and MoD increases its capacity to implement the Plan.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The MoD does not currently have a specific, evidence-based gender action plan aimed at enhancing gender equality in the institution based on an in-depth institutional gender analysis.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, relevant staff have developed capacities to implement and monitor the Gender Action Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continued to support the development of the Gender Action Plan in the Ministry of Defence (MoD) and the Army. On 9 October 2024, representatives from DCAF’s Skopje office met with the Minister of Defense of North Macedonia, Mr Vlado Misajlovski. Discussion focused on ongoing processes within the MoD, supported through the DCAF’s Intelligence and Security Sector Reform Programme in North Macedonia, including the gender self-assessment process and the capacity building process of the Military Service for Security and Intelligence (MSSI). The meeting also emphasized DCAF's support to furthering gender equality in the defence through implementation of the Gender Action Plan (2024-2028) in the MoD and the Army of North Macedonia. Both Minister Misajlovski and the DCAF representatives reaffirmed the importance of continuing the reform processes and expressed their commitment to further strengthening their cooperation. They emphasized the value of sustained collaboration in advancing key reforms within the security sector.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-12-10"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-13"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, relevant staff have developed capacities to implement and monitor the Gender Action Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Following the Gender Self-Assessment process, the Ministry of Defense (MoD) took a significant step towards advancing gender equality by establishing a working group to implement the Gender Action Plan (2024–2028). To support this effort, DCAF, in collaboration with the Dutch Royal Army, organized a Working Visit to the Netherlands which took place between 10-13 December 2024. This visit offered Macedonian MoD and Army personnel a unique opportunity to learn from the Dutch Royal Army’s successful integration of gender perspectives into military operations and organizational culture. The program provided practical insights, best practices, and firsthand experiences and approaches to gender mainstreaming within the defence sector, which could be adapted to fit the Macedonian context. The Netherlands is widely regarded as a leader in this field, having successfully implemented its Defence Action Plan and demonstrated a strong commitment to embedding gender perspectives across all levels of its military sector. The working visit provided meaningful exchanges on institutional mechanisms, leadership engagement, and gender-responsive policies. DCAF will continue to support the MoD through the implementation process through capacity-building initiatives and expert guidance.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.6.1: A system for accountability in the use of intrusive methods (SIM), where different actors involved are aware of each other’s role and function in complementarity (judiciary, parliamentary committees, law enforcement, CCS, etc) is developed.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://jorm.gov.mk/izgotven-vodich-za-nishtene-na-podatoczite-sobrani-so-posebnite-istrazhni-merki/" format="text/plain">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="mk">Guideline on Retention and Destruction of Data Collected by SIMs</narrative>
        </title>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="mk"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2024-12-16"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Weak inter-institutional strands such as: Criminal justice chain: police-prosecutors-judges; Judiciary-OTA – on ex-post judicial control, digitalization of warrants; Judiciary-Directorate for Personal Data Protection (DPDP)-Directorate for Security of Classified (DSCI) Information; Evaluation of the established procedures/standards for using, managing, handling, storing/keeping personal data and classified info by the judiciary; Judiciary-Parliament-CCS; Lack of material-technical resources that are required for the use of SIM within the MoI e.g. non-existence of proper facilities and equipment for listening and transcription of communications, thus failing to ensure the secrecy and protection of human rights.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-12-16"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-17"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2023 most judicial practitioners working on criminal investigative matters have theoretical and practical knowledge on procedures and European standards for managing personal data and classified information. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The final roundtable discussion and launch of the Guideline on Retention and Destruction of Data Collected by SIMs took place in Skopje on December 16. The newly developed guide systematizes and outlines procedures for storing and destroying data collected through Special Investigative Measures (SIMs). It incorporates international standards for data retention and destruction, addresses the challenges, obstacles, and limitations that may hinder the process, and specifies the individuals or entities responsible for the destruction process, along with their roles, duties, and responsibilities. This guideline was created at the request of the Basic Criminal Court – Skopje, in line with recommendations from the Agency for the Protection of Personal Data, following their supervisory work in the area of communications monitoring. The guide was developed through a series of workshops organized from June 2023 to October 2024, as part of the Intelligence and Security Sector Reform Program in the Republic of North Macedonia, implemented by DCAF.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-11-20"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-11-22"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2023 most judicial practitioners working on criminal investigative matters have theoretical and practical knowledge on procedures and European standards for managing personal data and classified information.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">During DCAF's activities and discussions with members of the judiciary, several practical challenges in implementing Special Investigative Measures (SIMs) were identified, primarily due to legislative inconsistencies. To address these challenges, DCAF hosted its second workshop with the judiciary group in Gevgelija from 20 to 22 November 2024. This workshop focused on reviewing current amendments and developing new proposals for the Law on Criminal Procedure, specifically regarding SIMs. The group, which includes members from the Ministry of Justice's official Working Group, is dedicated to addressing legislative gaps to ensure a modern, European-standard criminal procedure that upholds human rights while enhancing efficiency. This initiative seeks to align North Macedonia's criminal procedures with Euro-Atlantic standards, particularly in areas such as privacy, data retention, judicial oversight, proportionality, transparency, and accountability in the use of Special Investigative Measures (SIMs).</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="2">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Main Results 2024</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/DCAF-IntelSSR-in-NMK_Annual-Operational-Report-Jan-Dec-2024_final-20250502070510.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">2024 Annual Report </narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">2024 Annual Report on the Intelligence &amp; Security Sector Reform Programme in the Republic of North Macedonia (2021-2026)</narrative>
      </description>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2025-04-30"/>
    </document-link>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/Annex-1---Performance-According-to-Result-Framework-20250502070526.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Annex 1_2024 Annual Report</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Annex 1_Performance According to Results Framework of the 2024 Annual Report on the Intelligence &amp; Security Sector Reform Programme in the Republic of North Macedonia (2021-2026)</narrative>
      </description>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2025-04-30"/>
    </document-link>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/Annex-2---Transversal-Themes-20250502070541.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Annex 2_2024 Annual Report</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Annex 2_Transversal Themes of the 2024 Annual Report on the Intelligence &amp; Security Sector Reform Programme in the Republic of North Macedonia (2021-2026)</narrative>
      </description>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2025-04-30"/>
    </document-link>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/Annex-3---Risk-assessment-update-20250502070553.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Annex 3_2024 Annual Report</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Annex 3_ Report Risk Assessment Update of the 2024 Annual Report on the Intelligence &amp; Security Sector Reform Programme in the Republic of North Macedonia (2021-2026)</narrative>
      </description>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2025-04-30"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.1 (b):  Amended laws, by-laws and procedures on intelligence implemented by oversight sector actors.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The current law, by-laws and procedures are not suitable to allow for effective oversight of the intelligence services. In addition, legally mandated oversight bodies are functioning but not sufficiently effective. The formal relationship between the Parliament and the Council for Civilian Supervision remains inadequate as a result.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-13"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-16"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The Guidelines for the Destruction of Data Collected through Special Investigative Measures (SIMs) were developed following an inclusive multi-stakeholder process with a working group consisting of judicial practitioners and experts and received broad approval across the judiciary.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The Committee on Oversight of the Implementation of Measures for Interception of Communications strengthened its regulatory framework by adopting Rules of Procedure, which incorporate the Common Minimum Standards (CMS) for Conducting Control and Oversight Visits in the Security and Intelligence Institutions of the Republic of North Macedonia.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-02-05"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Security operating procedures for Shielded Room that were drafted through an inclusive process with the Parliament, the Directorate for Security of Classified Information (DSCI), and the MoI, along with the   Statement for Security Needs and Security Assessment were handed over to DSCI and based on these documents the Shielded Room was smoothly accredited in 2024. After the accreditation in 2024, these documents are put into practical usage. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.3: All missing requirements and standards, for automated exchange of biometric (DNA) data pursuant to the PCC Prüm Agreement are in place and are sufficient for exchange.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Ministry of Interior has established a solid normative base in the field of DNA exchange, however not yet sufficient to initiate automated exchange of such data, pursuant to the PCC Prüm Agreement.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The Department for Forensic Examinations at the MoI has met all necessary legal, technical, and operational requirements and is fully prepared to initiate the international automated exchange of biometric data (DNA and dactyloscopy) under the PCC Prüm framework. From a technical perspective, the required firewall infrastructure (hardware) have been successfully established. Legally, internal guideline modifications have been made in accordance with the PCC Prüm framework.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.3: The Ministry of Interior of North Macedonia (MoI) has strategic and operational capacity to effectively build integrity in line with European values and good policing practice, enabling more effective oversight.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Section for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations, and Professional Standards (DICCIPS), in cooperation with DCAF, developed an Integrity Plan over the past three years. The Plan assesses the corruption risk of all job positions in the Ministry of Interior, in accordance with the Rulebook on systematization of job positions in the MoI, proposing measures aimed to reduce risk.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The second Annual Report was issued by MoI on the implementation of its Integrity Plan (2023 – 2025) which indicates 90% implementation rate, with all trainings, controls, and other activities performed. Additionally, over 40 police inspectors from the MoI’s Department for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations, and Professional Standards (DICCIPS) were trained to strengthen their criminal investigation capacities, in accordance with the Law on Internal Affairs. In 2024, DICCIPS initiated investigations into 1,366 cases of alleged illegal, unprofessional, and unethical conduct, as well as abuse of official position, reflecting a 10.6% increase compared to the previous year.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator # 2.1: Quality and frequency of direct oversight interaction between the Parliament and intelligence services increased to meet oversight effectiveness.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Cooperation between the Parliament and security and intelligence services exists but does not meet full oversight needs.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">After the consolidation of the new Parliament following the 2024 elections and the establishment of new Committees with revised compositions, three oversight-related activities were conducted. Four parliamentary staff members were trained in communication and advisory skills to support new MPs in the oversight process. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Shielded Room and Protected Workplace was constructed and established in the Parliament. The Parliament is equipped with secure facility and protective systems for handling sensitive data and confidential information during the oversight activities. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.5: Recommendations from the GSA process translated into Gender Action Plan with the capacity to be configured as a complementary part of the institutional gender activities, plans and strategies of the MoD</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Ministry of Defense and Army do not have a Gender Action Plan based on a thorough institutional assessment.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The Gender Action Plan (2024-2028) was officially adopted.  It is a strategic document, setting clear objectives, actions and practical steps to overcome identified barriers to gender mainstreaming and inclusivity in the MoD and Army of North Macedonia.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-06-03"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">A new MoD working group, comprising 16 administrative personnel from MoD, along with civilian and military staff from the Army (10 women and 6 men), has been established to implement and monitor the implementation of the Gender Action Plan (2024–2028). </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">A new systematization has been established in the MoD and the Army, which contributes to strengthening the gender structure in the MoD and the Army as outlined in the Gender Action Plan.  This includes a minimum of three positions dedicated to gender equality within the MoD's Support Sector and a designated Advisor for Gender Equality in the Cabinet of the General Staff.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.1: Public can debate and challenge the content of reports produced by intelligence and law enforcement actors.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The intelligence sector reforms and accountability are not sufficiently and publicly debated and professionally addressed by media and CSOs.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">14 representatives from CSOs and media that were trained throughout 2023, started a ToT programme in 2024 in order to continue disseminating the acquired knowledge among their peers, organizations and networks.  Guidelines for Informal Civilian Oversight of Intelligence and Security conducted by CSOs and Media in North Macedonia was updated as a joint product to reflect the new realities.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-10-02"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Three Gender Talks (moderated discussions) were organised (one in 2023 and two in 2024) in cooperation with partner CSO UNI-FORM with interlocutors from intelligence agencies, MoI and MoD. Each Gender Talk was attended by more than 30 participants (representatives of the intelligence and security institutions and representatives of CSOs and media organizations/outlets).</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-04-03"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Roadmap with Performance Indicators for Assessing Transparency, Accountability, and Effectiveness in the Intelligence and Security Sector of North Macedonia was published after a two-year development process led by a partner CSO, with input from oversight actors and intelligence institutions. This Roadmap reflects and summarizes the practical and instrumental findings based on evidence and qualitative primary data retrieved from interviews, open-ended questionnaires and nominal group discussions with representatives from the intelligence and security sector and independent actors. A video was prepared by partner media organization in 2024 to promote the roadmap. The roadmap was already used throughout 2024 during trainings with CSOs/media and parliamentary staff on how to use the indicators to monitor the work of the intelligence and security institutions. It will be widely promoted throughout 2025.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.2: Increased consistency of judicial practice (prosecutors and judges) in authorization and review of intrusive methods (intrusive methods to be based on law, be non-discriminatory, have a legitimate aim, and be a “necessary” and “proportional” response)</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The ECHR case law is not regularly observed by prosecutors and judges in the request and authorisation of intrusive methods. The judicial practice (interpretation and application of law by prosecutors and judges) in authorization of intrusive methods is still not consistent and adequate.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The reports from the Public Prosecutor’s Office in 2023 indicate there was an increase in cases where special investigative measures (SIM) were implemented compared to previous years that showcased consistent decline.   However, despite this increase, the number of individuals with established identities subjected to these measures saw only a slight uptick.  Regarding criminal cases covered by special investigative measures, there is a decrease in the number from 136 in 2022 to 93 in 2023. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-09-04"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Collection of Case-Law on SIMs in North Macedonia was developed throughout 2023 and 2024. It was made available on the Academy’s website in local languages for use by the students and practitioners as additional educational tool and useful resource material. The case law will assist current and future judges and prosecutors to act in a consistent manner when resorting to the use of SIMs.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Trainers from the Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors (AJPP) utilized the skills gained from DCAF's capacity-building programs to deliver 22 academic hours of training on the implementation of measures for the interception of communications, along with 5 additional sessions on topics including organized crime, corruption, financial crime, custody, ethics, hate crime, and confiscation throughout 2024. The Benchbook has been distributed to all 97 students of the AJPP's future judges and public prosecutors. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.2: Media coverage and CSO research paper mentioning the topic of intelligence reform, integrity and accountability</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual reporting by intelligence and security sector institutions and oversight actors is not sufficiently comprehensive, appropriate, and transparent.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Three in-depth stories/mini-TV documentaries (eight to 12 minutes each), related to intelligence and security sector reform aired as part of the “360 Degrees” TV show on Macedonian Radio-television (MRT). These mini documentaries were also shared and extensively promoted on the website, Facebook page, and YouTube channel of 360 Degrees, as well on DCAF’s official website, social media and YouTube channel. They helped increase the Programme’s visibility and informed the broader public on the progress of reforms in the intelligence and security sector. The mini documentaries attracted significant viewership and engagement, with each video receiving more than 1K views on both YouTube and Facebook.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-10-21"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The Ceremonial Opening of the Shielded Room and Protected Workplace in the Parliament was covered by a range of local mainstream media (TV channels, newspapers, and media portals). In addition, there was significant engagement on social media (via Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn) with content shared/re-shared and tweeted/re-tweeted on DCAF’s and participants’ social media profiles, including the ones of policymakers. The event was additionally summarised in two short documentaries produced by 360 Degrees and the Parliamentary Channel. This extensive coverage indicates significant public attention and interest in the topic of oversight.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-09-23"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">There is an increase in reporting on intelligence and security matters by the CSO and media group that attends the trainings for civilian oversight. For instance, TELMA TV produced 45-minute video documentary examining the announced merger of the Intelligence Agency and the National Security Agency (NSA) into a single entity. The same TV channel also broadcasted series of reports (well-informed videos) on the controversial election process of the members of the Council of Civilian Supervision.  ALFA TV produced a compelling live broadcast episode addressing the potential merger of the Intelligence Agency (IA) and the National Security Agency (NSA).</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.3: Transparency, towards the public is improved for the overall work of the intelligence and law enforcement actors, respecting the limits of classified information and personal data protection (GDPR).</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual reporting by intelligence and security sector institutions and oversight actors is not sufficiently comprehensive, appropriate, and transparent.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-15"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Security sector institutions and intelligence agencies have demonstrated a consistent commitment to transparency, as reflected in their active participation in DCAF events, including Gender Talks and interviews for mini documentaries.  A monitoring report conducted with CSOs and the media training group revealed that the gap between civil society and state institutions is shrinking, as evidenced by increased access to Ministers and Directors of intelligence and security sector institutions—previously less attainable for interviews and meetings.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-05-13"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The Forensics Department published the Brochure/Service Catalogue on Forensics Services. It serves as an informative tool for justice institutions to get more information on valuable forensics services. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2024-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2024-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Guide for Developing Annual Reports in Security and Intelligence Services and Control and Oversight Institutions was developed through a series of multi-stakeholder workshops with 18 public institutions participating. It aims to improve the reporting standards within the institutions and was internally shared within the intelligence and security institutions and has been endorsed by intelligence leadership as a valuable and effective tool. OTA has already started using the guidelines when preparing their annual reports. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report: January - March 2025</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter-15_EN_JAN-MAR-2025-20250604090636.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF Quarterly Newsletter: January - March 2025</narrative>
      </title>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2025-05-30"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.3.2: MP’s, staffers and security personnel qualified on the use of the Shielded Room and protected workspace.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">New MPs elected in 2020 have no knowledge on how to secure and use classified documents&gt; they also have no knowledge on the use of a Shielded Room and protected space.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-01-27"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-02-25"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By end of 2021 all MPs, staffers and security personnel have undergone mandatory trainings on the use of the Shielded Room and protected workspace.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continues to support parliamentary staff in enhancing and institutionalising oversight of intelligence and security. After several targeted trainings, DCAF organised two workshops on Developing a Framework for Communication, Analytical, and Advisory Skills, held in Veles on 27–28 January and 24–25 February 2025. These workshops aimed to strengthen the capacity of parliamentary staff to effectively analyse security-related information, provide strategic advice, and communicate oversight findings in a clear and compelling manner. The sessions also prompted peer learning and cross-institutional exchange of practical experiences.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.1.1: CSOs and Media receive trainings/mentoring programs on intelligence and security sector governance, accountability requirements and police integrity.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">CSOs and Media are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge and skills on intelligence sector reforms and accountability requirements, and police integrity to do monitoring and assessments of intelligence and law enforcement sector reforms.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-01-23"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-01-25"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025, at least 5 capacity building activities per year delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF also continued with the Training of Trainers (ToT) programme, dedicated to enhancing the skills of representatives from CSOs, media, and the Parliamentary Channel in North Macedonia. Between 23–25 January 2025, ToT #5 was held in Veles. The ToT #5 included focused modules on learning retention techniques, voice and diction, effective language and communication style, body language, and the application of rhetorical principles to strengthen clarity, persuasion, and audience engagement.The initiative aims to empower CSOs and media professionals with advanced knowledge and skills to effectively disseminate information on security sector reform and governance across their organisations and networks while strengthening oversight and accountability mechanisms.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.2.6: The targeted staff at the Ombudsperson institution have a better understanding of their role as oversight actors.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Ombudsperson institution, although legally mandated for oversight over intelligence and security, still has no capacities to conduct proper oversight.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-02-10"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-02-11"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, at least 8 staff members of the Ombudsperson institution report improved practical and theoretical knowledge on how to conduct oversight over intelligence and security.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Between 10-11 February 2025 in Veles, a Workshop for Development of the Checklist for Conducting Oversight Visits by the Ombudsperson took place. The event provided participants with comparative insights, practical tools, and interactive exercises to enhance their understanding and capacity for effective oversight, including the development of internal procedures and simulation of real-world oversight practices. The workshop focused on structuring and finalizing a standardized tool to guide and enhance the effectiveness of oversight visits by the Ombudsperson in North Macedonia. Once finalized, the checklist will be intended to serve as a practical framework to ensure that all critical aspects of oversight were systematically addressed. The workshop facilitated discussions among experts and stakeholders to ensure that the checklist aligned with legal mandates, operational needs, and global standards for oversight and governance.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.5.2: DCAF provides expert advice to support relevant experts from the Ministry of Interior, and other relevant institutions if necessary, in drafting the normative/legal documents.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://jorm.gov.mk/izgotven-vodich-za-nishtene-na-podatoczite-sobrani-so-posebnite-istrazhni-merki/" format="text/plain">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="mk">Guideline on Retention and Destruction of Data Collected by SIMs</narrative>
        </title>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="mk"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2024-12-16"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF currently does not provide expert advice to experts in the MoI on this topic. The EU Member States that are Parties to the PCC Prüm Agreement have already undergone all required normative/legal changes when joining the EU Prüm framework. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-03-26"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-03-28"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2022, all requested expert advice to support the drafting of necessary normative/legal documents will be provided.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The first meeting of the Thematic Working Group on implementing the PCC Prüm Agreement focusing on automated Vehicle Registration Data (VRD) exchange, took place in Vienna from 26 to 28 March 2025. Representatives from North Macedonia’s Ministry of Interior, including the Civil Affairs and Telecommunications Departments, actively participated, presenting the country’s progress, plans, and key needs for operationalising automated VRD exchange under PCC Prüm. With DCAF’s support, the Ministry has completed all necessary preparations to connect to the EU’s secure TESTA-ng network. In coordination with the newly established Ministry of Digital Transformation, the designated national Point of Contact to DG DIGIT, the Ministry is well-positioned for integration. TESTA-ng supports secure, automated exchange of biometric and identification data—including DNA, fingerprints, and vehicle registration—within the PCC SEE framework, also known as “mini Prüm.”</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.3.1: Independent working group produce meaningful monitoring reports.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_X8NIvSOZjk" format="video/vnd.sealed.mpeg4">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Opening of a Shielded Room in the Parliament: why is it important?</narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Mini-documentary story </narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="mk"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2024-11-01"/>
      </document-link>
      <document-link url="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L92NWFZUOvk" format="video/vnd.sealed.mpeg4">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Who will protect the Ombudsperson's right to oversee the work of the police sector and intelligence services?</narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Mini-documentary story </narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="mk"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2024-10-01"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The annual report of public prosecutor is the only source of information about use of SIM (number or requests and number of approved warrants) in criminal investigation. There is no publicly available information allowing an assessment of the use of SIM and judicial authorisation of SIM. Last report published was in 2018.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-03-12"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-03-25"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">At least one monitoring report per year produced and shared with public and relevant institutions.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">On 12 March 2025, DCAF launched a research initiative on judicial practices related to the authorisation and implementation of Special Investigative Measures (SIMs) in North Macedonia. Initiated at the request of the Academy of Judges and Public Prosecutors during Judicial Steering Group meetings, the initiative aims to enhance transparency and accountability in the use of SIMs. To support this effort, DCAF helped the Academy develop a comprehensive methodology of the research. This jointly agreed tool enables systematic analysis of judicial practices—both quantitative and qualitative—based on real case law and decisions. It also serves as a monitoring framework for ongoing evaluation of SIM authorisation and implementation.The research will be carried out by a working group comprising Academy representatives and members of the Judicial Group of Judges and Prosecutors. The research started with focus groups, which were held in Skopje on 24 and 25 March 2025 bringing together judges, prosecutors, Ministry of Interior officials, and legal experts to provide input and enrich the research with practical insights. As a next step of the research process, several workshops with the working group will be held to analyze the results from the interviews and the desktop research, review and compare the collected data, and conceptualize and draft the research report.  </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.1.1: Regular multi-stakeholder meetings and joint trainings/workshops are held and are attended by a gender-diverse group from all relevant institutions.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Insufficient cooperation between intelligence/security services and legally mandated oversight actors.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-03-10"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-03-14"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Each multi-stakeholder event has at least 30% female participation.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Between 10 - 14 March 2025 in Gevgelija, DCAF organized a Training of Trainers (ToT) for representatives of the Military Service for Security and Intelligence (MSSI) within the Ministry of Defence. The training enhanced the expertise of the MSSI personnel by strengthening and expanding their knowledge of advanced methodologies for delivering instruction on military intelligence and good governance. The sessions were accompanied by practical mock cases and simulation exercises. Following the completion of the advanced ToT, two comprehensive courses will be delivered to MSSI staff by the trained personnel, allowing them to apply their newly acquired skills in practice.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.1.3: Gender Action Plan developed by MoD based on recommendations in the Gender-Self Assessment report and MoD increases its capacity to implement the Plan.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The MoD does not currently have a specific, evidence-based gender action plan aimed at enhancing gender equality in the institution based on an in-depth institutional gender analysis.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-02-10"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-02-11"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, relevant staff have developed capacities to implement and monitor the Gender Action Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">A workshop on revising the Ministry of Defence (MoD) Gender Action Plan (GAP) was held in Veles from 10–11 February 2025, bringing together working group members from the MoD and the Army of North Macedonia. The GAP serves as a strategic framework outlining measures, objectives, and accountability mechanisms to promote inclusiveness, equality, and alignment with international standards. Due to recent structural changes within the MoD, the workshop focused on reviewing outdated sections and enhancing the GAP’s practical relevance. It also provided a platform for participants to contribute to improving the document’s clarity, effectiveness, and applicability as a planning and decision-making tool. DCAF will continue to support the MoD in the implementation of the revised GAP.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.8.1: DICCIPS’ employees have updated knowledge and skills to perform their duties related to preventing corruption and integrity violations more efficiently within the MoI.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://mvr.gov.mk/Upload/Editor_Upload/ENG_%D0%98%D0%97%D0%92%D0%95%D0%A8%D0%A2%D0%90%D0%88%202024.pdf" format="application/pdf">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">2024 Annual Report on implementation of the Integrity Action plan </narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">2024 Report on the Realisation of the Action Plan for Implementing the Integrity Plan of the Ministry of Interior 2023-2025</narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="en"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2025-02-17"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Over the last two years DCAF supported the MoI in the development and drafting of the Integrity Plan. Presently, the Integrity Plan is pending approval from the Minister of Interior. The Ministry of Interior (MoI) is amending the law on internal affairs to improve the internal control mechanisms that promote integrity. The new law will include integrity testing measures as a means of internal control, which will be applied to both current and future employees of the MoI. The MoI does not possess technical equipment to perform professional integrity testing, which will be a requirement in accordance to the new Law on Internal Affairs. In addition, the North Macedonian Police have revised their Code of Ethics in 2020.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-01-30"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-03-05"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, 80% of DICCIPS employees report increasing their capacities for conducting criminal and disciplinary investigations.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">With DCAF’s support, the implementation of the Ministry of the Interior’s Integrity Plan 2023–2025 continues to advance. By providing strategic guidance and sustained assistance, DCAF played a key role in facilitating the implementation, monitoring, and evaluation of the plan. Following a DCAF-organized workshop held from 30 January to 1 February to assess the second year of implementation, the Internal Control Department released its second annual public report. This comprehensive report is available on the Ministry’s website in Macedonian, Albanian, and English. Looking ahead, the Internal Control Department remains committed to executing the 2025 Action Plan, with DCAF continuing to provide support in all phases of implementation, monitoring, and evaluation.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-03-05"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-03-06"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, 80% of DICCIPS employees report increasing their capacities for conducting criminal and disciplinary investigations.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">In line with DCAF’s Programme priorities to strengthen internal control and prevent corruption within the Ministry of Interior (MoI), a high-level Roundtable on Police Integrity: Roles and Responsibilities of Police Managers was held on 5 March 2025. The event gathered Assistant Ministers and Heads of Sectors of Internal Affairs to discuss managerial responsibilities in promoting integrity and accountability. The roundtable highlighted the importance of leadership in fostering ethical conduct, sharing best practices, and advancing anti-corruption efforts. As the first event of its kind for mid- and senior-level MoI management, it set the foundation for an annual platform to support professional and ethical policing.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report: July – September 2026</narrative>
    </title>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.1 All institutions - Indicator #2.1.3: Gender Action Plan developed by MoD based on recommendations in the Gender-Self Assessment report and MoD increases its capacity to implement the Plan.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The MoD does not currently have a specific, evidence-based gender action plan aimed at enhancing gender equality in the institution based on an in-depth institutional gender analysis.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-09-10"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-09-11"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, relevant staff have developed capacities to implement and monitor the Gender Action Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continued its cooperation with the Ministry of Defence of North Macedonia (MoD) focused on supporting the implementation of the Ministry’s Gender Action Plan (GAP) 2024–2028. As part of the GAP, DCAF supported the development of the Training Manual for Gender Trainers and organized coordinative development session on 10 September 2026 with MoD and Army representatives. The Training Manual for Gender Trainers is designed to provide a standardized training methodology and serve as practical resource for certified trainers, combining gender-related content with adult-learning principles to strengthen the delivery of gender training across the defence sector. The Manual will provide certified trainers in the Ministry and the Army with unified modules for Basic Gender Training and Pre-deployment Gender Training.  Advancing capacities of 14 MoD gender trainers.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.4 Council for Civilian Supervision (CCS) - Indicator #2.4.1: The CCS is fully established and functional.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Lack of proper working conditions impede the functioning of the CCS. The CCS was not able to access funding from the Parliament due to flaws in the LIC legislation. The Parties within the Parliament were not able/willing to find a solution to amend the legislation.  By mid-2020 both the chair and three members had resigned, and one member is still without a security clearance.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-07-05"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-07-07"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By end of 2026, CCS members have received training on their roles.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continues to build the capacities of the members of the newly established Council of Civilian Supervision (CCS) to achieve functional and independent oversight of security and intelligence services. From 5 to 7 July 2026, DCAF organised a working visit to the Duch Review Committee on the Intelligence and Security Services in The Hague, Netherlands for CCS members to exchange good practices and lessons learned on relevant legislation, oversight and operational management. Presentations and discussions focused on complaint handling and oversight of the interception of communications done by the Dutch Review Committee, as well as strengthening international cooperation and networking among supervisory bodies. The visit to this relevant international oversight body served as reference model as DCAF will provide continuous support to CCS members to strengthen their oversight function and democratic accountability over the implementation of communications interception measures in the country.  Six appointed CCS members attend capacity building activities for enhancing their oversight roles.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 3.1 CSOs and Media - Indicator #3.1.1: CSOs and Media receive trainings/mentoring programs on intelligence and security sector governance, accountability requirements and police integrity.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">CSOs and Media are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge and skills on intelligence sector reforms and accountability requirements, and police integrity to do monitoring and assessments of intelligence and law enforcement sector reforms.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-07-30"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-09-26"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025, at least 5 capacity building activities per year delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Throughout the year DCAF was organising advanced training sessions dedicated to strengthening the capacities of representatives from CSOs, media, and the Parliamentary staff to understand and monitor the impact of new technologies on the security sector, and to enhance their role in democratic oversight and public accountability. The third advanced training course on New Technologies and Civilian Oversight was organised from 30 July to 1 August 2026 in Berovo and focused on open-source intelligence (OSINT) as a tool for democratic oversight of the security sector. Through group discussions and case studies participants analysed OSINT methodologies and tools and its role in parliamentary oversight, civic oversight, and investigative journalism. As a follow up, the fourth and final training was held from 24 to 26 September 2026 in Strumica and discussed how AI, algorithms, biometrics, integrated databases, and private providers are changing security. Guided by mentors, participants analysed the security sector as a digital “black box” and practiced using OSINT as a tool for monitoring, investigating, and verifying institutional claims. As a final outcome, CSOs and media professionals under the DCAF programme are equipped with specific knowledge and skills to strengthen civilian oversight and further improve monitoring and reporting on the security sector governance and accountability in the new digital era.   This quarter, 2 capacity building activities were delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-09-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-11-11"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025, at least 5 capacity building activities per year delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF and Goce Delčev University in Štip (UGD) have jointly developed a university-level micro-qualification programme in Security Sector Governance and Oversight, which began in September 2026 and will run until November 2026. The cooperation began with the joint development of training modules and progressed through a curriculum design between UGD academic staff and CSO and media actors. The programme combines the academic expertise of UGD professors with the practical experience of trainers from civil society and the media who have completed DCAF’s Training of Trainers programme. This collaboration connects academic learning with practical knowledge of security sector governance and democratic oversight. The goal of the academic programme is to strengthen the knowledge and capacities of current and future oversight actors (from CSO and media) and supports more informed, effective and sustainable democratic oversight of the security sector.One academic course delivered by CSOs and Media representatives in cooperation with Goce Delčev University in Štip.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 1.5 – Strengthened normative/legal capacities for automated exchange of biometric (DNA and dactyloscopic) data - Indicator #1.5.2: DCAF provides expert advice to support relevant experts from the Ministry of Interior, and other relevant institutions if necessary, in drafting the normative/legal documents. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF currently does not provide expert advice to experts in the MoI on this topic. The EU Member States that are Parties to the PCC Prüm Agreement have already undergone all required normative/legal changes when joining the EU Prüm framework. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-08-24"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-08-27"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of the programme, all requested expert advice to support the drafting of necessary normative/legal documents will be provided.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Building upon DCAF’s multi-year support to the Ministry of Interior (MoI) for establishing solid normative, organisational and technical capacities for automated biometric data exchange under the PCC Prüm framework, DCAF initiated multi-phased assessment for analysing national capacities for automated vehicle registration data (VRD) exchange with EU countries and PCC Prüm signatories. The on-site part of the assessment took place from 24 to 27 August in Skopje aimed at assessing the existing operational and technical aspects of the vehicle registration system, and the legal framework and procedures required for automated VRD exchange under the PCC Prüm framework. The assessment findings covering legal, institutional, operational and technical aspects of VRD exchange will identify capacity gaps and practical needs that must be addressed to enable effective operational participation in the automated exchange in future. The expert assessment team also met with representatives of the Austrian Embassy to discuss how the respective partners could jointly support and encourage further reforms within the MoI related to the implementation of the PCC Prüm framework. DCAF will offer capacity building support to the MoI for automated VRD exchange in 2027 based on the recommendations from the assessment report produced by the end of the year.  Three experts hired to assess automated vehicle registration data exchange capacities and normative framework. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report: April – June 2026</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter-20_EN_APR-JUN-2026-20260902120901.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report: April – June 2026</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter 20 of the Intelligence and Security Sector Reform Programme in the Republic of North Macedonia (2021-2026) for the period April – June 2026</narrative>
      </description>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2026-08-21"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.1 All institutions - Indicator #2.1.3: Gender Action Plan developed by MoD based on recommendations in the Gender-Self Assessment report and MoD increases its capacity to implement the Plan.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The MoD does not currently have a specific, evidence-based gender action plan aimed at enhancing gender equality in the institution based on an in-depth institutional gender analysis.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-06-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-06-02"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, relevant staff have developed capacities to implement and monitor the Gender Action Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continued with the enhancement of skills of selected trainers from the Ministry of Defense and the Army of North Macedonia to deliver gender-sensitive trainings on harassment prevention and response, as part of the activities outlined in the Gender Action Plan (2024–2028). The third Module of the training of trainers (ToT) on Workplace Harassment Protection, held on 1 and 2 June 2026 in Veles, focused on deeper understanding and recognition of harassment in the workplace, the transfer of knowledge on gender perspectives and intersectionality, and advancement of training delivery skills including leadership roles, challenges and training evaluation. Through role-plays and team presentations participants enhanced their knowledge and skills to tackle different situations of workplace harassment, practiced joint delivery, motivating participants and giving and receiving feedback. The ultimate goal of the ToT process is to establish mobile training teams within the MoD and the Army, capable of supporting personnel in recognizing, preventing, and appropriately responding to workplace harassment.  Advancing capacities of 14 MoD gender trainers.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.8 – MoI – DICCIPS integrity testing: Capacity building activities (trainings/study visits and expert support, technical equipment) provided to the “Section for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations and Professional Standards (DICCIPS)” to effectively implement the MoI Action Plan on police integrity and perform investigations.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Over the last two years DCAF supported the MoI in the development and drafting of the Integrity Plan. Presently, the Integrity Plan is pending approval from the Minister of Interior. The Ministry of Interior (MoI) is amending the law on internal affairs to improve the internal control mechanisms that promote integrity. The new law will include integrity testing measures as a means of internal control, which will be applied to both current and future employees of the MoI. The MoI does not possess technical equipment to perform professional integrity testing, which will be a requirement in accordance to the new Law on Internal Affairs. In addition, the North Macedonian Police have revised their Code of Ethics in 2020.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-06-07"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-06-09"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, 80% of DICCIPS employees report increasing their capacities for conducting criminal and disciplinary investigations.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF provides continuous support to the MoI Department for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations and Professional Standards (DICCIPS) for implementing, monitoring and evaluating the Professional Integrity Plan 2026-2028. From 7 to 9 June 2026, DCAF organised a working visit to the Albanian Police Oversight Agency in Tirana for DICCIPS selected personnel to advance bilateral cooperation in police integrity, oversight of police work and accountability mechanisms. The aim of the visit was to exchange best practices on modern internal control systems and digitalized e-testing methodologies, and establish a shared framework for cross-border collaboration, including joint border controls, coordinated investigations, simulated integrity tests with foreign security personnel, and mutual exchange of information. This working visit paved a strategic step toward modernizing and aligning internal oversight and police accountability standards, and achieving long-term collaboration between both institutions with shared commitment to protecting human rights, and preserving transparency, and public trust.  Increased capacities of 5 senior DICCIPS employees.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.4 Council for Civilian Supervision (CCS) - Indicator #2.4.1: The CCS is fully established and functional.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Lack of proper working conditions impede the functioning of the CCS. The CCS was not able to access funding from the Parliament due to flaws in the LIC legislation. The Parties within the Parliament were not able/willing to find a solution to amend the legislation.  By mid-2020 both the chair and three members had resigned, and one member is still without a security clearance.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-04-15"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-04-17"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By autumn 2025 new Council for Civilian Supervision (CCS) Members appointed, including new Chairperson and three new members, and by end of 2026, CCS members have received training on their roles.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continues to support the Parliament of North Macedonia in enhancing and institutionalising oversight of security and intelligence. With the recent establishment of the Council of Civilian Supervision (CCS), DCAF supports its effective functioning and targeted capacity building of its members, as an independent oversight body established to strengthen democratic accountability over the implementation of communications interception measures in the country. From 15 to 17 April 2026 in Berovo, DCAF organised a Workshop on Developing the Rules of Procedure of the newly established CCS, that focused on translating the Council's legal mandate into practical internal procedures to guide its organization, decision-making, complaint handling, and cooperation with relevant institutions. Particular attention was given to ensuring that the Rules of Procedure reflect the principles of independence, confidentiality, professionalism, and integrity. Through collaborative discussions and the exchange of comparative practices, Council members worked on establishing a clear operational framework that will support the effective and transparent functioning of the CCS, while complementing parliamentary oversight and reinforcing public trust in the oversight system. In the forthcoming period DCAF will organize workshops and working visits for CCS members to strengthen their knowledge and skills for sustainable functioning of the CCS.  Six appointed CCS members have received training on their roles and contributed to the development of one guideline document.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.5 Judiciary_Support to the Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors - Indicator #2.5.1: Judicial practitioners receive training on judicial authorisation of SIM (more concretely on interception of communications), use of European legal standards and principles related to information collection. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">No training delivered by the Academy on SIM.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-05-04"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-05-05"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">In 2021 most of the judicial practitioners working on criminal cases will undergo in-service training. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continuously supports the Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors (AJPP) in enhancing its continuous education activities and providing quality training sessions for practitioners. Thus, DCAF organised the Training on Artificial Intelligence (AI) Ethics, Literacy and Judicial Communication on 4 and 5 May 2026 at the premises of AJPP in Skopje, aimed at strengthening the capacities of judges and prosecutors for ethical, responsible and transparent use of tools based on artificial intelligence, as well as understanding the challenges related to communication and trust in institutions in the AI era. Through interactive sessions and case analysis participants were able to discuss European AI standards and regulations, the risks of algorithmic bias, the protection of human rights, as well as practical approaches for the responsible use of AI in judicial processes.31 judicial practitioners attended the training.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.9 DNA and dactyloscopic Exchange - Indicator #2.9.2: Relevant experts from the Ministry of Interior receive mentoring to support them in performing duties.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The EU Member States that are Parties to the PCC Prüm Agreement already have the experience and routine of exchanging data. The Ministry of Interior will during the project identify where such experience/routine from these countries would be of added value.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-06-02"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-06-11"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, all requested mentoring by experts from EU Member States will be provided.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF works to strengthen national normative capacities for automated biometric data exchange under the PCC Prüm framework and continuously supports the Department of Forensic Examinations (DFE) to expand their forensic capabilities with international expertise. DCAF organized two subsequent workshops with DFE’s Working Groups on developing DNA and Dactyloscopic Guidelines that complies with best practices and international standards for match evaluation. The initial workshop to develop the Guideline for interpretation of results from kinship and family analysis based on autosomal STR analysis (Familial Searching Guideline) was held from 2 to 4 June 2026 in Skopje, to outline the forensic-technical processing steps for accurate interpretation of kinship analysis of crime trace evidence. During this workshop, the forensic experts started working on the revision and updating of the Y-Chromosome (Y-STR) Analysis Guideline that was initially developed with DCAF support in 2024 to describe the method for evaluating and interpreting DNA profiles when determining Y chromosome haplotypes. This guideline revision is necessary to better align with evolving EU standards and automated data exchange requirements. From 9 to 11 June 2026 a workshop for development and drafting of Ten-Print Identification Guideline took place guided by international dactyloscopic expert to enable improved examination results with higher positive hit confirmations and ensure set standards for automated exchange of quality fingerprint data with other operational PCC Prüm signatories. The development of the DNA and Dactyloscopic guidelines will continue until the end of the year to serve as reference for improved quality of collected trace evidence aligned with international standards and PCC Prüm framework.  Mentoring was provided by two EU Member States experts.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 3.3. M&amp;E independent expert group - Indicator #3.3.1: Independent working group produce meaningful monitoring reports.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://www.dcaf.ch/application-special-investigative-measures-republic-north-macedonia" format="application/pdf">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Application of special investigative measures in the Republic of North Macedonia</narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">This publication analyzes the justice system (prosecutorial and judicial) practice of approving, implementing and controlling special investigative measures (SIMs). </narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="mk"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2026-05-26"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The annual report of public prosecutor is the only source of information about use of SIM (number or requests and number of approved warrants) in criminal investigation. There is no publicly available information allowing an assessment of the use of SIM and judicial authorisation of SIM. Last report published was in 2018.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-05-26"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-05-27"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">At least one monitoring report per year produced and shared with public and relevant institutions.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The enhanced cooperation with AJPP culminated with the official promotion of the analysis report on Application of Special Investigative Measures (SIMs) in the Republic of North Macedonia and panel discussion on the analysis of judicial practices regarding SIMs application held on 26 May 2026 in Skopje. This promotion event was a result of the sustained research process conducted with AJPP and the judiciary group throughout 2025 to enhance transparency and accountability in the use of SIMs. The event brought together key stakeholders, including judges, public prosecutors, institutional leaders, and international partners, for dynamic panel discussions on key findings, challenges, dilemmas and recommendations on the application of SIMs in practice. Different perspectives, systemic challenges, institutional coordination and the efficiency of SIMs in organized crime and corruption investigations were analysed by key speakers among others the State Public Prosecutor, the president of the Basic Criminal Court - Skopje and the AJPP Director, in line with rule of law, good governance, and the protection of human rights. The promotion of this important publication summarises DCAF’s multiyear efforts in instilling sustainable judicial reforms through local ownership and dedicated engagement, and showcases comprehensive conclusions and recommendations from the first systematised assessment on how SIMs are lawfully approved, implemented, and overseen within the judiciary.One report on Application of Special Investigative Measures in the Republic of North Macedonia produced and officially promoted.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 3.1 CSOs and Media - Indicator #3.1.1: CSOs and Media receive trainings/mentoring programs on intelligence and security sector governance, accountability requirements and police integrity.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">CSOs and Media are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge and skills on intelligence sector reforms and accountability requirements, and police integrity to do monitoring and assessments of intelligence and law enforcement sector reforms.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-05-18"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-06-19"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025, at least 5 capacity building activities per year delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continuously organises multi-stakeholder workshops to foster constructive dialogue and cooperation between oversight bodies and the institutions subject to oversight. DCAF organised the second multi-stakeholder workshop on new technologies and oversight from 17 to 19 June 2026 in Struga and brought together representatives of Parliament, intelligence and security institutions, the Council of Civilian Supervision, the judiciary and the prosecution, civil society organisations (CSOs), and the media to discuss challenges brought by new technologies interlinked with their respective mandates and oversight functions. The workshop examined fundamental principles of the right to privacy and data protection, mass surveillance and modern monitoring tools, the balance between national security and human rights, categories of personal and sensitive data, as well as the impact of digital transformation on privacy and data protection. DCAF will continue to convene sensitive and high-level discussions to strengthen confidence-building between oversight institutions and civil society.Following the long-term process of developing the curriculum for Micro-Qualification Studies on Security Sector Governance and Oversight by DCAF, Goce Delčev University professors, CSOs and media practitioners who previously participated in DCAF’s security sector reform trainings and training of trainers programme, а Coordination workshop with all parties was organised on 18 May 2026 in Stip. The workshop served as discussion platform for planning the official launch of the micro-qualification studies on Security Sector Governance and Oversight and their administration followed by publishing of the first call for enrolment and the promotional video on 30 May 2026. The video highlights the programme’s objectives, target groups, and unique bottom-up approach, which transformed years of DCAF-supported capacity-building for civil society and the media into an accredited academic programme aligned with European standards on micro-credentials and lifelong learning.DCAF also continued with organising advanced training sessions dedicated to expanding the knowledge and skills of representatives from CSOs, media, and the Parliamentary staff on oversight and accountability mechanisms. The advanced training on New Technologies and Civilian Oversight took place from 5 to 6 June 2026 in Veles and focused on new technologies as a global challenge and their impact on democratic oversight. The training familiarised CSOs and media representatives with the international and national legal frameworks covering digital technologies, AI and the protection of human rights, including the right to privacy and personal data protection. Specific focus was put on practical exercises and advanced techniques for recognizing and analysing deepfakes. DCAF will continue to empower CSOs and media professionals with advanced knowledge and skills on civilian oversight in the new digital era.     This quarter, 3 capacity building activities were delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report: April - June 2025</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter-16_EN_APR-JUN-2025-20250806010836.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Programme newsletter April-June 2025</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly activity reporting: April-June 2025</narrative>
      </description>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2025-08-05"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 3.1 CSOs and Media - Indicator #3.1.2: By the first half of 2025, the mentored group of journalists develop journalist curriculum on informal oversight over the security/intelligence sector.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">In North Macedonia, there is still no specialised curriculum at university programs for journalists on reporting security matters.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-04-28"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-06-04"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Several workshops/meetings conducted for preparation of the curriculum by the end of 2025.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF and Goce Delčev University in Štip (UGD) are jointly working to develop a curriculum for a university-level micro-qualification degree programme in Security Sector Governance and Oversight. The programme is intended to be accredited as part of UGD’s regular specialized professional offerings. DCAF organized two workshops for the development of the University Curriculum for Security Sector Governance and Oversight (the first one from 28 to 29 April in Shtip, and the second from 3 to 4 June in Veles), and gathered UGD professors, civil society representatives, and media professionals to collaboratively design the structure and content of the new academic programme. Through a series of interactive sessions, participants worked collaboratively to define learning goals, refine module titles and content, propose appropriate teaching and facilitation methods, and discuss assessment tools and indicators for measuring success. This collaboration ensures that DCAF’s work will have greater outreach and will outlive the timespan of the programme implementation.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 3.3. M&amp;E independent expert group - Indicator #3.3.1: Independent working group produce meaningful monitoring reports.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_X8NIvSOZjk" format="video/vnd.sealed.mpeg4">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Opening of a Shielded Room in the Parliament: why is it important?</narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Mini-documentary story </narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="mk"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2024-11-01"/>
      </document-link>
      <document-link url="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L92NWFZUOvk" format="video/vnd.sealed.mpeg4">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Who will protect the Ombudsperson's right to oversee the work of the police sector and intelligence services?</narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Mini-documentary story </narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="mk"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2024-10-01"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The annual report of public prosecutor is the only source of information about use of SIM (number or requests and number of approved warrants) in criminal investigation. There is no publicly available information allowing an assessment of the use of SIM and judicial authorisation of SIM. Last report published was in 2018.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-04-25"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-06-13"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">At least one monitoring report per year produced and shared with public and relevant institutions.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continued with the research initiative to enhance transparency and accountability in the use of Special Investigative Measures (SIMs) in cooperation with the Academy of Judges and Public Prosecutors and the judiciary group. Thus, on 25 April 2025 key interviews with selected judges and public prosecutors were held to discuss current practices on SIMs authorisation and implementation. Subsequently, from 21 to 23 May 2025 DCAF organized an analysis workshop with the judiciary group in Gevgelija to review the data gathered during the desk research, the focus groups and the interviews, based on the Methodology guideline developed last year, which serves as a tool for systematic monitoring and evaluation of SIMs usage in relation to human rights obligations and European standards. The workshop outlined the need for further insight from lawyers and other judiciary practitioners and analysed the reports on SIMs utilization published in the last three years. On 13 June, DCAF held a focus group with relevant lawyers specialized in criminal law to consider the challenges faced by the defence, protection of human rights and improvements in SIMs application. This research process will continue in the following months to draft the content of the assessment report and get further input from the group. The promotion of the report is planned for December and will set the baseline for AJPP to assume full ownership of the research process and conduct it regularly every second year.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.2 Parliament/Oversight bodies - Indicator #2.2.1 - 2.2.3: Committee Members and staffers (female and male) report improved understanding of intelligence oversight matters, and Female committee members and staffers actively participate at DCAF events.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">A baseline survey of the new oversight committees’ MPs will be conducted to assess the level of knowledge and skills in oversight.  Organisational functions of Working Body staff are inadequate and prevent effective performance.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-05-28"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-06-13"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, 70% of the female MPs and staffers have attended organised activities and actively participated.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continues to support parliamentary staff in enhancing and institutionalizing oversight of intelligence and security. After several targeted trainings and two workshops on Developing a Framework for Communication, Analytical, and Advisory Skills, DCAF organized three additional workshops on “Advancing Capacities for Knowledge Transfer with a Focus on Content Visualization”. These workshops aimed to strengthen the capacity of parliamentary staff to effectively analyse security-related information, provide strategic advice, and communicate oversight findings in a clear and compelling manner. The sessions also prompted peer learning and cross-institutional exchange of practical experiences. The first workshop was held in Veles from 28 to 29 May and focused on enhancing facilitation skills, and the next two were organized in Skopje on 5 and 13 June in support of effective functioning of parliamentary processes and enhanced accountability in accordance with European good practice. DCAF will continue with the capacity-building initiatives for the parliamentary staff engaged in the oversight process and further develop their knowledge transfer and advisory skills as guardians of institutional continuity and advocates for sustainability.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.1 All institutions - Indicator #2.1.1: Regular multi-stakeholder meetings and joint trainings/workshops are held and are attended by a gender-diverse group from all relevant institutions.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Insufficient cooperation between intelligence/security services and legally mandated oversight actors.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-04-14"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-06-18"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Each multi-stakeholder event has at least 30% female participation.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Following the advanced ToT event on Intelligence Governance, DCAF held a workshop and expert discussion on the design and preparation of an advanced level course on Military Security, Intelligence and Good Governance on 14 April 2025 in Skopje for the Directorate for Security and Intelligence in the Defence (DSID). This closed-door event brought together the newly trained DSID representatives to collaboratively design the structure, content, and learning outcomes of an advanced-level course focused on military security, intelligence, and principles of good governance. The expert discussion aimed at identifying priority themes and ensuring that the course reflects the operational realities. Between 12 and 23 May 2025, two one-week courses titled "Modern Military Intelligence: Balancing Efficiency, Integration, and Democratic Accountability" were delivered for DSID for further enhancement of their skills, with a total of 27 personnel in attendance. On 18 June, DCAF organized an official award ceremony in the Army Hall for DSID trainers to receive certificates of successful completion of the advanced TOT. DCAF will continue to build training capacities of DSID staff for sustainable delivery of the advanced military intelligence courses created with DCAF support.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-04-23"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-04-25"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Each multi-stakeholder event has at least 30% female participation.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Recognizing the need for oversight to include ongoing scrutiny and evaluation of security-related laws, as well as the importance of networking and sharing experiences, DCAF continued to organize multi-stakeholder workshops. The multi-stakeholder workshop “Post-Legislative Scrutiny of Security Laws and Policies” was held from 23 to 25 April 2025, and brought together MPs, representatives of civil society, the media, and the Ombudsperson’s office to deepen their understanding of post-legislative scrutiny as a tool for ensuring democratic oversight of security laws and policies. The workshop focused on how different oversight actors can collaborate to assess the implementation, impact, and continued relevance of security-related legislation and to get familiar with methodology for post-legislative scrutiny. DCAF will continue to use these forums to instigate debate and to stimulate cooperation among different oversight actors.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-04-16"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-04-17"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">80% of invited institutions attend each multi-stakeholder event.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">As part of the ongoing support to security and intelligence sector reform, DCAF identified key challenges in the management of classified information which include inconsistencies in classification processes, such as overclassification, reclassification, and declassification, and varying classification approaches across institutions. In response, DCAF is convening two multi-institutional workshops with representatives from relevant institutions to discuss divergent security certification needs and to address identified shortcomings. DCAF facilitated the first workshop on Classified Information on 16 April in Skopje with the aim to establish unified guidelines and criteria for classification, as well as internal mechanisms for the control and verification of classification processes applicable across all institutions. As next step to this process, DCAF will support the development of a guidance document on Information Classification that will contribute to a more consistent application of the legal framework on classified information, improved institutional security, more efficient use of human, institutional and technical resources, and strengthened inter-institutional trust and effective information exchange.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 1.1. Security and Intelligence Institutions - Indicator #1.1.1: DCAF provides recommendations for any relevant intelligence sector legislation, including on gender and human rights obligations, as part of the legislative review process.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://jorm.gov.mk/izgotven-vodich-za-nishtene-na-podatoczite-sobrani-so-posebnite-istrazhni-merki/" format="text/plain">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="mk">Guideline on Retention and Destruction of Data Collected by SIMs</narrative>
        </title>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="mk"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2024-12-16"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Current laws do not foster effective oversight. Enhanced legal authority and access to information are required to make oversight effective, in the Macedonian political context. The current law on AR, from 1996, does not sufficiently address increased requirements for intelligence accountability nor the new intelligence sector landscape, with OTA and the new law on intelligence coordination. No law on parliamentary oversight of intelligence exists, allowing for clear oversight powers, roles and effective oversight.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-06-27"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-06-28"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025, DCAF has provided recommendations that respond to gaps in intelligence sector law and problems in implementation.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continues to strengthen intelligence institutions’ accountability and to provide recommendations and multistakeholder platforms leading to improved legislative frameworks in line with North Macedonia’s human rights obligations including gender equality. On 27 June 2025, DCAF supported the Operational-Technical Agency (OTA) in organizing multi-institutional roundtable discussion on Enhancing the Use of the Accredited System for Classified Information Exchange in Skopje. The discussion promoted regular and efficient use of the accredited secure system for the preparation and exchange of documentation between relevant stakeholders in the processes of initiating and approving proposals, requests and court orders for communications surveillance measures, endorsed by key speakers such as the OTA Director, the Minister of Interior, the Director of Public Security Bureau, and high level guests from the judiciary, intelligence and the military services. Attendees discussed the challenges that institutions are currently facing during the initial use of the system, proposed effective measures for enhanced inter-institutional connectivity and developed an Action plan with specific steps for efficient system use.   DCAF will support OTA in monitoring the progress of the Action plan that should be fully implemented by the end of the year.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.1 All institutions - Indicator #2.1.3: Gender Action Plan developed by MoD based on recommendations in the Gender-Self Assessment report and MoD increases its capacity to implement the Plan.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://www.dcaf.ch/report-gender-self-assessment" format="application/pdf">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Gender Self-Assessment Report</narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Gender Self-Assessment Report of the Ministry of Defence of North Macedonia</narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="en"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2025-05-20"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The MoD does not currently have a specific, evidence-based gender action plan aimed at enhancing gender equality in the institution based on an in-depth institutional gender analysis.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-05-20"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-05-21"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, relevant staff have developed capacities to implement and monitor the Gender Action Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">On 20 May 2025, the Ministry of Defence of North Macedonia, with DCAF support, hosted the official promotion of the Gender Self-Assessment (GSA) results and the launch of the Gender Action Plan (2024–2028) at Hotel Limak in Skopje. The event convened high-profile political leaders, MPs, ambassadors, civil society representatives, and media. Keynote speeches were delivered by the President of the Republic of North Macedonia, Minister of Defence, Ambassador of the Kingdom of Sweden in North Macedonia, and the Deputy Director of DCAF. The event presented the findings of the GSA, and highlighted existing institutional strengths, gaps, and opportunities for advancing gender equality in the Ministry and the Army. It also marked the launch of the MoD Gender Action Plan, which outlines strategic goals and concrete measures to integrate gender perspectives across policies, operations, and organizational culture. DCAF will continue to support the MoD in implementing the Gender Action Plan. The process will start with developing an Evaluation, Monitoring, and Reporting (EMR) Framework, which will be integrated as part of the Gender Action Plan, and should help the MoD in assessing progress of its implementation.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.5 Judiciary_Support to the Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors - Indicator #2.5.1: Judicial practitioners receive training on judicial authorisation of SIM (more concretely on interception of communications), use of European legal standards and principles related to information collection.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://mvr.gov.mk/Upload/Editor_Upload/ENG_%D0%98%D0%97%D0%92%D0%95%D0%A8%D0%A2%D0%90%D0%88%202024.pdf" format="application/pdf">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">2024 Annual Report on implementation of the Integrity Action plan </narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">2024 Report on the Realisation of the Action Plan for Implementing the Integrity Plan of the Ministry of Interior 2023-2025</narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="en"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2025-02-17"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">No training delivered by the Academy on SIM</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-05-16"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-05-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">In 2021 most of the judicial practitioners working on criminal cases will undergo in-service training.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">As part of the ongoing capacity-building efforts for the Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors (AJPP), from 13 to 16 May 2025 DCAF organized a working visit at the Justice Academy of Türkiye in Ankara, which is longstanding partner of AJPP. The visit offered AJPP personnel a unique opportunity to understand the training cycle management practices and collaboration mechanisms between the Justice Academy and other judicial institutions in providing quality mentorship and traineeship programmes. AJPP representatives exchanged valuable experiences and insight with their Turkish colleagues to be able to introduce changes in the selection and training processes of new judges and public prosecutors based on planned legislative changes in near future. Furthermore, from 28 to 30 May DCAF organised Project Management and Budgeting training in Mavrovo to enhance AJPP professional competencies in managing and monitoring partnership projects and equip them with necessary tools for efficient institutional performance. DCAF will continue to support AJPP in their efforts to modernise the training system and therefore organize targeted events for strengthening capacities in introducing systematic and sustainable institutional reforms.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="2" aggregation-status="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual Report April - December 2021</narrative>
    </title>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual Report for period April - December 2021</narrative>
    </description>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/DCAF-IntelSSR-in-MK_Operational-Report-April-Dec-2021_short-20230124110136.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual Report Jan-Dec 2021 </narrative>
      </title>
      <category code="B01"/>
      <language code="en"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Programmes Development indicators</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator # 2.1: Quality and frequency of direct oversight interaction between the Parliament and intelligence services increased to meet oversight effectiveness.Indicator #2.2: Increased consistency of judicial practice (prosecutors and judges) in authorization and review of intrusive methods (intrusive methods to be based on law, be non-discriminatory, have a legitimate aim, and be a “necessary” and “proportional” response)Indicator #2.3: The Ministry of Interior of North Macedonia (MoI) has strategic and operational capacity to effectively build integrity in line with European values and good policing practice, enabling more effective oversight. Indicator #2.4: The Ministry of Interior (MoI) of North Macedonia has organizational and technical capacity to engage in an automated exchange of biometric (DNA) data with other Parties to the joint PCC Prüm  multilateral legal framework, aligned with European standards and good practice</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2020" iso-date="2020-06-30"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-31"/>
        <target value="Target PG #1: By the end of 2026 the EU Progress Report, independent experts’ reports as well as media articles state that the parliament performance in legislating and overseeing of the security services is enhanced compared to previous years. "/>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="9" aggregation-status="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report  April - Sept 2021</narrative>
    </title>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">The report combines two quarterly reports April - June and July - September 2021</narrative>
    </description>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter_EN_APR-SEP_2021-%28final%29-20230124110117.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter April - September 2021 </narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">The report shows activities organised during the period and progress towards results/outputs </narrative>
      </description>
      <category code="A08"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator related to Output 2.1 - Capacity Building for different institutions involved in the Programme</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.1.1: All relevant institutions attend most of the trainings/workshop events</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2020" iso-date="2020-06-30"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-31"/>
        <target value="Target #2.1.1: 80% of institutions attend multi-stakeholder events with female and male participation. "/>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator related to Output 1 - Legal &amp; Institutional Framework ...all institutions involved </narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.3.1: Inter-Institutional Common Minimum Standards (CMS) between intelligence services and oversight/control bodies are approved, consistent with gender and human rights obligations. </narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2020" iso-date="2020-06-30"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-31"/>
        <target value="Target #1.3.1: Three practical multi-stakeholder workshops organised in 2021 and 2022"/>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="9" aggregation-status="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report Oct - Dec 2021</narrative>
    </title>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">The report shows activities organised and progress towards achieved results/outputs. </narrative>
    </description>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter_EN_OCT-DEC_2021-%28final%29-20230124110112.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter Oct-Dec 2021</narrative>
      </title>
      <category code="A08"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicators related to Output 1</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.1.1: DCAF recommendation, including on gender and human rights obligations, taken into consideration as part of the legislative review process. </narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2020" iso-date="2023-01-24"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-31"/>
        <target value="Target #1.1.1: By 2025 DCAF has provided recommendations respond to real gaps in law and real problems in implementation."/>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator related to Outcome 2</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en"> Quality and frequency of direct oversight interaction between the Parliament and intelligence services increased to meet oversight effectiveness.</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2020" iso-date="2021-06-30"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-31"/>
        <target value="Target #2.1:  By 2025, each security and intelligence committee convenes an oversight session or hearing at least 6 times annually and produces, for public access, an annual committee report documenting its (non-classified) oversight activities and conclusions.  "/>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator related to Output 2.3 - Shielded Room</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.2.1: Committees are actively engaged in amending the R&amp;P;  </narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2020" iso-date="2021-06-30"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-31"/>
        <target value="Target #1.2.2: By June 2021 the Committees draft new R&amp;Ps   "/>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="9" aggregation-status="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report Jan - March 2022</narrative>
    </title>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">This report shows activities performed and progress towards results/outputs</narrative>
    </description>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter_EN_JAN-MAR_2022-20230124110146.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter Jan-March 2022</narrative>
      </title>
      <category code="A08"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 1.5: MoI The Section for Crime-Technical Analysis and Expertise is supported in drafting normative /legal documents for automated exchange of biometric (DNA) data in practice</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.5.1: Relevant experts from the Ministry of Interior, and other relevant institutions if necessary, are actively engaged in the drafting of normative/legal documents (e.g. regulations, amendments to national laws or by-laws).</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2020" iso-date="2020-06-30"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-31"/>
        <target value="Target #1.5.1 (a): By the end of 2022, the necessary normative/legal documents drafted and assessed by selected experts from EU Member States. Target #1.5.1 (b): By mid-2023, the normative/legal documents adopted."/>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicators related to MoI Integrity testing </narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.8.1: SICPS’ employees have updated knowledge and skills to perform their duties related to preventing corruption and integrity violations more efficiently within the MoI;</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2020" iso-date="2020-06-30"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-31"/>
        <target value="Target # 2.8.1: By end of 2023 all employees within the SICPS have undergone integrity training."/>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator related to OUTCOME 3 – Public trust</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.2: Media coverage and CSO research paper mentioning the topic of intelligence reform, integrity and accountability.</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2020" iso-date="2020-06-30"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-31"/>
        <target value="Target #3.2: As of 2022, at least one investigative programme and/or policy/research paper per year produced by media and CSOs on intelligence reform and results of the intelligence accountability system."/>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="9" aggregation-status="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report April - June 2022</narrative>
    </title>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">The report shows activities performed during this period and progress towards results/outputs. </narrative>
    </description>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter_EN_APR-JUN_2022-20230124110120.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter April-June 2022</narrative>
      </title>
      <category code="A08"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator related to Outcome 2 - capacity building of Parliament</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2020" iso-date="2020-06-30"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-31"/>
        <target value="Target #2.1:  By 2025, each security and intelligence committee convenes an oversight session or hearing at least 6 times annually and produces, for public access, an annual committee report documenting its (non-classified) oversight activities and conclusions.  Target #2.2 (a): By 2025 judicial practice in authorisation of intrusive methods is more consistent and adequate compared to 2020.   Target #2.2 (b): By 2026, 60-80% of the judicial practitioners dealing with SIM are more attentive to the international standards and principles while considering the reasons for issuing SIM. Target #2.2 (c): By 2026, 60-80% of the judicial practitioners e use European jurisprudence and caselaw while reviewing the case evidences and making their decisions. Target #2.3: By end of the programme the MoI (SICPS) is successfully implementing the Integrity Plan. Target #2.4: By mid-2024, the Ministry of Interior has successfully performed the pilot run foreseen by the PCC Prüm Agreement. "/>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="9" aggregation-status="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report July - Sept 2022 </narrative>
    </title>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">The report shows activities organised during this period and progress towards results/outputs. </narrative>
    </description>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter_EN_JUL-SEP_2022-20230124110105.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter July-Sept 2022</narrative>
      </title>
      <category code="A08"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator related to Outcome 1 - Output 1.5 DNA exchange. OUTPUT 1.5: MoI The Section for Crime-Technical Analysis and Expertise is supported in drafting normative /legal documents for automated exchange of biometric (DNA) data in practice. </narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.5.1: Relevant experts from the Ministry of Interior, and other relevant institutions if necessary, are actively engaged in the drafting of normative/legal documents (e.g. regulations, amendments to national laws or by-laws).</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2020" iso-date="2020-06-30"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <target value="Target #1.5.1 (a): By the end of 2022, the necessary normative/legal documents drafted and assessed by selected experts from EU Member States."/>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Output 2.9 – DNA Exchange Capacity building activities (Vocational training and on-the-spot mentoring, ITC Equipment) provided to employees in the relevant sections of the Ministry of Interior </narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.9.1: Selected employees from the Ministry of Interior successfully conclude vocational trainings.</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2020" iso-date="2020-06-30"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-12-31"/>
        <target value="Target #2.9.1: By the end of 2023, relevant employees from the Ministry of Interior received the necessary vocational trainings."/>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="1" aggregation-status="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Main Results 2021</narrative>
    </title>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">The table shows main/key results achieved during 2021 that lead towards achieving desired/planned outcomes </narrative>
    </description>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/DCAF-IntelSSR-Main-Results-2021-20230124110123.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">key results</narrative>
      </title>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2021-12-31"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Outcome 1 Indicators</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.1 (a): Amended laws, bi-laws and procedures on intelligence aligned with international principles, gender and human rights obligations, good practice and respecting the diversity of the citizens of the Republic of North Macedonia, adopted by Parliament. Indicator #1.1 (b):  Amended laws, by-laws and procedures on intelligence implemented by oversight sector actors. Indicator #1.2: The MoI is acting in accordance with new amendments to the law on Internal Affairs and in accordance with the MoI Integrity Plan. Indicator #1.3: All missing requirements and standards, for automated exchange of biometric (DNA) data pursuant to the PCC Prüm Agreement are in place and are sufficient for exchange.</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2020" iso-date="2023-01-24"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-31"/>
        <target value="Target #1.1 (a): By 2023 North Macedonia has suitable laws, by-laws and procedures (Law on Interception of Communications and other relevant laws;) allowing effective oversight over the intelligence services. Target #1.1 (b): By 2023 all oversight bodies are more effectively implementing oversight and control over intelligence and security sector actors. Target #1.2: By end of the programme (2024) the MoI (Section for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations and Professional Standards - SICPS) is successfully implementing the Integrity Plan.Target #1.3: By mid-2024, the Ministry of Interior has successfully integrated all missing requirements and standards for automated exchange of biometric (DNA) data pursuant to the PCC Prüm Agreement. "/>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Outcome 2 Indicators </narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator # 2.1: Quality and frequency of direct oversight interaction between the Parliament and intelligence services increased to meet oversight effectiveness.Indicator #2.2: Increased consistency of judicial practice (prosecutors and judges) in authorization and review of intrusive methods (intrusive methods to be based on law, be non-discriminatory, have a legitimate aim, and be a “necessary” and “proportional” response)Indicator #2.3: The Ministry of Interior of North Macedonia (MoI) has strategic and operational capacity to effectively build integrity in line with European values and good policing practice, enabling more effective oversight. Indicator #2.4: The Ministry of Interior (MoI) of North Macedonia has organizational and technical capacity to engage in an automated exchange of biometric (DNA) data with other Parties to the joint PCC Prüm  multilateral legal framework, aligned with European standards and good practice</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2020" iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-31"/>
        <target value="Target #2.1:  By 2025, each security and intelligence committee convenes an oversight session or hearing at least 6 times annually and produces, for public access, an annual committee report documenting its (non-classified) oversight activities and conclusions.  Target #2.2 (a): By 2025 judicial practice in authorisation of intrusive methods is more consistent and adequate compared to 2020.   Target #2.2 (b): By 2026, 60-80% of the judicial practitioners dealing with SIM are more attentive to the international standards and principles while considering the reasons for issuing SIM. Target #2.2 (c): By 2026, 60-80% of the judicial practitioners e use European jurisprudence and caselaw while reviewing the case evidences and making their decisions. Target #2.3: By end of the programme the MoI (SICPS) is successfully implementing the Integrity Plan. Target #2.4: By mid-2024, the Ministry of Interior has successfully performed the pilot run foreseen by the PCC Prüm Agreement. "/>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Outcome 3 Indicators </narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.1: Public can debate and challenge the content of reports produced by intelligence and law enforcement  actors. Indicator #3.2: Media coverage and CSO research paper mentioning the topic of intelligence reform, integrity and accountability. Indicator #3.3: Transparency, towards the public is improved for the overall work of the intelligence and law enforcement  actors, respecting the limits of classified information and personal data protection (GDPR).</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2020"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2021-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-31"/>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="9" aggregation-status="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report Oct - Dec 2022</narrative>
    </title>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 3.1.1: CSOs and Media report improved understanding of intelligence sector reforms, accountability requirements and police integrity.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">CSOs and Media are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge and skills on intelligence sector reforms and accountability requirements, and police integrity to do monitoring and assessments of intelligence and law enforcement sector reforms.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-12-14"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-16"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2023, 5 trainings/workshops delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Second training on intelligence and security sector governance for civil society and media. CSO and media representatives improved their understanding of good governance in the intelligence/security sector, with a focus on accountability and transparency and the lens of EU requirements (Chapters 23 and 24).</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">In 2021 formal relationship established between DCAF and relevant CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Building on the formal relationship developed in 2021 between DCAF and certain CSOs/media organisations, one CSO finalised analysis for a report on enhancing the intelligence and security sector reforms in North Macedonia. Another CSO organised a discussion between the Operational Technical Agency and civil society/media. In addition, one video was produced by a tv production company on the Annual Review Conference on Intelligence and Security Sector Reforms, along with an in-studio interview of the Director of the Intelligence Agency.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 2.6.1: A system for accountability in the use of intrusive methods (SIM), where different actors involved are aware of each other’s role and function in complementarity (judiciary, parliamentary committees, law enforcement, CCS, etc) is developed.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Weak inter-institutional strands such as:•Criminal justice chain: police-prosecutors-judges;•Judiciary-OTA – on ex-post judicial control, digitalization of warrants;•Judiciary-Directorate for Personal Data Protection (DPDP)-Directorate for Security of Classified (DSCI) Information •Evaluation of the established procedures/standards for using, managing, handling, storing/keeping personal data and classified info by the judiciary•Judiciary-Parliament-CCS •Lack of material-technical resources that are required for the use of SIM within the MoI (e.g.non-existence of proper facilities and equipment for listening and transcription of communications, thus failing to ensure the secrecy and protection of human rights. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-11-29"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-11-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2023 most judicial practitioners working on criminal investigative matters have theoretical and practical knowledge on procedures and European standards for managing personal data and classified information. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Judicial practitioners exchanged good practices on judicial authorisation and review of special investigative measures with their Austrian counterparts. Macedonian practitioners increased their knowledge of European practices and standards for the use of special investigative measures.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 1.5.1: Relevant experts from the Ministry of Interior, and other relevant institutions if necessary, are actively engaged in the drafting of normative/legal documents (e.g. regulations, amendments to national laws or by-laws).</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Some normative/legal capacities are already in place. Some of these existing documents will require amendments, while some additional documents might need to be created.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-12-21"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-23"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By mid-2023, the normative/legal documents adopted.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">MoI Working Group is in the final stage of developing a Manual for Criminal and Technical Registration and Identification of Persons and Unknown Corpses.The Manual is developed according to new requirements related to storing, processing and automated exchange of DNA, dactyloscopic data and photos.The MoI WG is actively engaged in drafting the regulation.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 2.2.1: Committee Members and staffers (female and male) report improved understanding of intelligence oversight matters.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">A baseline survey of the new oversight committees’ MPs will be conducted to assess the level of knowledge and skills in oversight.  Organisational functions of Working Body staff are inadequate and prevent effective performance.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-11-14"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-11-15"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2022, 70% of new MPs have improved understanding of intelligence oversight matters.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">An Awareness Workshop on Technical Aspects of Communications Interceptions was held for MPs and representatives of the intelligence and security community. Attendees learned about technical devices for the interception of communications, as well as the importance of oversight and internal control of these devices.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 2.8.1: SICPS’ employees have updated knowledge and skills to perform their duties related to preventing corruption and integrity violations more efficiently within the MoI.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Over the last two years DCAF supported the MoI in the development and drafting of the Integrity Plan. Presently, the Integrity Plan is pending approval from the Minister of Interior. The Ministry of Interior (MoI) is amending the law on internal affairs to improve the internal control mechanisms that promote integrity. The new law will include integrity testing measures as a means of internal control, which will be applied to both current and future employees of the MoI. The MoI does not possess technical equipment to perform professional integrity testing, which will be a requirement in accordance to the new Law on Internal Affairs. In addition, the North Macedonian Police have revised their Code of Ethics in 2020.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-10-25"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-13"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By end of 2023 all employees within the SICPS have undergone integrity training.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">SICPS employees were supported through two workshops for the development of the public integrity plan. SICPS employees were trained in identifying corruption risks and performing the corruption risk assessment. This contributes to their capacity to engage in integrity planning.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 2.9.3: Necessary technical equipment replaced and installed.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Ministry of Interior already has solid technical capacities in place. Some of these capacities will require adaptation or upgrades, while some additional technical equipment will need to be procured (.e.g. servers, virtual network security, etc). </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2023, the Ministry of Interior have replaced and installed the necessary technical equipment systems.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF concluded the tendering process and selected a company that will establish a medium-sized DNA laboratory for running the combined DNA index system (CODIS). Equipment will be delivered and installed in the beginning of 2023.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 3.2.1: Public institutions legally mandated to oversee or control intelligence services report on their activities.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">There is none or inconsistent public reporting by intelligence sector actors taking place.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-12-27"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-27"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2022 four theoretical and practical trainings on report drafting organised with all intelligence sector actors.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">One workshop was completed on reporting standards for security/intelligence services and control/oversight institutions. The workshop reached representatives from 12 intelligence/security institutions and facilitated a discussion on good reporting practices.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="1" aggregation-status="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report January - March 2023</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter_EN_JAN-MAR_2023-20230517010535.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter 7: January - March 2023</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter 7. Covering activities and results achieved in period January - March 2023</narrative>
      </description>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 1.2: The MoI is acting in accordance with new amendments to the law on Internal Affairs and in accordance with the MoI's Integrity Plan.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The amendments to the Law on Internal Affairs, which are currently in parliamentary procedure (June 2021), make a change in Article 66 of the law that sets up the general criteria a person should meet so that he/she can be employed in the MoI, with a new criterion being introduced – the person must pass an Integrity Test carried out by the MoI.  A professional integrity test will also be conducted for existing employees, contributing to the prevention of corruption and abuse of office, aimed at strengthening the integrity of Ministry and Police employees and preventive action. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-02-08"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-02-23"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of the programme (2024) the MoI is successfully implementing the Integrity Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The MoI approved the Integrity Plan and Action Plan (2023 - 2025) and published it on their website. This achievement came after the successful delivery of a series of mentoring sessions and workshops in the period that increased the capacities of the Department for Internal Control for integrity planning.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 2.3.1: Shielded Room and protected workspace constructed in Parliament and equipment installed.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Parliament has no protected workspace and meeting facility to discuss and store classified information, impeding meaningful exchange of sensitive and classified information with security and intelligence services. Parliament, in Feb 2020, approved the establishment of the shielded room. Within its Phase I Programme DCAF allocated funds as a contribution towards the establishment of the Shielded Room and protected workplace. Due to Covid-19 the process was delayed throughout 2020. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-03-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2021 the Parliament has a Shielded Room and protected space Installed.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The sixth tendering process for the Shielded Room was successful. The Assembly selected a bidder and the construction of the Shielded Room will begin soon.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-02-16"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-03-24"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2021 the Parliament has a Shielded Room and protected space installed.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF organised Two Workshops on Developing Accreditation Documents for the Shielded Room and Protected Workspace in the Parliament of the Republic of North Macedonia. The first workshop took place from 16-17 February 2023 in Veles. The second workshop, held from 22-24 March 2023 in Berovo, was focused on developing a Statement of Security Needs and included practical work aimed at aligning views on the scope and concept of the accreditation documents. These workshops are part of a series of six workshops, facilitated by a local expert. The process will continue until all accreditation documents are developed and deployed following the construction of the Shielded Room. The finalisation of the accrediation documents will allow the Shielded Room to function once constructed.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 2.5.1: Judicial practitioners receive training on judicial authorisation of SIM (more concretely on interception of communications), use of European legal standards and principles related to information collection. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">No training delivered by the Academy on SIM.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-02-13"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-02-16"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">(1) In 2021, most of the judicial practitioners working on criminal cases will undergo in-service training.(2) Each year starting 2021 candidates for future judges and prosecutors selecting the subject on interception of communications, will undergo 9 academic classes.(3) Starting mid 2021 supplementary self-paced online courses, undertaken by future candidates, judges and prosecutors working on criminal investigative matters.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">In support of strengthening the training curricula in the Judicial Academy, DCAF organised a Working Visit to Judicial Training Centres in Spain between 13-16 February 2023 on Exchanging Good Practices on Conceptualising and Organising Judicial Training: the Spanish and the Macedonian Models for 11 representatives of the North Macedonian Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors. Macedonian representatives (judges, prosecutors, and the Academy’s secretariat) met their Spanish counterparts from the Judicial Training Center in Barcelona, the Periodic Training Service of the Judicial School and the Public Assistance Service in Madrid, and the General Judicial Council in Madrid. Discussions, facilitated by a team of senior experts from the Spanish institutions, provided participants valuable insight into the Spanish judicial system and its educational system. Macedonian practitioners were particularly attentive to the process of selecting students, the evaluation system, the selection of trainers and mentors, and the internship programmes.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 2.9.1: Selected employees from the Ministry of Interior successfully conclude vocational trainings.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Employees from the Ministry of Interior, e.g. the Section for Crime – Technical Analysis and Expertise, and the National Central Unit for Information Exchange, are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge to administer automated exchange of DNA data.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-02-20"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-02-24"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2023, relevant employees from the Ministry of Interior received the necessary vocational trainings.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Between 20-24 February 2023, DCAF conducted a Hybrid Training for DNA specialists on Statistical Methods in Relatedness and Pedigree Analysis Based on STR Markers Using Different Software for the Forensics Department of the MoI as part of building the capacity to exchange DNA data within the PCC Prüm framework. The training was attended by employees from DNA identification laboratories within the Forensics Department and was conducted by two international experts in forensic sciences and DNA and two experts from INTERPOL.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 2.1.5: Recommendations from the GSA process translated into Gender Action Plan with the capacity to be configured as a complementary part of the institutional gender activities, plans and strategies of the MoD.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">A Gender Self-assessment has yet to be conducted. A gender action plan does not exist in the MoD.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-02-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-03-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Recommendations from the GSA process translated into Gender Action Plan with the capacity to be configured as a complementary part of the institutional gender activities, plans and strategies of the MoD.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF organised a kick-off training on GSA methodology for the 14 members of the WG between 01-03 February 2023 in Veles, marking the first official gathering of the WG members and the engaged experts. Through this training, WG members began to prepare for the data collection process in the GSA.In addition, DCAF organized a GSA Workshop for Testing and Validating Data Collection Tools for the members of the Working Group of the MoD and the Army from 29-31 March 2023 in Skopje. The objective of the workshop was to review, test, and validate the data collection tools (surveys, focus group questions, interview questions) that will be used for the GSA. During the workshop, the data collection tools were adjusted according to the context and needs of the MoD and the Army. An implementation plan for field research was developed and field research will be conducted beginning in April 2023.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 3.2.1: Public institutions legally mandated to oversee or control intelligence services report on their activities.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">There is none or inconsistent public reporting by intelligence sector actors taking place.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-02-27"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-02-28"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2022 four theoretical and practical trainings on report drafting organised with all intelligence sector actors.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF held the Second Multi-stakeholder Workshop on Reporting Standards for Security/Intelligence Services and Control/Oversight Institutions between 27-28 February 2023 in Veles. Representatives responsible for reporting, public relations, and inter-institutional cooperation from intelligence and security services and institutions with an oversight or control mandate attended the workshop. During the workshop, each institution presented their process of reporting and identified common features across institutions. In addition, the expert on classified information from Croatia shared experiences and good practices related to the classification, declassification, and overclassification of reports and triggered interesting discussion among participants about existing reporting challenges.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 3.1.1: CSOs and Media report improved understanding of intelligence sector reforms, accountability requirements and police integrity.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">CSOs and Media are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge and skills on intelligence sector reforms and accountability requirements, and police integrity to do monitoring and assessments of intelligence and law enforcement sector reforms.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-03-13"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-03-15"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2023, 5 trainings/workshops delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF organised Training No. 3 on Intelligence and Security Sector Governance and Accountability: “Human Rights Mainstreaming in Security Sector Reform” for 14 representatives of civil society organisations (CSOs) and media in North Macedonia from 13-15 March 2023 in Berovo. Participants also acquired knowledge on venues for promoting a rights-based and gender-responsive SSR processes.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-03-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">-</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The TV production company '360 Degrees' was supported by DCAF to produce two mini-documentaries: one entitled 'Women in the Special Forces' and the other entitled 'The Integrity of (New) Employees in the MoI on Test'. These productions allowed the media outlet to continue engagement with security and intelligence sector topics and increase their familiarity with reform processes.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="2">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Main Results 2022</narrative>
    </title>
    <description>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Outcome-level results achieved in year 2022</narrative>
    </description>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/DCAF-IntelSSR-in-MK_Operational-Progress-Report-Jan-Dec-2022_Outcomes-Table-20230502010507.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual Report 2022 - Outcomes</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Table of progress towards outcomes from Annual Report 2022.</narrative>
      </description>
      <category code="B01"/>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
    </document-link>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/2022-DCAF-IntelSSR-in-MK_Operational-Report-Jan-Dec-2022_short-version-20230504090512.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual Report 2022 - Narrative</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Annual Report 2022. Narrative text on progress towards outcomes and outputs as well as transversal themes.</narrative>
      </description>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <category code="B01"/>
      <language code="en"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">3.2: Media coverage and CSO research paper mentioning the topic of intelligence reform, integrity, and accountability</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Outcome 3 - Public Trust</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2021" iso-date="2021-04-01">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The intelligence sector reforms and accountability are not sufficiently and professionally addressed by CSOs and Media. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">As of 2022, at least one investigative programme and/or policy/research paper per year produced by media and CSOs on intelligence reform and results of the intelligence accountability system.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Six in-depth stories/mini TV documentaries (eight to 12 minutes each) on topics related to intelligence and security sector reform aired as part of the “360 Degrees” TV show on TV Alsat. These mini documentaries were also shared and extensively promoted on the website, Facebook page, and YouTube channel of 360 Degrees, as well on DCAF’s official website and YouTube channel. They helped increase the Programme’s visibility and informed the broader public on the progress of reforms in the intelligence and security sector. The reach of the mini-documentaries was significant, with each video receiving more than 35,000 views on TV and 45,000 views on Facebook.Two research products were developed by two CSOs with DCAF’s support. One of the research projects included a comparative analysis of the communication practices of the intelligence agencies of three countries (UK, Slovenia, and North Macedonia) and the development of a transparency matrix as a result. The second research project included a complex system analysis and resulted in the development of a Roadmap containing evidence-based indicators for transparency, accountability, and efficiency, along with context-specific recommendations. The two products will be made available on DCAF’s website (in English and local languages) and will be promoted extensively by the two CSOs on their social media/website pages in 2023.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-10-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF’s Annual Review Conference was covered by a range of local media (TV channels, newspapers, and media portals). In addition, there was significant engagement on social media (via Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn) with content shared/re-shared and tweeted/re-tweeted on DCAF’s and participants’ social media profiles (including Ministers’ social media pages). The event was additionally livestreamed via an MIA (Media Information Agency) media aggregator and was summarised in a short documentary video produced by 360 Stepeni. The documentary was aired on Alsat TV and complemented an in-studio interview with the Director of the Intelligence Agency. The interview attracted 42,000 viewers on TV and 51,500 viewers on social media, receiving 129 reactions making the public more aware on the subject of intelligence reforms.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">2.4: The MoI has organisational and technical capacity to engage in an automated exchange of biometric (DNA) data with other Parties to the joint PCC Prüm multilateral legal framework, aligned with European standards and good practice.</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Outcome 2 - Capacity Building</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Ministry of Interior has established solid organizational, and technical capacity in the field of DNA, however not yet sufficient to initiate automated exchange of such data, pursuant to the PCC Prüm Agreement.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The Ministry of Interior has established solid organizational, and technical capacity in the field of DNA, however not yet sufficient to initiate automated exchange of such data, pursuant to the PCC Prüm Agreement.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DNA specialists from OKTIV increased their knowledge for the use and application of different methods and software (such as EuroForMix, LRmix Studio, and Case Solver) used to interpret and analyse DNA profiles. This will help them to be better prepared for the automated exchange of biometric (DNA) data with other Parties to the joint Police Cooperation Convention (PCC) Prüm multilateral legal framework. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">2.5: Recommendations from the GSA process translated into Gender Action Plan with the capacity to be configured as a complementary part of the institutional gender activities, plans, and strategies of the MoD.</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Outcome 2 - Capacity Building</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2021"/>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF signed a cooperation agreement with the MoD for conducting the GSA in the MoD and the Army. A WG (composed of MoD and Army representatives) was subsequently formed to conduct research for the purposes of the GSA. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">2.2: Increased consistency of judicial practice (prosecutors and judges) in authorisation and review of intrusive methods (intrusive methods to be based on law, be non-discriminatory, have a legitimate aim, and be a "necessary" and "proportional" response).</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Outcome 2 - Capacity Building</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2021" iso-date="2021-04-01">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The ECHR case law is not regularly observed by prosecutors and judges in the request and authorisation of intrusive methods. The judicial practice (interpretation and application of law by prosecutors and judges) in authorization of intrusive methods is still not consistent and adequate. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025 judicial practice in authorisation of intrusive methods is more consistent and adequate compared to 2020. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The reports issued by the Public Prosecutor’s Office in 2022, providing data from the 2021 period, suggest that in comparison with previous years, the intrusive measures applied by the Public Prosecutor's Office are reducing (specifically the number of wiretaps, physically monitored persons, deployment of persons with concealed identity to detect more serious forms of crimes). Special investigative measures (SIM) have decreased in use from 67 cases in 2020, to 59 cases in 2021 (-12%). During a monitoring meeting conducted in 2021, all interviewees agreed that there has been progress in judicial practice when it comes to the use of SIM (citing that DCAF’s Programme contributed to this progress). </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-01-02"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2026, 60-80% of the judicial practitioners dealing with SIM are more attentive to the international standards and principles while considering the reasons for issuing SIM.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">14 trainers (judicial experts and practitioners -Benchbook authors and contributors) increased their individual capacities through the Training of Trainers (ToT) process and delivered several trainings on judicial authorisation for the use of intrusive measures for information collection to more than 60 members of the judiciary (judges, public prosecutors, legal advisors, and judicial police authorised for the implementation of SIM) from different regions of North Macedonia. Half of the participants of these activities were women. Some members of DCAF’s judicial target group are now part of the newly established Committee on Detection of Criminal Procedural Gaps and Inconsistencies, as well as the WG of the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) established in 2021 for drafting amendments to the Criminal Procedure Code. They will have the opportunity to use their knowledge when drafting the provisions/sections related to SIM.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">1.1 (a): Amended laws, bi-laws, and procedures on intelligence are aligned with international principles, gender and human rights obligations, good practice, and respecting the diversity of the citizens of the Republic of North Macedonia, adopted by Parliament.</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Outcome 1 - Legal and Institutional Framework</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The current law, by-laws and procedures are not suitable to allow for effective oversight of the intelligence services. In addition, legally mandated oversight bodies are functioning but not sufficiently effective. The formal relationship between the Parliament and the Council for Civilian Supervision remains inadequate as a result.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2023 North Macedonia has suitable laws, by-lawsand procedures (Law on Interception of communications and other relevant laws) allowing effective oversight over the intelligence services.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Manual for Criminal and Technical Registration and Identification of Persons and Unknown Corpses (that will be passed as a bylaw in 2023 prescribing the procedures and rules of work of the Department for Criminal Technical Investigations and Expertise (OKTIV) for the criminal-technical registration and identification of persons and unknown corpses through fingerprints, DNA, and photos) was developed by the MoI WG (composed of representatives of OKTIV and other organisational field units). </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-01-02"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2023 North Macedonia has suitable laws, by-lawsand procedures (Law on Interception of Communications and other relevant laws;) allowing effective oversight over the intelligence services.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF in an inclusive process along with the Parliament, the Directorate for Security of Classified Information (DSCI), and MoI/Parliamentary Security, developed draft Security Operating Procedures (SecOP) for the use of the Shielded Room (SR). This is one of the documents needed for the accreditation of the SR. The whole process for developing accreditation documents continues in 2023. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">1.2: The MoI is acting in accordance with new amendments to the law on Internal Affairs and in accordance with the MoI Integrity Plan.</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Outcome 1 - Legal and Institutional Framework</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2021" iso-date="2021-04-01">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The amendments to the Law on Internal Affairs, which are currently in parliamentary procedure (June 2021), make a change in Article 66 of the law that sets up the general criteria a person should meet so that he/she can be employed in the MoI, with a new criterion being introduced – the person must pass an Integrity Test carried out by the MoI. A professional integrity test will also be conducted for existing employees, contributing to the prevention of corruption and abuse of office, aimed at strengthening the integrity of Ministry and Police employees and preventive action.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By end of the programme (2024) the MoI (Section for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations and Professional Standards - SICPS) is successfully implementing the Integrity Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The Integrity Plan and Action Plan (2023-2025) of the MoI was developed throughout 2022 by the MoI’s WG on Integrity. It will be finalised and adopted in 2023 and will be made publicly available. It will assist the MoI to prevent and mitigate corruption risks in its institution. (linked to Outcome 2.3)</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">2.1: Quality and frequency of direct oversight interaction between the Parliament and intelligence services increased to meet oversight effectiveness.</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Outcome 2 - Capacity Building</narrative>
      </description>
      <baseline year="2021" iso-date="2021-04-01">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Cooperation between the Parliament and security and intelligence services exists but does not meet full oversight needs.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-01-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025, each security and intelligence committee convenes an oversight session or hearing at least 6 times annually and produces, for public access, an annual committee report documenting its (non-classified) oversight activities and conclusions.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The MPs and parliamentary staff were involved in Programme activities that concerned institutional oversight over the intelligence and security sectors and other related topics. The majority of the MPs (members of the 3 parliamentary committees supervising the security and intelligence sectors, representatives of all political parties), as well as the parliamentary staff that supports the three oversight committees, participated in the capacity building activities organized by DCAF throughout 2022 (workshops, conferences, working visits, and debates). MPs reported raising their awareness and increasing their understanding of security and intelligence governance, accountability, and oversight. Their capacities for oversight of the intelligence and security sectors have resultingly increased. Half of the participants of these capacity building activities were women.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2022-01-02"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2022-12-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025, each security and intelligence committee convenes an oversight session or hearing at least 6 times annually and produces, for public access, an annual committee report documenting its (non-classified) oversight activities and conclusions.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The three parliamentary committees supervising security and intelligence conducted 8 main oversight activities in 2022. The oversight activities involved 1 report, 5 oversight hearings, and 2 oversight visits to the National Security Agency (NSA) and Intelligence Agency (IA). The Director of NSA noted that between 2019 and 2022 the NSA had 15 meetings with the two committees ‘which is more than all director-level meetings with the two committees of all previous mandates of all previous directors’ In addition, other forms of less formal communication (coordination, ad hoc meetings, DCAF events, etc.) are increasing between the agencies and the committees to improve cooperation between the institutions. This informal development is a good indicator of concretes progress of improved coordination/communication leading towards more effective oversight. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="1" aggregation-status="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report April - June 2023</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter_EN_APR-JUN_2023-20230721010744.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter 8, April - June 2023</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Programme newsletter for period 1 April 2023 to 30 June 2023.</narrative>
      </description>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.1 (a): Amended laws, bi-laws, and procedures on intelligence aligned with international principles, gender and human rights obligations, good practice and respecting the diversity of the citizens of the Republic of North Macedonia, adopted by Parliament. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The current law, by-laws and procedures are not suitable to allow for effective oversight of the intelligence services. In addition, legally mandated oversight bodies are functioning but not sufficiently effective. The formal relationship between the Parliament and the Council for Civilian Supervision remains inadequate as a result. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-06-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2023 North Macedonia has suitable laws, by-laws and procedures (Law on Interception of Communications and other relevant laws;) allowing effective oversight over the intelligence services.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">The draft Law on Amendments and Supplements to the Law on Interception of Communications is currently in Parliamentary procedure. It is expected to be voted on. The adoption of the Law would remove obstacles to the functioning of the Council for Civilian Supervision and enable technical experts to be hired for oversight. DCAF acted as a facilitator in the process, contributing to the law’s text and assisting to achieve political consensus.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.2: The MoI is acting in accordance with new amendments to the law on Internal Affairs and in accordance with the MoI Integrity Plan.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Baseline #1.2: The amendments to the Law on Internal Affairs, which are currently in parliamentary procedure (June 2021), make a change in Article 66 of the law that sets up the general criteria a person should meet so that he/she can be employed in the MoI, with a new criterion being introduced – the person must pass an Integrity Test carried out by the MoI.  A professional integrity test will also be conducted for existing employees, contributing to the prevention of corruption and abuse of office, aimed at strengthening the integrity of Ministry and Police employees and preventive action. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-06-26"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-06-27"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #1.2: By end of the programme (2024) the MoI (Section for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations and Professional Standards - SICPS) is successfully implementing the Integrity Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">On 26 June 2023 a Launching Event of the Integrity Plan of the Ministry of Interior (2023-2025) was organised. The Integrity Plan, available on the MoI’s webpage, serves as a strategic document aimed at building integrity and hindering corrupt practices in MoI structures and police in North Macedonia by identifying corruption risks and establishing mechanisms that minimise those risks. It was previously a classified document and the launching event marks the conclusion of the MoI's redevelopment of the Plan as a public document. The MoI’s Department for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations, and Professional Standards developed the Plan in cooperation with DCAF, additionally consulting  all organisational units of the MoI during development. This Plan is crucial for building public confidence in the MoI, contributing to regional stability, and ensuring North Macedonia’s compliance with EU standards. DCAF will continue to support the MoI to implement, monitor, and evaluate the Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.3.1: Shielded Room and protected workspace constructed in Parliament and equipment installed.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Baseline #2.3.1: The Parliament has no protected workspace and meeting facility to discuss and store classified information, impeding meaningful exchange of sensitive and classified information with security and intelligence services. Parliament, in Feb 2020, approved the establishment of the shielded room. Within its Phase I Programme DCAF allocated funds as a contribution towards the establishment of the Shielded Room and protected workplace. Due to Covid-19 the process was delayed throughout 2020. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-06-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #2.3.1: By the end of 2021 the Parliament has a Shielded Room and protected space Installed. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Between April and June 2023, DCAF organised several Workshops and Meetings on Developing Accreditation Documents for the Shielded Room and Protected Workspace in the Parliament of the Republic of North Macedonia. The workshops included stakeholders from across the intelligence and security sector institutions and were attended by four parliamentary staff from Security and Intelligence Committees, one IT staff member, representatives from the Directorate for Security of Classified Information, and representatives from the MoI responsible for the security of the Assembly and facilitated by a local expert. The workshops will continue until all accreditation documents are developed and deployed following the construction of the Shielded Room. The accreditation documents are essential to the use of the Shielded Room.The company for the construction of the Shielded Room has been selected by Parliament and construction is expected to begin in July and conclude in December 2023.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.2.1: Committee Members and staffers (female and male) report improved understanding of intelligence oversight matters.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Baseline #2.2.1 – 2.2.5: A baseline survey of the new oversight committees’ MPs will be conducted to assess the level of knowledge and skills in oversight.  Organisational functions of Working Body staff are inadequate and prevent effective performance.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-06-05"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-06-07"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #2.2.1: By the end of 2024, 70% of MPs feel more confident in their role as overseers. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Between 5-7 June 2023 in Veles, DCAF organised a Workshop for MPs and Parliamentary Staff on “NATO and EU Approach to Security Sector Reform: Lessons for the Parliamentary Oversight”. The participants had an opportunity to get acquainted with NATO/EU standards and the obligations that NATO/EU membership entails through theoretical presentations, custom-made exercises, and expert facilitation. Participants increased their understanding  of Parliamentarians’ requirements when exerting control and practicing oversight over the intelligence, security, and defense sector according to NATO/EU standards. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.4.2: Inter-institutional Protocols, harmonised Templates and Guidelines for different stages of SIM approval are drafted and submitted for approval by relevant institutions within the criminal justice chain.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Baseline #1.4.1 - 1.4.2: Courts and prosecutorial offices have different (sometimes dated, or even contradictory) procedures and templates used in the authorisation of SIM. Harmonisation of practice and exchange of information are not in place to ensure effective authorisation of SIM, in agreement with new legislative provisions and European standards.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-06-28"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-06-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #1.4.2: By 2022 working groups draft proposals designed to unify and harmonise practice.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Upon the request of the Criminal Court in Skopje, DCAF organised the First Workshop on Conceptualising Procedures for Destroying Data Produced by Special Investigative Measures (SIM) from 28-30 June 2023 in Mavrovo. The need for a specific procedure was identified during multistakeholder workshops on the implementation of measures for the interception of communications that DCAF organised over the last two years. The development of a procedure on data destruction is also a recommendation from the Agency for Personal Data Protection as a safeguard for citizens’ privacy. During the workshop, the judicial ‘tight group’ discussed and identified the main aspects of the data destruction process for data produced by SIM, such as its legal basis and the responsible persons, steps, and deadlines for retaining and destroying data. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.5.1: Judicial practitioners receive training on judicial authorisation of SIM (more concretely on interception of communications), use of European legal standards and principles related to information collection. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Baseline #2.5.1 - 2.5.3: No training delivered by the Academy on SIM </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-06-09"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-06-10"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #2.5.2: Each year starting 2021 candidates for future judges and prosecutors selecting the subject on interception of communications, will undergo 9 academic classes.  </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">On 09 June 2023, DCAF organised an Initial Meeting for the working group (WG) for the Development of a Collection of Case-Law on Special Investigative Measures (SIM) in North Macedonia. The Collection will serve as a training resource for the Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors and is to be used in judicial courses at both entry- and higher-level education. It will complement the Benchbook, previously developed with DCAF’s support, and facilitate its application to local practice. The development process will provide an opportunity for the application of the European Convention on Human Rights to SIM authorisation in Macedonian proceedings and judicial reasoning to be analysed. This meeting centered around planning activities for the development of the Collection. DCAF will continue its support to the working group for the development of this knowledge product by sharing experiences and providing advice and mentorship. This will contribute to the Academy's ability to deliver academic classes on SIM.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.5.1: Relevant experts from the Ministry of Interior, and other relevant institutions if necessary, are actively engaged in the drafting of normative/legal documents (e.g. regulations, amendments to national laws or by-laws).</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Baseline # 1.5.1: Some normative/legal capacities are already in place. Some of these existing documents will require amendments, while some additional documents might need to be created.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-04-28"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-04-29"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #1.5.1 (a): By the end of 2022, the necessary normative/legal documents drafted and assessed by selected experts from EU Member States.Target #1.5.1 (b): By mid-2023, the normative/legal documents adopted.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF organised the Final Meeting for the MoI Working Group (WG) to Incorporate the Recommendations Received by the Reviewers of the Manual for Criminal and Technical Registration and Identification of Persons and Unknown Corpses on 28 April 2023 in Skopje. At this meeting, the WG members finalised the procedures for the criminal and technical registration and identification of persons and unknown corpses according to best practice and revised the text according to recommendations and proposals provided by regional forensics’ experts. The Manual is developed in line with PCC Prüm requirements related to the storage, processing, and automated exchange of DNA, dactyloscopic data, and photos, as well as national regulations related to the work of the Police. Once the Manual has been approved within the MoI, it will be adopted by the Minister as a by-law and distributed to all forensics technicians in the country, who will be expected to align their working procedures with the new standards.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.8.1: SICPS’ employees have updated knowledge and skills to perform their duties related to preventing corruption and integrity violations more efficiently within the MoI.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Baseline # 2.8.1 – 2.8.4: Over the last two years DCAF supported the MoI in the development and drafting of the Integrity Plan. Presently, the Integrity Plan is pending approval from the Minister of Interior. The Ministry of Interior (MoI) is amending the law on internal affairs to improve the internal control mechanisms that promote integrity. The new law will include integrity testing measures as a means of internal control, which will be applied to both current and future employees of the MoI. The MoI does not possess technical equipment to perform professional integrity testing, which will be a requirement in accordance to the new Law on Internal Affairs. In addition, the North Macedonian Police have revised their Code of Ethics in 2020.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-04-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-06-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target # 2.8.1: By end of 2023 all employees within the SICPS have undergone integrity training.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Between 9 – 12 May 2023 in Skopje, DCAF organised a series of mentoring sessions and workshops aimed at enabling trainers from the MoI to develop hybrid training on integrity and integrate integrity into other training curricula. DCAF supports these trainers in cooperation with the OSCE Mission to Skopje, currently implementing a three-year project aimed at developing hybrid learning courses on a range of topics for MoI employees. Through the mentoring sessions, the four trainers tasked with developing the hybrid course on integrity became more familiar with the topic, agreed upon the course’s format and concept, and discussed integrating the hybrid course on integrity into existing training structures with relevant institutions (Police Training Centre, Internal Control Department). DCAF will continue to support the development of integrity curricula and the organisation of train-the-trainers to enable sustained delivery of hybrid integrity courses. The development of these hybrid courses is expected to conclude in mid-2024. Meanwhile, DCAF supports the MoI in conceptualising and developing police integrity training courses that need to be delivered to different target groups in the MoI, identified in the MoI’s Integrity Plan. In this regard,  DCAF organised an Initial Meeting of the Working Group (WG) for Developing a Training Course on Police Integrity on 12 June 2023. The WG is led by the Department for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations, and Professional Standards. The course will be developed to support the implementation of the Integrity Plan of the MoI (2023-2025) and will target police officers in different organisational units of the Ministry identified as most vulnerable to corruption risks. The WG members agreed to start working on the training curricula, which will be submitted to the Minister of Interior for approval. DCAF will continue to support this WG by providing advice and mentoring and organising a Train-the-Trainers course to prepare them for the successful delivery of the integrity course.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 2.1.5: Recommendations from the GSA process translated into Gender Action Plan with the capacity to be configured as a complementary part of the institutional gender activities, plans and strategies of the MoD.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">A Gender Self-assessment has yet to be conducted. A gender action plan does not exist in the MoD.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-05-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-06-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Recommendations from the GSA process translated into Gender Action Plan with the capacity to be configured as a complementary part of the institutional gender activities, plans and strategies of the MoD.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continued with the activities that are part of the Gender Self-Assessment (GSA) process in the Ministry of Defence (MoD) and the Army of North Macedonia. The field research, officially started in May 2023 and will last until the end of September 2023, consisting of interviews with key leaders from the MoD and the Army, focus groups with MoD and Army personnel, and surveys. The research will be concluded with an in-depth analysis, conducted by experts and the MoD’s Working Group (WG), that will identify gaps and weaknesses in the MoD and Army’s structures regarding gender equality as well as opportunities and entry points for gender mainstreaming.The MoD’s WG, consisting of 13 military and civilian representatives of the Army and administrative staff of the MoD, continues to have significant responsibility during the GSA process, specifically collecting information and providing organisational support, thus ensuring local ownership over the process. DCAF will continue to support the process beyond the research and analysis phases, namely during the preparation of the Gender Action Plan that will translate the findings and recommendations on gender mainstreaming into practical actions. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.2.1: Public institutions legally mandated to oversee or control intelligence services report on their activities.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Baseline #3.2.1: There is none or inconsistent public reporting by intelligence sector actors taking place.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-05-03"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-05-05"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #3.2.1: By 2022 four theoretical and practical trainings on report drafting organised with all intelligence sector actors.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Between 03-05 May 2023 in Mavrovo, DCAF held the Third Multi-stakeholder Workshop on Reporting Standards for Security/Intelligence Services and Control/Oversight Institutions. Representatives responsible for reporting, public relations, and inter-institutional cooperation from intelligence and security services and institutions with an oversight or control mandate attended the workshop. During the workshop, participants discussed reporting stages of development, identified common features in reports across institutions, and considered relevant standards for report writing and communication with the public. In addition, two CSO representatives presented the findings of their research on accountability and transparency in the Macedonian security and intelligence services which sparked interesting discussions on improving the services’ communication strategies. In the next period, a smaller group of selected participants will draft a document of common standards and principles for preparing public reports which will serve intelligence and security services/institutions as a guideline for better reporting to the relevant state institutions and the public.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.1.1: CSOs and Media report improved understanding of intelligence sector reforms, accountability requirements and police integrity. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Baseline #3.1.1: CSOs and Media are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge and skills on intelligence sector reforms and accountability requirements, and police integrity to do monitoring and assessments of intelligence and law enforcement sector reforms.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-04-26"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-04-28"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #3.1.2: by 2023, 5 trainings/workshops delivered to CSOs and Media. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Between 26-28 April 2023 in Ohrid, DCAF organised a Multistakeholder Workshop on “Reconciling Parliamentary Oversight and Civilian Oversight over Intelligence and Security”. This was a joint workshop that brought together MPs and parliamentary staff of the three parliamentary committees supervising the intelligence and security sector and representatives of local CSOs and media (namely the CSO/media training group involved in the DCAF-led series of capacity building activities) in order to increase understanding of their different roles in ensuring a well-governed intelligence and security sector. Through tailored exercises and a scenario-based simulation, participants had the opportunity to enhance their knowledge of different forms of oversight in line with international human rights standards. In addition, the workshop served as a platform for trust building among oversight actors (Parliamentarians and CSOs/media) and, through a discussion of oversight functions and challenges, will contribute to better oversight practices.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-06-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-06-03"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #3.1.2: by 2023, 5 trainings/workshops delivered to CSOs and Media. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF, as part of building capacity in CSOs and media organisations, organised Training no. 4 on Security Sector Governance and Accountability on the topic “NATO and EU Standards for Security Sector Reform: The Role of Democratic Oversight” from 01-03 June 2023. The training group, consisting of 14 representatives of local CSOs and media organisations, learned how to monitor security sector actor’s and institution’s compliance with NATO and EU standards through expert advice and tailor-made exercises. In addition, through integrated discussions, participants gained insight on the structure of NATO and the EU, the military aspects of security sector reform and the process of defense reform in North Macedonia, and justice and police reform processes in the context of Chapters 23 and 24 of the EU acquis. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="1" aggregation-status="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report July - September 2023</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter_EN_JUL-SEP_2023-20231115011100.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter 9, July - September 2023</narrative>
      </title>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.1 a Amended laws, bi-laws and procedures on intelligence aligned with international principles, gender and human rights obligations, good practice and respecting the diversity of the citizens of the Republic of North Macedonia, adopted by Parliament.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The current law, by-laws and procedures are not suitable to allow for effective oversight of the intelligence services. In addition, legally mandated oversight bodies are functioning but not sufficiently effective. The formal relationship between the Parliament and the Council for Civilian Supervision remains inadequate as a result.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-07-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-09-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2023 North Macedonia has suitable laws, by-laws and procedures (Law on Interception of Communications and other relevant laws;) allowing effective oversight over the intelligence services.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">On 18 July 2023, the Parliament of North Macedonia passed the amendment of the Law on Interception of Communications (LIC) with a 2/3 majority (80 votes in favour). The adoption of the LIC amendment provides a legal basis for the proper functioning of the Council for Civilian Supervision (CCS) and Parliament’s engagement of technical experts to support the Council. DCAF facilitated the amendment process, contributing to the law’s text and assisting to achieve political consensus.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.1.1: DCAF recommendation, including on gender and human rights obligations, taken into consideration as part of the legislative review process.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en"> Current laws do not foster effective oversight. Enhanced legal authority and access to information are required to make oversight effective, in the Macedonian political context. The current law on AR, from 1996, does not sufficiently address increased requirements for intelligence accountability nor the new intelligence sector landscape, with OTA and the new law on intelligence coordination. No law on parliamentary oversight of intelligence exists, allowing for clear oversight powers, roles and effective oversight.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-07-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-09-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025 DCAF has provided recommendations respond to real gaps in law and real problems in implementation.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF provided recommendations on the revision of LIC that was adopted in July 2023. The revision responded to existing gaps in the law and will make the Council for Civilian Supervision better able to function.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.4.2: Inter-institutional Protocols, harmonised Templates and Guidelines for different stages of SIM approval are drafted and submitted for approval by relevant institutions within the criminal justice chain.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en"> Courts and prosecutorial offices have different (sometimes dated, or even contradictory) procedures and templates used in the authorisation of SIM. Harmonisation of practice and exchange of information are not in place to ensure effective authorisation of SIM, in agreement with new legislative provisions and European standards.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-07-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-09-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2022 working groups draft proposals designed to unify and harmonise practice.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF organised the Second Workshop on Conceptualising Procedures for Destroying Data Produced by Special Investigative Measures (SIM) in September 2023. This workshop continued work towards the development of a procedure on data destruction to safeguard citizens’ privacy. Future workshops organised by DCAF will result in the approval of the procedure.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.3.1: Shielded Room and protected workspace constructed in Parliament and equipment installed.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Parliament has no protected workspace and meeting facility to discuss and store classified information, impeding meaningful exchange of sensitive and classified information with security and intelligence services. Parliament, in Feb 2020, approved the establishment of the shielded room. Within its Phase I Programme DCAF allocated funds as a contribution towards the establishment of the Shielded Room and protected workplace. Due to Covid-19 the process was delayed throughout 2020.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-07-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-09-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2021 the Parliament has a Shielded Room and protected space Installed.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continued to support the Assembly for the construction and accreditation of a Shielded Room and protected workspace for handling classified information. The construction, directed by Parliament and supported by DCAF, commenced in July 2023. The process is progressing, and, according to the Construction Action Plan, is expected to be completed by the end of January 2024. In addition, DCAF continues to facilitate the process of producing accreditation documents for the use of the Shielded Room. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.2 a: Increased consistency of judicial practice (prosecutors and judges) in authorization and review of intrusive methods (intrusive methods to be based on law, be non-discriminatory, have a legitimate aim, and be a “necessary” and “proportional” response).</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The ECHR case law is not regularly observed by prosecutors and judges in the request and authorisation of intrusive methods. The judicial practice (interpretation and application of law by prosecutors and judges) in authorization of intrusive methods is still not consistent and adequate. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-07-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-09-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025 judicial practice in authorisation of intrusive methods is more consistent and adequate compared to 2020.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">On 4 July 2023, DCAF organised a Workshop on Developing Methodology for Case-Law Collection on SIMs. A team of three legal advisors from the Basic Criminal Court and Basic Public Prosecution Office and a criminal law professor (the editor of the Collection) agreed on a methodology for developing the Collection of Case-Law on Special Investigative Measures (SIM) in North Macedonia. The team is currently working on identifying cases and extracting relevant information from those selected to compile the Collection. The Collection will serve as a training resource for the Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors and is expected to be used in judicial courses at both entry- and higher-level education. This Collection will complement the Judicial Benchbook, previously developed with DCAF’s support, and facilitate its application to local practice. The Collection will ensure that standards of the European Convention on Human Rights are applied to SIM authorisation in Macedonian proceedings and judicial reasoning.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #1.5.1: Relevant experts from the Ministry of Interior, and other relevant institutions if necessary, are actively engaged in the drafting of normative/legal documents (e.g. regulations, amendments to national laws or by-laws).</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Some normative/legal capacities are already in place. Some of these existing documents will require amendments, while some additional documents might need to be created.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-07-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-09-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">a. By the end of 2022, the necessary normative/legal documents drafted and assessed by selected experts from EU Member States.b. By mid-2023, the normative/legal documents adopted.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">In this period, DCAF organised two workshops on Revising the Interpretation Guideline for Autosomal STR (Short Tandem Repeat) Profiling for a working group from the Forensics Department of the MoI. The working group revised and improved the profiling guidelines, reporting approaches, and methods for interpreting DNA profiles after genotyping. The guidelines were then reviewed by other representatives of the Department. The review was led by the Head of the Unit and discussions centred around best practices and international recommendations and standards on STR profiling, including PCC Prüm requirements related to the storage, processing, and automated exchange of DNA data. DCAF will continue to support the Forensics Department to improve its internal procedures related to DNA data sampling, processing, profiling analysis, interpretation, and exchange. The Guideline is expected to be completed in the next two months, subject to approval and adoption by the MoI.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.8.2 : Employees in the Section for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations and Professional Standards receive training for the purpose of implementing the Integrity Test (use of audio and video equipment for simulated situations).</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Over the last two years DCAF supported the MoI in the development and drafting of the Integrity Plan. Presently, the Integrity Plan is pending approval from the Minister of Interior. The Ministry of Interior (MoI) is amending the law on internal affairs to improve the internal control mechanisms that promote integrity. The new law will include integrity testing measures as a means of internal control, which will be applied to both current and future employees of the MoI. The MoI does not possess technical equipment to perform professional integrity testing, which will be a requirement in accordance to the new Law on Internal Affairs. In addition, the North Macedonian Police have revised their Code of Ethics in 2020.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-07-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-09-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2022 all employees in the SICPS received training on integrity testing.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF organised a working visit for representatives of the internal control department of the Macedonian MoI to the Serbian MoI on the subject of integrity testing. This practical exchange of experiences allowed Macedonian MoI representatives to increase their understanding of possible integrity testing scenarios which will contribute to their ability to design and implement their own tests.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #3.1.1: CSOs and Media report improved understanding of intelligence sector reforms, accountability requirements and police integrity. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">CSOs and Media are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge and skills on intelligence sector reforms and accountability requirements, and police integrity to do monitoring and assessments of intelligence and law enforcement sector reforms.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-07-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-09-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2023, 5 trainings/workshops delivered to CSOs and Media. </narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Between 5 and 7 September 2023 in Berlin, Germany a Working Visit for CSOs, media representatives, and parliamentary staff working on security and intelligence topics, from North Macedonia was organised in cooperation with Stiftung Neue Verantwortung (SNV). The visit enhanced participants’ knowledge and understanding of the role of CSOs and media in democratic oversight through an exchange of experiences with German counterparts. The visit also facilitated networking for the Macedonian representatives. The Working Visit instigated significant discussions regarding what practices in Germany are relevant and applicable in North Macedonia for future civilian oversight of the Macedonian security sector.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator 2.11.1 Recommendations from the Gender Self-Assessment are translated into a Gender Action Plan by the Ministry of Defense.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Within the Ministry of Defence (MoD), despite of the existing gender-sensitive policies, which have so far made significant progress in terms of gender responsiveness of the institution, there is still no evidence-based research on the degree of progress in enhancing gender-responsive practices, as well as on the potential gaps and weaknesses in the domain of the gender mainstreaming.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-07-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-09-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025, a Gender Action Plan is developed for the Ministry of Defense and the Army.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF proceeded with activities that are part of the Gender Self-Assessment (GSA) process in the Ministry of Defence (MoD) and the Army of North Macedonia. The field research that began in May 2023 was finalised at the end September 2023. The field research consisted of interviews with key leaders from the MoD and the Army, focus groups with MoD and Army personnel, and surveys conducted with a representative sample of the MoD and Army staff. A series of focus groups with MoD and Army personnel focused on different subject matters related to gender mainstreaming were conducted in various barracks in North Macedonia. The survey (consisting of closed and open-ended questions) was disseminated both online and with hard copies throughout different military units. In the next period, the data collected will be analysed by experts with contribution from the MoD’s Working Group (WG), to identify gaps and weaknesses in the MoD and Army’s structures regarding gender equality as well as opportunities and entry points for gender mainstreaming.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Indicator #2.3: The Ministry of Interior of North Macedonia (MoI) has strategic and operational capacity to effectively build integrity in line with European values and good policing practice, enabling more effective oversight. </narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The Section for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations, and Professional Standards (SICPS), in cooperation with DCAF, developed an Integrity Plan over the past three years. The Plan assesses the corruption risk of all job positions in the Ministry of Interior, in accordance with the Rulebook on systematization of job positions in the MoI, proposing measures aimed to reduce risk. </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2023-07-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2023-09-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By end of the programme the MoI (SICPS) is successfully implementing the Integrity Plan</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF organised a Meeting of the Working Group (WG) for Developing a Curricula for Training Courses on Police Integrity on 15 September 2023. The WG is comprised of representatives of the Department for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations, and Professional Standards and the Police Training Centre and is supported by DCAF and trainers from the MoI participating in an OSCE project focused on hybrid training. During the meeting, the WG developed curricula for conducting training courses for police officers in different organisational units of the MoI identified as most vulnerable to corruption. The curricula has been submitted to the Minister of Interior for approval. The presence of integrity training curricula will allow the trainings planned in the Integrity Plan to be implemented in a sustainable and uniform way.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report: July - September 2025</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter-17_EN_JUL-SEP-2025-20251110021131.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Programme newsletter July-September 2025</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly activity reporting: July-September 2025</narrative>
      </description>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2025-11-07"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 3.3. M&amp;E independent expert group - Indicator #3.3.1: Independent working group produce meaningful monitoring reports.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_X8NIvSOZjk" format="video/vnd.sealed.mpeg4">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Opening of a Shielded Room in the Parliament: why is it important?</narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Mini-documentary story </narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="mk"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2024-11-01"/>
      </document-link>
      <document-link url="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L92NWFZUOvk" format="video/vnd.sealed.mpeg4">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Who will protect the Ombudsperson's right to oversee the work of the police sector and intelligence services?</narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Mini-documentary story </narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="mk"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2024-10-01"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The annual report of public prosecutor is the only source of information about use of SIM (number or requests and number of approved warrants) in criminal investigation. There is no publicly available information allowing an assessment of the use of SIM and judicial authorisation of SIM. Last report published was in 2018.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-08-22"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-09-19"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">At least one monitoring report per year produced and shared with public and relevant institutions.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continued with the research initiative to enhance transparency and accountability in the use of Special Investigative Measures (SIMs) during the summer period, and focused on finalising the content of the assessment report in cooperation with the Academy of Judges and Public Prosecutors and the judiciary group. On 22 August 2025 a focus group with criminal investigators was held to discuss their investigative practices and perspectives related to SIMs usage and to propose improvements to the investigative flow and institutional coordination. DCAF organised the final workshop with the judiciary group from 17 to 19 September 2025 in Ohrid to review the drafted research paper with set of conclusions and recommendations. This research process, based on DCAF’s Methodology guidelines for systematic monitoring and evaluation of SIMs usage, will help the AJPP conduct bi-annual assessment on this topic. By the end of the year, the report findings will be promoted to showcase the comprehensive conclusions and recommendations from the first systematised assessment in a decade on how Special Investigative Measures are lawfully approved, implemented, and overseen within the judiciary.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 3.1 CSOs and Media - Indicator #3.1.2: By the first half of 2025, the mentored group of journalists develop journalist curriculum on informal oversight over the security/intelligence sector.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">In North Macedonia, there is still no specialised curriculum at university programs for journalists on reporting security matters.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-09-29"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-09-30"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Several workshops/meetings conducted for preparation of the curriculum by the end of 2025.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF and Goce Delčev University in Štip (UGD) completed the micro-qualification curriculum on Security Sector Governance and Oversight, intended to be accredited as part of UGD’s specialized professional offerings. To this end, DCAF organised the third and final Curriculum Development Workshop from 29 to 30 September 2025 in Shtip to finalize, refine and validate the proposed academic programme by incorporating perspectives from civil society and media representatives. The collaboration between the UGD professors and the civil society and media representatives ensures that the curriculum not only meets university standards but also reflects the needs of practitioners and society. By involving dedicated counterparts and launching the Security Sector Governance and Oversight academic programme next year, DCAF will leave sustainable legacy to be continued by the younger generations.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.1 All institutions - Indicator #2.1.1: Regular multi-stakeholder meetings and joint trainings/workshops are held and are attended by a gender-diverse group from all relevant institutions.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Insufficient cooperation between intelligence/security services and legally mandated oversight actors.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-07-02"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-07-04"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Each multi-stakeholder event has at least 30% female participation.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Recognizing the need for oversight to include ongoing scrutiny and evaluation of security-related laws, as well as the importance of networking and sharing experiences, DCAF continued with the second multi-stakeholder workshop on “Post-Legislative Scrutiny of Security Laws and Policies” held from 2 to 4 July 2025 in Gevgelija. As a continuation of the first event, the second workshop brought again MPs, representatives of civil society, the media, and the Ombudsperson’s office to discuss and deepen their understanding of post-legislative scrutiny as a tool for ensuring democratic oversight of security laws and policies. The workshop focused on how different oversight actors can collaborate to assess the implementation, impact, and continued relevance of security-related legislation and discussed the impact assessment of security laws, oversight responsibilities, and best practices in drafting policy briefs and reports on post-legislative scrutiny findings. DCAF will continue to support the purposeful debate and cooperation among different oversight actors.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-07-10"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-07-11"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">80% of invited institutions attend each multi-stakeholder event.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">As part of its ongoing commitment to supporting security and intelligence sector reform, DCAF has been addressing key challenges in the management of classified information from inconsistent classification practices to varying approaches among institutions. To help tackle these challenges, DCAF organized the second multi-institutional workshop titled Institutional Approaches to Information Classification: Challenges and Perspectives from 10 to 11 July 2025 in Veles. By fostering collaboration among experts from various sectors, the workshop sought to promote best practices and exchange of experiences, thus laying the groundwork for a more coherent and coordinated approach to classification. The discussions highlighted the need for unified guidelines and clear criteria for classification, as well as effective internal mechanisms for oversight and verification across all institutions. As an outcome, a working group has been established to develop a comprehensive guidance document on information classification in the forthcoming period. This Classification Guidelines will contribute to standardised application of the legal framework across institutions, consistent information sharing, and improved institutional security and accountability.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.1 All institutions - Indicator #2.1.3: Gender Action Plan developed by MoD based on recommendations in the Gender-Self Assessment report and MoD increases its capacity to implement the Plan.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://www.dcaf.ch/report-gender-self-assessment" format="application/pdf">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Gender Self-Assessment Report</narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Gender Self-Assessment Report of the Ministry of Defence of North Macedonia</narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="en"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2025-05-20"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The MoD does not currently have a specific, evidence-based gender action plan aimed at enhancing gender equality in the institution based on an in-depth institutional gender analysis.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-07-23"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-07-25"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, relevant staff have developed capacities to implement and monitor the Gender Action Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Following the official promotion of the Gender Self-Assessment report and the Gender Action Plan 2024–2028 (GAP) of the Ministry of Defence (MoD), DCAF organized a Workshop for Development of Evaluation, Monitoring, and Reporting Framework in line with the continuous support provided to the Ministry for implementation of the GAP. The workshop took place from 23 to 25 July 2025 in Veles and brought together MoD Working Group (WG) members to jointly define objectives, indicators, data sources, timelines and reporting cycles for structured and evidence-based implementation of the GAP. Through expert facilitation, tailored presentations, and practical exercises, WG members strengthened their understanding of concepts and methodologies in evaluation, monitoring, and reporting based on international best practices for promoting gender equality in the defence sector. Through tailored events, DCAF will continue to build the MoD Working Group’s capacity to track GAP progress, assess impact, and ensure accountability and transparency for gender mainstreaming across the defence sector.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 3.1 CSOs and Media - Indicator #3.1.1: CSOs and Media receive trainings/mentoring programs on intelligence and security sector governance, accountability requirements and police integrity.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">CSOs and Media are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge and skills on intelligence sector reforms and accountability requirements, and police integrity to do monitoring and assessments of intelligence and law enforcement sector </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-09-15"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-09-16"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025, at least 5 capacity building activities per year delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continues the extensive Training of Trainers (ToT) programme that aims to empower civil society organisations and media professionals with advanced knowledge and skills to effectively disseminate information on security sector reform and governance. The sixth ToT session was organized between 15-16 September 2025 in Veles and focused on the leadership in training and theories of internal and external motivation, such as Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs. This initiative aims to strengthen oversight and accountability mechanisms with networking of the civilian and media sectors.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Output 2.9 – DNA and dactyloscopic Exchange - Indicator #2.9.2: Relevant experts from the Ministry of Interior receive mentoring to support them in performing duties.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://jorm.gov.mk/izgotven-vodich-za-nishtene-na-podatoczite-sobrani-so-posebnite-istrazhni-merki/" format="text/plain">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="mk">Guideline on Retention and Destruction of Data Collected by SIMs</narrative>
        </title>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="mk"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2024-12-16"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The EU Member States that are Parties to the PCC Prüm Agreement already have the experience and routine of exchanging data. The Ministry of Interior will during the project identify where such experience/routine from these countries would be of added value.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-08-25"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-08-28"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By mid-2023, all requested mentoring by experts from EU Member States will be provided.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continuously provides support to the MoI Forensics Examinations Department to enhance the normative, organisational, and technical aspects related to automated biometric data processing and exchange under the PCC Prüm framework. Within this framework, DCAF organised a working visit to the Hungarian Institute for Forensic Sciences for national experts from the DNA and Dactyloscopic Laboratories. The visit took place from 25 to 28 August 2025 in Budapest and enabled forensic experts from both countries to exchange practical experiences on fingerprint identification, DNA profiling, and forensic examinations. The visit focused on practical demonstrations of Prüm-related biometric data management using the AFIS and CODIS systems and familiarized participants with Hungary’s best practices in ensuring data accuracy, quality assurance, and the automated exchange of forensic information. Following the visit, the Forensics Examinations Department with DCAF’s support will undertake necessary steps to initiate the official PCC Prüm evaluation for automated DNA and fingerprint data exchange with other parties.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.5 Judiciary_Support to the Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors - Indicator #2.5.1: Judicial practitioners receive training on judicial authorisation of SIM (more concretely on interception of communications), use of European legal standards and principles related to information collection.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://mvr.gov.mk/Upload/Editor_Upload/ENG_%D0%98%D0%97%D0%92%D0%95%D0%A8%D0%A2%D0%90%D0%88%202024.pdf" format="application/pdf">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">2024 Annual Report on implementation of the Integrity Action plan </narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">2024 Report on the Realisation of the Action Plan for Implementing the Integrity Plan of the Ministry of Interior 2023-2025</narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="en"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2025-02-17"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">No training delivered by the Academy on SIM</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-07-09"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-08-08"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">In 2021 most of the judicial practitioners working on criminal cases will undergo in-service training.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">As part of its ongoing capacity-building support to the Academy for Judges and Public Prosecutors (AJPP), DCAF organized a Strategic Planning Workshop on 9 July 2025 in Skopje. The workshop aimed to strengthen participants’ ability to analyse strategic processes and familiarise them with the methodology for developing strategic documents in the field of judicial education. On 10 and 11 July, DCAF continued its support with two additional training courses focused on Training Administration and Communication Skills. These sessions were designed to enhance participants’ understanding of key aspects of Training Cycle Management and effective communication, with the aim of supporting efficient planning, development, and evaluation of training programs for judges and prosecutors. These activities aimed at strengthening the institutional capacities of AJPP to initiate meaningful educational reforms with a strategic outlook.      To further support the judicial training and recruitment reforms led by AJPP, DCAF organised a working visit to the School of Magistrates and other key justice institutions in Tirana, Albania, from 6 to 8 August 2025. The visit contributed to the establishment of a judicial working group tasked to draft amendments to the Law on the Academy that envision enhanced recruitment procedures and entrance examinations, and reforms of the overall training framework in line with EU standards. By observing Albania’s approach to the initial training and recruitment of judges and prosecutors, AJPP representatives gained valuable insights into practical solutions related to governance structures, recruitment models, and curriculum design. These lessons will inform and strengthen the legal reforms underway, helping ensure their effectiveness and alignment with best practices.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.2 Parliament/Oversight bodies - Indicator #2.2.1 - 2.2.3: Committee Members and staffers (female and male) report improved understanding of intelligence oversight matters, and Female committee members and staffers actively participate at DCAF events.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">A baseline survey of the new oversight committees’ MPs will be conducted to assess the level of knowledge and skills in oversight.  Organisational functions of Working Body staff are inadequate and prevent effective performance.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-07-30"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-07-31"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, 70% of the female MPs and staffers have attended organised activities and actively participated.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continues to build the capacities of parliamentary staff in enhancing and institutionalising oversight of intelligence and security and strengthening their abilities to effectively transfer knowledge to Members of Parliament through clear, engaging, and accessible communication. Following the development of a Framework for Communication, Analytical, and Advisory Skills, DCAF organised the third workshop on “Advancing Capacities for Knowledge Transfer with a Focus on Content Visualisation” from 30 to 31 July in Veles. This workshop placed special emphasis on content visualisation techniques, aiming to help parliamentary staff convey information on the importance and mechanisms of oversight in a user-friendly and comprehensible manner. Through content sequencing and feedback, four dedicated staffers practiced application of training delivery methods and techniques and used the opportunity to discuss the update of the communication, analytical and advisory skills manual. DCAF will continue with sustainable capacity-building initiatives for the longstanding staff that supports the work of three Intelligence and Security Committees within the Parliament.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report: October - December 2025</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter-18_EN_OCT-DEC-2025-20260219120259.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly report: October-December 2025</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter no. 18 of the Intelligence and Security Sector Reform Programme in the Republic of North Macedonia (2021-2026)</narrative>
      </description>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2026-02-19"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 3.3. M&amp;E independent expert group - Indicator #3.3.1: Independent working group produce meaningful monitoring reports.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_X8NIvSOZjk" format="video/vnd.sealed.mpeg4">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Opening of a Shielded Room in the Parliament: why is it important?</narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Mini-documentary story </narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="mk"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2024-11-01"/>
      </document-link>
      <document-link url="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L92NWFZUOvk" format="video/vnd.sealed.mpeg4">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Who will protect the Ombudsperson's right to oversee the work of the police sector and intelligence services?</narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Mini-documentary story </narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="mk"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2024-10-01"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The annual report of public prosecutor is the only source of information about use of SIM (number or requests and number of approved warrants) in criminal investigation. There is no publicly available information allowing an assessment of the use of SIM and judicial authorisation of SIM. Last report published was in 2018.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-10-21"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-26"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">At least one monitoring report per year produced and shared with public and relevant institutions.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF finalised the research initiative to enhance transparency and accountability in the use of Special Investigative Measures (SIMs) following a series of workshops, focus groups, interviews and drafting sessions conducted in the past several months in cooperation with the Academy of Judges and Public Prosecutors (AJPP) and the judiciary group. On 21 October 2025 a coordination workshop with the judiciary group was held in Skopje to review the final text, findings and recommendations of the comprehensive analysis report titled ‘Application of Special Investigative Measures in the Republic of North Macedonia’. The workshop aimed to collect final comments and remarks, harmonize views, and revise any potentially overlooked elements before publication. On 25 December 2025, DCAF organised a coordination meeting with the judges to discuss lessons learned from the sustained research process, and plan for a promotion event in 2026. This research process, which is based on DCAF’s Methodology guidelines for systematic monitoring and evaluation of SIMs usage, will serve as a baseline to monitor progress and will help the AJPP conduct such bi-annual assessments on their own. DCAF will promote this systematised assessment with 16 recommendations for improvement of judicial practice at a roundtable discussion on how Special Investigative Measures are lawfully approved, implemented, and overseen within the judiciary.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.1 All institutions - Indicator #2.1.1: Regular multi-stakeholder meetings and joint trainings/workshops are held and are attended by a gender-diverse group from all relevant institutions.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Insufficient cooperation between intelligence/security services and legally mandated oversight actors.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-11-03"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-19"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">80% of invited institutions attend each multi-stakeholder event.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continued with the support of the intelligence agencies and in the past period has organized several multi-institutional workshops on classified information management. In November and December 2025, DCAF held several meetings with the multi-institutional working group tasked to develop comprehensive Classification Guidelines that will be applicable in all intelligence institutions. The guidelines will outline standardised classification criteria, normative framework, and effective internal mechanisms for oversight and verification across institutions. DCAF will continue with the discussions and guidelines development to achieve improved institutional security and accountability through consistent information sharing.All invited institutions attended the organised events.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-12-03"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-05"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Each multi-stakeholder event has at least 30% female participation.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continued to rely on multi-stakeholder workshops to build trust and institutional connectivity among oversight actors. The multi-stakeholder workshop “New Technologies and Oversight”, held between 3-5 December 2025 in Gevgelija, brought together MPs, representatives of civil society, the media, and the Ombudsperson’s office to explore how emerging and rapidly evolving technologies are reshaping the landscape of security governance and democratic oversight. The workshop examined the legal, political, and strategic implications of new technologies, the evolving landscape of digital and hybrid threats, and the challenges posed by mass surveillance, profiling, and data-driven decision-making. The participants discussed how different oversight actors can collaborate to safeguard fundamental rights, especially the right to privacy, and ensure that technological and AI innovations used by security institutions remain transparent, accountable, and democratically governed. In the upcoming period, DCAF will continue to use multi-stakeholder formats to strengthen dialogue and build durable networks among diverse oversight actors.This multi-stakeholder event had 44% female participation.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.1 All institutions - Indicator #2.1.3: Gender Action Plan developed by MoD based on recommendations in the Gender-Self Assessment report and MoD increases its capacity to implement the Plan.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://www.dcaf.ch/report-gender-self-assessment" format="application/pdf">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Gender Self-Assessment Report</narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Gender Self-Assessment Report of the Ministry of Defence of North Macedonia</narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="en"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2025-05-20"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The MoD does not currently have a specific, evidence-based gender action plan aimed at enhancing gender equality in the institution based on an in-depth institutional gender analysis.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-10-01"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-15"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, relevant staff have developed capacities to implement and monitor the Gender Action Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Within the framework of the continuous support provided to the Ministry of Defence (MoD) for implementation of the Gender Action Plan 2024–2028 (GAP), between October and December 2025 DCAF held a series of meetings with the MoD working group to operationalize planned activities in support of GAP implementation. A key initial step was the conceptualization of a Manual for Gender Trainers, envisioned to provide a unified methodology and content framework for four core training areas: basic gender training for all MoD and Army personnel; gender training for management and command staff; gender training for pre-deployment personnel; and training on gender mainstreaming in military exercises. DCAF will continue to support the MoD in the development and implementation of information and awareness-raising campaigns, as well as in strengthening institutional capacities for training delivery, coordination, and sustainability of the gender mainstreaming framework.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 3.1 CSOs and Media - Indicator #3.1.1: CSOs and Media receive trainings/mentoring programs on intelligence and security sector governance, accountability requirements and police integrity.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">CSOs and Media are not sufficiently equipped with knowledge and skills on intelligence sector reforms and accountability requirements, and police integrity to do monitoring and assessments of intelligence and law enforcement sector </narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-10-30"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-29"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By 2025, at least 5 capacity building activities per year delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continued with the extensive Training of Trainers (ToT) programme designed for civil society organizations and media professionals. The seventh ToT session that took place between 30-31 October 2025 in Veles focused on visualization theories and techniques, especially how to effectively use presentation tools and to deliver clear and compelling messages. The eight and final ToT session, held between 26-27 December 2025 in Skopje, centred on the importance of training evaluation as a means to measure learning outcomes, behaviour change, and institutional impact. This training initiative aimed to empower civil society organizations and media professionals with advanced knowledge and skills to effectively disseminate information on security sector reform and governance across their organizations and networks, while further strengthening oversight and accountability mechanisms. In 2026, DCAF will engage these certified trainers as expert contributors to the postgraduate micro-qualification programme accredited at the University Goce Delčev - Štip thus ensuring continuity and sustainability of the initiative.This quarter, 2 capacity building activities were delivered to CSOs and Media.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.2 Parliament/Oversight bodies - Indicator #2.2.1 - 2.2.3: Committee Members and staffers (female and male) report improved understanding of intelligence oversight matters, and Female committee members and staffers actively participate at DCAF events.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">A baseline survey of the new oversight committees’ MPs will be conducted to assess the level of knowledge and skills in oversight.  Organisational functions of Working Body staff are inadequate and prevent effective performance.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-10-03"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-11-25"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, 70% of the female MPs and staffers have attended organised activities and actively participated.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continued to support parliamentary staff in enhancing and institutionalizing oversight of intelligence and security. After several targeted trainings and two workshops on Developing a Framework for Communication, Analytical, and Advisory Skills, DCAF organized several advanced-level workshops in October and November 2025 to further strengthen the knowledge transfer and communication skills of parliamentary staff to be able to provide effective support to MPs through advice and training. These workshops aimed to continuously strengthen the capacity of parliamentary staff to effectively analyse security-related information, provide strategic advice, and communicate oversight findings in a clear and compelling manner. These interactive sessions also prompted peer learning and cross-institutional exchange of practical experiences.This quarter, 75% of the female staffers have attended organised activities and actively participated.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-11-17"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-11-20"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, 70% of the female MPs and staffers have attended organised activities and actively participated.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Furthermore, DCAF organized a Parliamentary Working Visit from 17 to 20 November 2025 in Berlin for a parliamentary delegation led by the Secretary General of the Macedonian Assembly. The visit aimed at deepening parliamentary staff’s understanding of Germany’s comprehensive and multi-layered intelligence oversight system and included exchanges with members of the Bundestag, advisors on intelligence oversight, the G10 Commission, and the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection. These discussions provided comparative insights into institutional design, governance, legislative frameworks, and practical oversight approaches. The visit supported the professional development of parliamentary officials and staff, helping them reflect on how German practices can inform and strengthen parliamentary oversight over intelligence and security in North Macedonia. Participants also had the opportunity to join an organized tour of the Bundestag.This quarter, 75% of the female staffers have attended organised activities and actively participated.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.8 – MoI – DICCIPS integrity testing: Capacity building activities (trainings/study visits and expert support, technical equipment) provided to the “Section for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations and Professional Standards (DICCIPS)” to effectively implement the MoI Action Plan on police integrity and perform investigations.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Over the last two years DCAF supported the MoI in the development and drafting of the Integrity Plan. Presently, the Integrity Plan is pending approval from the Minister of Interior. The Ministry of Interior (MoI) is amending the law on internal affairs to improve the internal control mechanisms that promote integrity. The new law will include integrity testing measures as a means of internal control, which will be applied to both current and future employees of the MoI. The MoI does not possess technical equipment to perform professional integrity testing, which will be a requirement in accordance to the new Law on Internal Affairs. In addition, the North Macedonian Police have revised their Code of Ethics in 2020.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2025-11-06"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2025-12-29"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, 80% of DICCIPS employees report increasing their capacities for conducting criminal and disciplinary investigations.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF provides continuous support to the MoI Department for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations and Professional Standards and implements targeted capacity-building initiatives in the area of criminal investigations focusing on strengthening the analytical and investigative competencies of Internal Control officers. In November and December 2025, DCAF organised two specialised trainings that aimed to enhance the Internal Control Department’s institutional and operational capacities for detecting, analysing, and documenting corruption and other criminal offences committed by police officers. The Training on Financial Investigations and Analysis was held from 6 to 7 November 2025 in Skopje and aimed to strengthen participants skills in tracing financial flows, identifying illicit enrichment, and improving inter-agency cooperation in financial crime investigations. The sessions offered practical application of learned skills through case studies, as participants made in-depth analysis of financial documentation, and traced assets acquired through illegal means in order to build a strong case against corrupted police officers. DCAF organised the second Training on Criminal Investigations of Crimes Committed by Police Officers for the Internal Control Department from 11 to 12 December 2025 in Skopje. This highly interactive training held with public prosecutors, judges, criminal investigators and a lawyer offered Internal Control Officers different perspectives into conducting criminal investigations against police officers and focused on enhancing evidence gathering, timely processes and cooperation with the prosecution while ensuring accountability and respect for human rights. The sessions included analysing trends of police misconduct, particularly excessive use of force, harassment, and evidence tempering, and joint discussions on preventive measures and sustaining lawful and ethical police behaviour. DCAF will continue delivering a multifaced format of trainings to the Internal Control Department to support their transparent efforts in promoting integrity in the police service.To further promote institutional accountability and integrity, on 9 and 10 December 2025, the Ministry of Interior hosted an official delegation from the Republic of Moldova National Public Security Inspectorate for a peer exchange on integrity, internal control, and good governance practices within the security sector. Supported by DCAF Skopje and Chisinau Offices, this working visit on police integrity aimed to facilitate professional dialogue, exchange of experiences, and sharing of practical approaches to strengthening integrity systems, internal oversight mechanisms, and accountability processes in law enforcement institutions.DCAF continuously provided guidance and sustainable support in all phases of implementation, monitoring, and evaluation of the MoI Integrity Plan 2023-2025, and aiming to assess the final year of its implementation, organized a workshop for drafting the 2025 Annual Progress Report on 29 December 2025 in Skopje. The workshop gathered a dedicated working group from the Internal Control Department which assumed full ownership of the drafting process and remains committed to embedding integrity as an institutional value. DCAF will support the working group in the development of the second Professional Integrity Plan of the Ministry for the next three years based on the goals, principles, and methodology applied during the development of the first Integrity Plan while ensuring the sustainability of the proposed anti-corruption measures.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
  <result type="1">
    <title>
      <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report: January - March 2026</narrative>
    </title>
    <document-link url="https://aidstream.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/documents/North_Macedonia_Newsletter-19_EN_JAN-MAR-2026-20260603080628.pdf" format="application/pdf">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Quarterly Report: January - March 2026</narrative>
      </title>
      <description>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">Newsletter 19: January - March 2026</narrative>
      </description>
      <category code="A08"/>
      <language code="en"/>
      <document-date iso-date="2026-06-01"/>
    </document-link>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.1 All institutions - Indicator #2.1.1: Regular multi-stakeholder meetings and joint trainings/workshops are held and are attended by a gender-diverse group from all relevant institutions.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Insufficient cooperation between intelligence/security services and legally mandated oversight actors.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-02-02"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-27"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">80% of invited institutions attend each multi-stakeholder event.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Following an inclusive multi-agency process with a working group consisting of intelligence and security practitioners, the Guidelines for Classification of Information were drafted by the end of 2025, outlining standardised classification criteria, normative framework, and effective internal mechanisms for oversight and verification across all intelligence and security institutions. In February and March 2026, DCAF organised two coordination meetings with the working group to finalize the text and plan the next step of the process. This collaborative process chaired by the Directorate for Security of Classified Information resulted in production of a coherent document that harmonises approaches for improved institutional security through consistent information sharing. The official promotion of the Guidelines is expected in the first half of June and will mark an important milestone in accountable and transparent handling of classified information by all security sector actors. Following its publication, DCAF will support duly implementation of the Guidelines for Classification of Information by the partner institutions. All invited institutions attended the organised events.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.1 All institutions - Indicator #2.1.3: Gender Action Plan developed by MoD based on recommendations in the Gender-Self Assessment report and MoD increases its capacity to implement the Plan.</narrative>
      </title>
      <document-link url="https://www.dcaf.ch/report-gender-self-assessment" format="application/pdf">
        <title>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Gender Self-Assessment Report</narrative>
        </title>
        <description>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Gender Self-Assessment Report of the Ministry of Defence of North Macedonia</narrative>
        </description>
        <category code="A08"/>
        <language code="en"/>
        <document-date iso-date="2025-05-20"/>
      </document-link>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">The MoD does not currently have a specific, evidence-based gender action plan aimed at enhancing gender equality in the institution based on an in-depth institutional gender analysis.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-02-24"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-25"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, relevant staff have developed capacities to implement and monitor the Gender Action Plan.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF continuously supports the Ministry of Defense and the Army of North Macedonia in their efforts to implement the Gender Action Plan (2024–2028). As part of the activities outlined in the GAP, a modular Training of Trainers (ToT) was developed to strengthen institutional capacities for the prevention and protection against workplace harassment. This training process is designed to expand the capacities of selected personnel to deliver gender-sensitive trainings on harassment prevention and response within their respective institution. The first Module of the ToT on Workplace Harassment Protection, held between 24 - 27 February 2026 in Strumica, covered types of workplace harassment, understanding and recognition of harassment in the workplace, international standards and good practices, as well as the roots and driving factors of harassment in military and defense institutions. The training also addressed the legal framework, procedures, and internal mechanisms for prevention, suppression, and protection from harassment within the Ministry of Defense and the Army. Additionally, participants were introduced to gender-sensitive language, terminology, and approaches to be used during these types of trainings. The second module of the ToT, conducted from 23 to 25 March 2026 in Veles, centred on gender perspectives and intersectionality, foundations of andragogy and learning styles, training design and preparation, facilitation techniques, participatory approaches, and effective training delivery. The ToT sessions included practical exercises in which participants practiced delivering training in front of a live audience, where they had opportunity to apply newly acquired knowledge. The ultimate goal of the ToT process is to establish mobile training teams within the MoD and the Army, capable of supporting personnel in recognizing, preventing, and appropriately responding to workplace harassment.  Advancing capacities of 14 MoD gender trainers.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
    <indicator measure="5" ascending="1" aggregation-status="1">
      <title>
        <narrative xml:lang="en">OUTPUT 2.8 – MoI – DICCIPS integrity testing: Capacity building activities (trainings/study visits and expert support, technical equipment) provided to the “Section for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations and Professional Standards (DICCIPS)” to effectively implement the MoI Action Plan on police integrity and perform investigations.</narrative>
      </title>
      <baseline year="2021">
        <comment>
          <narrative xml:lang="en">Over the last two years DCAF supported the MoI in the development and drafting of the Integrity Plan. Presently, the Integrity Plan is pending approval from the Minister of Interior. The Ministry of Interior (MoI) is amending the law on internal affairs to improve the internal control mechanisms that promote integrity. The new law will include integrity testing measures as a means of internal control, which will be applied to both current and future employees of the MoI. The MoI does not possess technical equipment to perform professional integrity testing, which will be a requirement in accordance to the new Law on Internal Affairs. In addition, the North Macedonian Police have revised their Code of Ethics in 2020.</narrative>
        </comment>
      </baseline>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-03-02"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-05"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">By the end of 2025, 80% of DICCIPS employees report increasing their capacities for conducting criminal and disciplinary investigations.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">DCAF supports and monitors the implementation of the MoI integrity framework since 2022 and continues to enhance capacities of MoI Internal control officers to instigate preventive anti-corruption measures and further promote the professional integrity within the organisation. Thus, from 2 to 5 March 2026, DCAF organised a working visit to the Estonian Police and Border Guard Board in Tallinn for representatives of the MoI Department for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations and Professional Standards to be familiarized with integrity management processes and practices of a highly digitalised EU country. The aim of the visit was to exchange experiences and good practices on prevention and detection of corruption, strengthening internal control mechanisms, transparent investigation processes and coordination between competent institutions. The counterparts compared the organization and functioning of the internal control system in both police services and discussed the application of modern digital solutions in case management, transparency in actions, and preventive mechanisms to reduce corruption risks. This working visit contributed to envisioning applicable approaches to enhance the efficiency of the internal control mechanisms outlined in the new integrity plan based on best European practices.  </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
      <period>
        <period-start iso-date="2026-03-25"/>
        <period-end iso-date="2026-03-26"/>
        <target>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">Target #2.8.1 (b): By the end of 2026, 80% of DICCIPS employees report increasing their capacities for conducting criminal and disciplinary investigations.</narrative>
          </comment>
        </target>
        <actual>
          <comment>
            <narrative xml:lang="en">On 25 March 2026 in Skopje, DCAF organised the official promotion of the new Professional Integrity Plan 2026-2028 of the MoI. The development of this document represents a key milestone toward increased transparency and accountability in law enforcement and offers a holistic platform for reducing potential risks of corruption among police officers, guided by the MoI Department for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations and Professional Standards. The MoI Professional Integrity Plan 2026-2028 was developed utilizing established methodologies, rigorous analysis and data collected from previous annual implementation reports supported by DCAF. The new plan outlines seven risk areas for potential corrupted behaviour and has an embedded action plan with preventive measures, capacity building initiatives and control mechanisms. By launching the new Professional Integrity Plan 2026-2028 to the wider audience, the MoI Department for Internal Control, Criminal Investigations and Professional Standards assumed full ownership of its integrity framework and highlighted the ‘MoI goal for zero corruption in the police’ and accountable policing for all citizens. DCAF will continue to support the MoI in the implementation of the set action plan in the next three years.  </narrative>
          </comment>
        </actual>
      </period>
    </indicator>
  </result>
</iati-activity>
</iati-activities>